<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Jumkie @ Jul 21 2009, 05:38 AM)
<{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Actually, personal insult is what is happening now, I though meaningful counterpoint would be more meaningful.
Totally agree but what appears to be happenning of late is that meaningful rebuttal results in more ammunition for personal insult as the discussion continues and I am somewhat over it and see no point in the personal insults (irrespectove of their 'side'). The shame for me is Jumkie that often a very valid point, argument or post will be lost amongst these insults that seem to be over-running most threads of late.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Jumkie @ Jul 21 2009, 05:38 AM)
<{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Oh, I mistook you for a Stoner fan. Sorry.
Nope, and in truth a fair way from it (in what I would term a fan) although I marvel at the way he rides a bike. That said I can easily see why people may assume it as I do come to teh 'defence' of Stoner but that is because I am a fan of racing and personalities mean little to me in terms of my respect for these athletes. Personally I do feel that CS gets a harsh rap far beyond that which is deserved and so I defend, as I would Max B were I a member at the time and as I will JL as I see he being the next with the target on the back.
If I am to be nailed down, my faves are the likes of Doohan, Rainey, Lawson, Spencer with a distinct liking of McCoy (have met - fantastic guy) and believe it or not Max B (we are talking GP only). Outside of GP I have a strong like for Bayliss (obviously) as well as a number of lesser names probably never really known on the world stage.
Admiration, well I strongly admire (and not sucking up) Hayden who for me and with total respect to the guy is one of the lesser lights of the world stage. He won a WC by accumulating the most points which is what a championship is about) but because he did not win many races he is for some reason treated as a 'lucky leper' (leper only added because it starts with L and flows with lucky
).
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Jumkie @ Jul 21 2009, 05:38 AM)
<{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Again, no they are not silent, that's my point, and except for a few, most of the counterpoints are weak. We all gloat (well except the Hayden fans, since we have nothing to gloat about Errr) but, even then there are easy rebuts when it goes beyond the "gloating". Saying your guy (who ever that may be) is the best every, well that's gloating, saying the competition uses more TC because one listened to the bike going past at 100mph plus, well that not gloating and easily refuted. See the difference?
Oh well, its not for me to say. Defend your guy if your able and willing I guess.
By silient I refer to the persons that I consider as contributing worthwhile discussion points and do notice now that Michael has posted a great reply. I readily see that the usual suspects have replied in kind to similar comments from 'the other side' and so the game continues with shot and return of serve, but sadly the game lacks the game ending counterpoints.
As for gloating, maybe we use different meanings as my interpretation and intent was a none to subtle dig at the continued 'over the top' abusive type of gloat and not that which you refer in Hayden terms (or the BS/Opinion type as per your example). Maybe I should have chosen different words or terminology but wanted to avoid the use of words that seem to illicit the level and type of comment that I find so repetitive and draining to read (until you get the good posts).
As for CS, there is little to defend just as there is little reason as he remains third in the title chase and within reach of a title, whetehr that is realistic is the matter as teh Yamaha package at the moment seems far superior but time will tell. As for defending at personal insult level, I have and will continue to do so but again, it drains and eventually one can only make the same point so many times.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Jumkie @ Jul 21 2009, 05:38 AM)
<{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>EDIT:
After reading some of the posts after yours Garry, I'm happy to see some of the Aussies coming to life. Excellent.
Absolutely but I am not so sure they are all Aussies, but yes they do have more fight than I do at the moment.
PS. Don't give up on Hayden as he has looked good of late and whilst he may not win another WC or even race, I suspect that he will remain a strong force and dare I say it, very worthy and welcome #2 at Ducati.
Garry