Gaz, this is your reasoning? Gaz, bro, I get the Aussies are, as Kropo said, in mourning (with good reason) but come on gentz, get a grip (easy for me to say, its not Hayden retiring).
Hayden will never retire mate, he will be there and around for years to some until another likable American is found that is teased with possibilities but only really a small part player in the larger game.
WTF. "very debatable"? WTF?!? There is NOTHING debatable about not honoring your contract! Vinales has been deservingly lambasted for having a hissy fit and not doing right thing by riding at Sepang; you think Casey would be justified in shitcanning his word, obligations, and contract over his feelings about the league? Again there is nothing debatable about what you propose. I'm laughing at you even suggesting it.
I do not propose it, but simply would not be surprised if it occurred.
What is debatable is whether people agree that it is admirable or acceptable, or whether people feel it is unacceptable and as I said afterwards, for me when you make a commitment you stick with it. Simple.
Would it mean that I would demonise him should he do it, no way as I actually enjoy the no BS, no ..... given attitude that he possesses and would say that if others had the same mentality (or degrees thereof0 than maybe the sport would not be in the position in which it finds itself/
Who is projecting the "admirable tone", you buddy. Despite you saying you wouldn't approve, the message you are sending is that somehow Casey has been screwed enough that it might (debatable) be ok for him to fail to honor his commitment as some statement. What exactly would that "statement" be? Goat is right on this one (a rare thing indeed) that nothing good could come of something so extremely silly of which you suggest.
Read much into a statement Jums?
It is a one line state where I said that I would not be surprised FFS, nowhere does it say that I admire nor hope he does it (although I would in some way love to see the look on Ezpeletas face at season end when Stoner has his final press conference)
Edit: Sorry, I have to add more, this suggestion is just too ....... silly. Ok, Gaz (and those agreeing with this prediction), have you stopped to think what that would mean for his team that he expresses so much love for, to leave them out of the cold for a race because he as in individual wanted to make some statement (which I am confused exactly what that would be)? He has a contract with HRC. And every time I see him around Nakamoto, it looks like they are in a perpetual hug. He would be dishonoring his contract with HRC, not to mention possibly destroying any good future relations he might have with the brand. Jesus, you know, I'll just stop, God knows I could go on a 8000+ word essay about how your suggestion is so wrong.
I have thought about the team and that alone is the reason why he should ride, nevere mind any other BS that may be around.
As for my suggestion being wrong, and Jums I do know that you often type for effect, attention and as somewhat of a troll, but why is everyone whom has a different opinion wrong (and feel free to type 8000 words, I am an Aussie and give up reading after 150 as that is all our brain can handle)
As I watched FP1&2, the best commentary quote of the day was, "Will they come within a second of Casey Stoner." I think that is FU enough.
Absolutely.
He wants to go out of PI with a bang and it is the sheer fact that it is PI that has my attention as to the possibility of his upping and going if he wins (afterall, from what I have read many times on many forums, his leaving will help the fans of the sport)
my offer still stands. $100 says that Casey will be at Valencia. And I'll add, if he is capable of winning it, he will. Bet?
If Stoner can win it he will, simple.
I do not see him settling at PI for anything other than the top step of the podium and on the bet, despite what you read I agree that he will be there but guess that I am not allowed to have a thought that he may not.