German GP 23

MotoGP Forum

Help Support MotoGP Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Thought it was a good race, Bags running a good thinking man’s race trying to conserve the tire but that touch on Martin’s back wheel broke the momentum. Good for Martin, he withstood the pressure.

I missed it, what happened to Binder? In any case, another podium for Zarco but when or can he win one? Would love to see it but sometimes a guy just can’t get there. His personal history working against him and there are a lot of hungry riders on the same bike.

After yesterday, I thought MM was going to try and finish the race but went missing from the lineup this morning. Oh well. When all is said and done, yes the Honda is a .... bike, BUT it went to .... on his watch. The ..... in the armor being his inability to help continue to develop the bike both before and after Lorenzo was injured. Some will say he hasn’t been around much to do that but he wasn’t doing it before he got hurt, which was entirely his doing. Too long a spell at Honda without another competitive rider. Things went went downhill there after Pedrosa was let go.

At Yamaha things are hardly better. Fabs also responsible for no development at Yamaha. He inherited a winning bike but failed to make it better. Again, lack of a competitive teammate didn’t help.

Now how much of all that is due to both factories either pinching pennies or just failing in the engineering department I suspect we will never really know. For each team, failing to secure another competitive rider didn’t help in the long run.

Ah well, the Ducati cup it is. At least it was a close race this morning.
It went to .... while he was injured an unable to test. I have said in the past his ability to ride around problems does not make him a good test rider. They need a pedro type rider for that. Bradl is not that guy.
 
Big call blaming two world champs for being unable to develop the bike.
You don't think the European companies haven't poured a heap of money in and been responsible for the developments that have put their bikes ahead? Aero and ride height being 2 fairly big ones.
You may also argue the loss of their ecu hasn't helped Honda with an engine that was designed around it. Yamaha aren't spending too much and are the only ones running an inline 4.
They are both miles behind. Put anyone else in there and do we see rider development bringing them back to the front anytime soon?
 
Big call blaming two world champs for being unable to develop the bike.
You don't think the European companies haven't poured a heap of money in and been responsible for the developments that have put their bikes ahead? Aero and ride height being 2 fairly big ones.
You may also argue the loss of their ecu hasn't helped Honda with an engine that was designed around it. Yamaha aren't spending too much and are the only ones running an inline 4.
They are both miles behind. Put anyone else in there and do we see rider development bringing them back to the front anytime soon?
It’s both things, always has been. In the end it is up to the rider to tell the team what he needs to make the bike better and it is up to the team to deliver. This is where the ability to communicate, analyse, adjust and try a few things to determine what works, etc. It is a skill on both sides. It is possible that neither Marc or Fabio is up to the task, or the factories aren’t delivering, or a combination of the two.

Yes, the euro manufacturers came up with some good ideas and executed them to make their bikes better. I don’t know why the Japanese teams have not responded. Somehow it may have to do with money or just being unwilling to push with the existing formula.

In that case, they should just pull out of the series and release both riders from their contracts. As it is, it is just a waste of both Marc’s and Fabio’s talent.
 
I missed it, what happened to Binder?
Went wide, hit the gravel, couldn't recover.
Oh well. When all is said and done, yes the Honda is a .... bike, BUT it went to .... on his watch.
Honda and Yamaha both are ..... Yamaha had Jorge, Vale, Mav, now Fabio, all complaining from consistent issues that remain throughout the years. It's clear to me that the way Japanese teams work is very outdated. Good riders can't save them anymore.

You can give all the feedback in the world, but doesn't matter if the Japanese factories refuse to bring timely updates, or hell, updates that work. I'm pretty sure Marc wasn't the one telling them to change the bike from a front-wheel demon to a rear-wheel tractor, that was solely a move trying to chase what worked for Ducati. They (Honda and Yamaha) have completely lost the ability to innovate and they're playing catch-up, while not doing a good job about it. They still haven't figured out how to fine tune the spec ECU that has been in place since 2016.
 
It’s both things, always has been. In the end it is up to the rider to tell the team what he needs to make the bike better and it is up to the team to deliver. This is where the ability to communicate, analyse, adjust and try a few things to determine what works, etc. It is a skill on both sides. It is possible that neither Marc or Fabio is up to the task, or the factories aren’t delivering, or a combination of the two.

Yes, the euro manufacturers came up with some good ideas and executed them to make their bikes better. I don’t know why the Japanese teams have not responded. Somehow it may have to do with money or just being unwilling to push with the existing formula.

In that case, they should just pull out of the series and release both riders from their contracts. As it is, it is just a waste of both Marc’s and Fabio’s talent.
They ain't the only riders on those machines.
Previously they dominated and both are now nowhere, no matter who rides them.
I do not see that as a result of their inability to provide feedback.
The Japanese manufacturers have been outspent and gunned in terms of initiative well and truly for several years now.

Yes I agree both machines are a waste of their talent. Sh it to watch.
 
I
It went to .... while he was injured an unable to test. I have said in the past his ability to ride around problems does not make him a good test rider. They need a pedro type rider for that. Bradl is not that guy.
Darth Puig strikes again. He fired Dani Pedrosa as an act of revenge as far I could see. How much better would he have been at developing the Honda than any rider who succeeded him ?. He would also quite possibly still be better as a race rider even now. I am a major Jorge Lorenzo fan, but I don’t think the Honda was his type of bike, he was fairly spent when he got there, and the bike made multiple attempts to kill or maim him before he could do anything anyway.

I admire MM greatly as a rider, but have never seen much sign of him being a bike developer, as a rider he was llike Casey Stoner in being able to ride around problems but with a harder/tougher edge to his personality. I am of the belief the good bike he inherited, particularly in 2014 when he was totally dominant, was down to DP +/- Stoner, who was involved in the development of the 2012 bike, which he said was totally invincible before Dorna/Carmelo nobbled it with the late weight change, which his times in pre-season testing rather backed up, and even then was looking very competitive, prompting Dorna to take away the tires for which it was designed as well.

I am with Lex, they don’t want to spent huge money on a new engine which is probably what they need without their bespoke ECU in the dying days of this formula. A previous HRC manager in Shuehi Nakomoto who as opposed to the petty Puig was smart and able pretty much foresaw that the control ECU would be a problem for them, at one stage threatening Honda would withdraw iirc. I somehow doubt their announcement of a return to F1 presages much in the way of prioritisation of their motogp effort.
 
Last edited:
I

Darth Puig strikes again. He fired Dani Pedrosa as an act of revenge as far I could see. How much better would he have been at developing the Honda than any rider who succeeded him ?. He would also quite possibly still be better as a race rider even now. I am a major Jorge Lorenzo fan, but I don’t think the Honda was his type of bike, he was fairly spent when he got there, and the bike made multiple attempts to kill or maim him before he could do anything anyway.

I admire MM greatly as a rider, but have never seen much sign of him being a bike developer, as a rider he was llike Casey Stoner in being able to ride around problems but with a harder/tougher edge to his personality. I am of the belief the good bike he inherited, particularly in 2014 when he was totally dominant, was down to DP +/- Stoner, who was involved in the development of the 2012 bike, which he said was totally invincible before Dorna/Carmelo nobbled it with the late weight change, which his times in pre-season testing rather backed up, and even then was looking very competitive, prompting Dorna to take away the tires for which it was designed as well.

I am with Lex, they don’t want to spent huge money on a new engine which is probably what they need without their bespoke ECU in the dying days of this formula. A previous HRC manager in Shiehi Nakomoto who as opposed to the petty Puig was smart and ablepretty much foresaw that the control ECU would be a problem for them, at one stage threatening Honda would withdraw iirc. I somehow doubt their announcement of a return to F1 presages much in the way of prioritisation of their motogp effort.
I was going to include stoner in my earlier post as someone who was hard to develop a bike around. Like Marc his freakish way of riding a bike made his data hard to use. Add to the fact that if they are winning on it, how do you change the direction of development? So it is easy to go in the wrong direction with riders who can ride around problems.
 
Big call blaming two world champs for being unable to develop the bike.
You don't think the European companies haven't poured a heap of money in and been responsible for the developments that have put their bikes ahead? Aero and ride height being 2 fairly big ones.
You may also argue the loss of their ecu hasn't helped Honda with an engine that was designed around it. Yamaha aren't spending too much and are the only ones running an inline 4.
They are both miles behind. Put anyone else in there and do we see rider development bringing them back to the front anytime soon?
Yes. Not as if the Yamaha handles badly. It just doesn't make sufficient usable power. Can't really expect the rider to tell the engineers how to accomplish that. Whereas the Honda, seems neither to make sufficient useable power and it handles terribly. Funny how the KTM and the Aprila don't appear to be hobbled by the Magnetti Marelli unit. I suspect that HRC will continue to eat it, until they are allowed to use a proprietary ECU. It's like they can't wrap their heads around a Eurocentric algorithm.
 
If Honda is going to continue to eat it, what are they in this at all.

Like F1, they could leave.
 
I was going to include stoner in my earlier post as someone who was hard to develop a bike around. Like Marc his freakish way of riding a bike made his data hard to use. Add to the fact that if they are winning on it, how do you change the direction of development? So it is easy to go in the wrong direction with riders who can ride around problems.
Yes, these are good points. But, it is also the purpose (or used to be) to have two good riders in the team to keep everybody at the pointy end of the stick. Cooperation goes a long way when you look for improvement. For example the team can make a change to a bike and have both ride it, give input, etc. If you have a nobody as teammate, well then the input is pretty useless. Both Honda and Yamaha have been one rider teams for a long time now. Just because a bike is winning doesn’t mean it always will. In fact, if you don’t innovate while you are winning, you won’t continue to win for very long. which is what we are seeing now.

A freakish way of riding is only that way when it is brand new. It seems everybody is kind of riding the same way nowadays, especially the VR46 crew. MM was the first to save a corner on his elbow and we saw Marini do it not long ago. True that Stoner and MM are extraordinary talents. Fabio may be also, but that remains a work in progress for the time being.
 
Ducati cup, lol. I have heard some moans about this. Well, what's now so funny is the fact that many people are ignoring that both Honda and Yamaha won 28 WC out of the last 33 WC as long as I remember, not to mention the Japaneses won 31 of this 33 WC, being Ducati the only factory up until now that has managed to interrupt the asian total dominance. How fun is that?

I can't recall a soul moaning about or calling it the "Japanese Cup" as long as their superheroes like Rossi, Marquez, Biaggi or Doohan were winning dominant boring races on that bikes. I wonder even if both Honda and Yamaha have some kind of "agree" with Dorna for letting things turn upside down for a while. I surely wouldn't doubt about a thing like that.

Well, after so many years watching only two factories winning everything, seeing fans blaming Ducati for having a glimpse of dominance, which will stop soon, is nothing but weird and very contradictory. I think most of the GP audience is composed by dumb fanboys of their own bikes and as most of them own an Yamaha or Honda, now that their favorite brand is struggling and getting beat, they are crying and moaning like a kid.
 
"If Honda is going to continue to eat it, what are they in this at all.

Like F1, they could leave."

In part I expect, because they've been a major presence in bike racing since the days of Mike the Bike. Much harder to walk away from so many years of this tradition. And, yes I know that people say win on Sunday sell on Monday no longer holds true, but Honda continue to be in the bike biz, whereas they don't really sell anything comparable to a Ferrari or a Corvette.

"Well, after so many years watching only two factories winning everything, seeing fans blaming Ducati for having a glimpse of dominance, which will stop soon, is nothing but weird and very contradictory. I think most of the GP audience is composed by dumb fanboys of their own bikes and as most of them own an Yamaha or Honda, now that their favorite brand is struggling and getting beat, they are crying and moaning like a kid."

I expect folks would not be so put off by the current Ducati domination if they were not fielding a factory team and 3 satellite teams.
 
I expect folks would not be so put off by the current Ducati domination if they were not fielding a factory team and 3 satellite teams.

Which satellite team would like a Honda or Yamaha right now? Aren't they the ones choosing what brand to go for? Or is Dorna deciding this?
 
Can't be more fan of this guy! Miller is synonym of sincerity!

MotoGP | Miller: "Sei pagato per guidare una moto, non per dire che fa schifo"

When asked for his thoughts on his rivals, Miller gave a decidedly colorful response.

"At KTM we are the only ones who don't complain about our bikes and try to do something to fix them," he began. "Others just throw their toys out of their cribs and say, 'My bike sucks.' That's simple."

"Why are they ....? Because they threw out 99% of the engineers to get theirs in, and now they're ...... up and can't even get a lap. So, it's their own fault. Everyone wants to complain about their bikes, but nobody wants to do nothing".

"Shut your ....... mouth and get over your job. You're paid to ride a motorcycle, not to be a ....... princess and complain about your bike."

It is unclear who exactly Miller's "he" refers to. However, if he refers to Marquez, it is not exact, as the Spaniard only brought with him from Moto2 the technical chief Santi Hernandez and the chief mechanic Carlos Linan.
 
I agree that Miller is a breath of fresh air. He seems honest, is very likeable and fast on his day. No hint of guile, unless it’s extremely well camouflaged. Which I doubt, otherwise he’d pull that rabbit out of the hat more often.
 
Yes, these are good points. But, it is also the purpose (or used to be) to have two good riders in the team to keep everybody at the pointy end of the stick. Cooperation goes a long way when you look for improvement. For example the team can make a change to a bike and have both ride it, give input, etc. If you have a nobody as teammate, well then the input is pretty useless. Both Honda and Yamaha have been one rider teams for a long time now. Just because a bike is winning doesn’t mean it always will. In fact, if you don’t innovate while you are winning, you won’t continue to win for very long. which is what we are seeing now.

A freakish way of riding is only that way when it is brand new. It seems everybody is kind of riding the same way nowadays, especially the VR46 crew. MM was the first to save a corner on his elbow and we saw Marini do it not long ago. True that Stoner and MM are extraordinary talents. Fabio may be also, but that remains a work in progress for the time being.
Good post. Imo Fabio is more of a JLo type rider than Stoner and MM. Consistent when things are right but has a hard time in no-optimum conditions. I was a doubter but he changed my mind. I believe the only current rider that could beat him on equal machinery is Marc. As for Stoner, his best season on Ducati and back at honda were his first seasons. I think that has a lot to do with his unorthodox style making development extremely difficult.
 
I

Darth Puig strikes again. He fired Dani Pedrosa as an act of revenge as far I could see. How much better would he have been at developing the Honda than any rider who succeeded him ?. He would also quite possibly still be better as a race rider even now. I am a major Jorge Lorenzo fan, but I don’t think the Honda was his type of bike, he was fairly spent when he got there, and the bike made multiple attempts to kill or maim him before he could do anything anyway.

I admire MM greatly as a rider, but have never seen much sign of him being a bike developer, as a rider he was llike Casey Stoner in being able to ride around problems but with a harder/tougher edge to his personality. I am of the belief the good bike he inherited, particularly in 2014 when he was totally dominant, was down to DP +/- Stoner, who was involved in the development of the 2012 bike, which he said was totally invincible before Dorna/Carmelo nobbled it with the late weight change, which his times in pre-season testing rather backed up, and even then was looking very competitive, prompting Dorna to take away the tires for which it was designed as well.

I am with Lex, they don’t want to spent huge money on a new engine which is probably what they need without their bespoke ECU in the dying days of this formula. A previous HRC manager in Shuehi Nakomoto who as opposed to the petty Puig was smart and able pretty much foresaw that the control ECU would be a problem for them, at one stage threatening Honda would withdraw iirc. I somehow doubt their announcement of a return to F1 presages much in the way of prioritisation of their motogp effort.

Yes that makes sense, I don't see that bike being any good next year either.
Pity, but that is the way it is.

Marquez trusting Honda because of their ability to make a formula one engine doesn't make much sense for this reason.
 
Which satellite team would like a Honda or Yamaha right now? Aren't they the ones choosing what brand to go for? Or is Dorna deciding this?
That's really besides the point. Having so many satellite teams A. overwhelms the field giving an unfair disadvantage to ALL teams. And B it supplies them with massive amounts of data and rider input. To my knowledge there is no precedent in MotoGp for any manufacturer to have that many satellite teams.
 
That's really besides the point. Having so many satellite teams A. overwhelms the field giving an unfair disadvantage to ALL teams. And B it supplies them with massive amounts of data and rider input. To my knowledge there is no precedent in MotoGp for any manufacturer to have that many satellite teams.
In 97 Honda had 8 bikes on the grid, I believe they won every race that year. Quite a few all Honda podiums.
 

Recent Discussions

Recent Discussions

Back
Top