The last three four pages of this thread should be ample evidence to anyone that debating Talpa and Rob is completely useless.
Mr. S, your post (page 34, #640
LINK) is one of the best refutes the detractor's thinking on the subject personified by Rob/Talpa. It was a pleasure to read for its perfect myth busting and relevance over a topic that has been debated for years. Yet, pages and pages later, it has failed to persuade said detractors into conceded their folly. The reason is NOT because the evidence doesn't support it, but because we are simply debating people incapable of following elementary logic and analysis. You certainly painted them into a corner, and notice how they simply disregarded it as irrelevant, even though it actually is exactly the crux of the point. They don't see it, and they are incapable of seeing it. It is completely useless debating these fools. We debate them because we see them type words, so we are tricked into thinking they are capable following simple logic, but I repeat, this is a fallacy! We are the wrong ones for thinking they (Talps, Rob, etal) can follow a debate to its logical conclusion.
This should be a warning to all those here attempting to debate Talps & Rob etal. Ask yourself this question, would you be so fervent in your post formulation if you knew you were debating a typical child or a mentally incapacitated person? I imagine not. Its the same thing I must remind myself when debating these two and others they represent. They've learned to type words, but without the necessary meaning and logic to have meaningful debate and dialogue. Its really that simple gentz. I will add though, that the value of reading the well formulated posts which have refuted the Stoner detractors here have been a pleasure to read. The value for me is the knowledge and evidence it compiles and the beauty of its logic. This I'm sure is the same for others who have read it and understand it.
For any more debate on the subject of power/speed advantage regarding Stoner vs the world while on a Ducati, I will refer to this
LINK.
--A post which basically highlights the statements by two world champions who would be in the best and unique position to know, Capirossi (a Ducati rider and once teammate to Stoner) and Rossi, the standard (a Ducati rider currently on Stoner's bike) stating in no uncertain terms that it is in fact the ability and capacity of Casey Stoner, as a rider, and rider of the Ducati to account for its performance while stating they cannot duplicate as of yet this unique Stoner phenomena.
