Should Casey be punished

MotoGP Forum

Help Support MotoGP Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
Having seen yer photo - I'm also practicing the chords

to the theme for the Jolly Green Giant.

Just dont start singing "Do you want to be in my gang".
<
<
 
I had trouble finding out your reply as you embedded that into my quoted message
<




Now I am treading the line of fire
<
- I am saying, Stoner might have said that at the heat of the moment. He might have felt that the marshalls should have pushed him more.

My point is, the video shows marshalls pushing his bike (around 5-6). They might have left him alone once they entered the danger zone and still his bike didn't start.



If you look at Sic's criticism of marshalls, it has a pattern (both have the new HRC clutch which is rumored to be cause for difficult restarts). The marshalls definitely tried to push him (as can be seen from the video) for some distance. I guess, both Casey and Sic felt wronged by the marshalls as their bikes didn't start but actually, the blame lies in the Honda clutch that takes too much of push to start.



And BTW, from what I understand ( I haven't raced in even club level nor have I marshalled), the job of marshall is to remove riders/ bikes from the danger zone. They may try to start the bike by pushing as it will help moving the bike. But I don't think it is their duty to push it till it starts





Great minds think alike
<




Kropo's take



BTW, have alook at this track side video. You can clearly see that Stoner is being pushed by all the marshalls

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYNe6VzhNo0[/media]
 
Steifel, PM me so i can send u address to send ur money. Cash only please.
<



Dear Friend,



I am in need of your assistance, I want to make a donation to the poor and

needy
Casey Stoner through you. My name is Mrs Rosemary Brown Stiefel ,A USA Dutch citizen, I live in

Abu Dubai the netherlands, right now i am in the hospital, I have been undergoing

treatment for oesophageal cancer.I have since lost my ability to talk and

my Doctors have told me that I have onlya few months to live. Before I

became ill, I kept USd$ 7.5 Million in a long-term deposit in a Security

Company in Europe.



Now that it is clear that i will not survive this sickness, I have decided

that i must give my wealth to the poor and needy just for assistance.

Mostly if you can donate to motherless, widows and hurricane victims Casey Stoner I

will highly appreciate. Kindly reply me through my email.(

[email protected] )



Yours sincerely,

stiefel
 
Dear Friend,



I am in need of your assistance, I want to make a donation to the poor and

needy
Casey Stoner through you. My name is Mrs Rosemary Brown Stiefel ,A USA Dutch citizen, I live in

Abu Dubai the netherlands, right now i am in the hospital, I have been undergoing

treatment for oesophageal cancer.I have since lost my ability to talk and

my Doctors have told me that I have onlya few months to live. Before I

became ill, I kept USd$ 7.5 Million in a long-term deposit in a Security

Company in Europe.



Now that it is clear that i will not survive this sickness, I have decided

that i must give my wealth to the poor and needy just for assistance.

Mostly if you can donate to motherless, widows and hurricane victims Casey Stoner I

will highly appreciate. Kindly reply me through my email.(

[email protected] )



Yours sincerely,

stiefel



You may not believe it, but this actually works! They hacked my best friend's email just 6 months ago and sent an email very similar to yours above to his dad. (The email said he was stuck in the UK without his wallet because it had been stolen and needed money quick). His dad sent 3000 dollars! No .........
 
Great minds think alike
<




My link



BTW, have alook at this track side video. You can clearly see that Stoner is being pushed by all the marshalls

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYNe6VzhNo0[/media]



Wow that one marshal has like 8 legs, 4 bodies & heads. Crazy! Its just to bad for Casey that altogether they had only one brain cell.
 
So you think Stoner 'made friends' yesterday with his gesture to the marshals and Rossi?



Lets be honest, no matter what he does Stoner will never be more popular than Rossi as much as you might want him to be. He probably doesn't care, but he has the temperament of a pubescent teenager.



Yes - we needed you of all people to bring this up, because while your knowledge of

racing is vast - it's clearly eclipsed by your capacity to make friends.
 
regardless of what happened that caused him to be taken out of the race he jumped over pit wall with the sole purpose to show vale his contempt. This put not only himself in danger but other riders on track. Spectators have no place on track side and i believe it is against the law. I also think HRC should face sanctions for there emotionally out of control employee's actions. This type of behaviour has no place in such a fast dangerous sport like motor racing. He should have stayed in his garage. What ever next?



http://www.daylife.com/search?q=valentino+rossi





So let e get this straight it's ok to hurtlearound the track and get knocked off by morons in your full leathers, gloves and helmet but not to stand track side dressed the same and applaud. So what about the flag waving marshalls are they putting themselves and the riders in danger too. You're just bitter cos you know Rossi faked his shoulder to cover up the fact that S
 
^

This dude just jumped head first into the pool. Didn't check the water or the depth.
 
Great minds think alike
<




Kropo's take



BTW, have alook at this track side video. You can clearly see that Stoner is being pushed by all the marshalls

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYNe6VzhNo0[/media]



Tho I have club raced - it hasn't much bearing on the topic. Technically - if one was to

look at the written agreement between the marshals and mgmt - it in all likelihood

says their responsibility is to deal with safety issues.



On the other hand - I will tell you that my former wife was a corner marshall and worked

at many races both at the club and national levels - and without any question - it has been

tradition for decades to help a rider back onto the track as long as the rider does not appear

to be concussed or otherwise obviously injured - assuming the bike is not leaking fluids or

on fire.



Lastly it's pointless for us mortals to conjecture about rumors and hearsay regarding the

chances of Stoner bump-starting the bike. If Stoner believed it was do-able - it probably

was.
 
What happened to all the people complaining that no marshal's helped Stoner?





It looks to me like there's quiet a few pushing that Honda.
 
What happened to all the people complaining that no marshal's helped Stoner?





It looks to me like there's quiet a few pushing that Honda.

Well if we have an Arcadian, I suppose Sli-Wood helps maintain the balance.



What part of AFTER do you not understand? Oh and quite a few did gather around, but it looks like one was actually pushing.
<
 
I think Rossi, Stoner, Marco Simoncelli, Ben Spies, and Collin Edwards should all be penalized for handing that sucky rider "The Kentucky Squid" a podium. That really pisses me off, now he even looks better then he really is.
 
So its gone from none, to quiet a few, to some that are doing nothing.



Man you change your mind more times than your underpants.



Would you mind filling me in then to how many helped jump start Rossi's bike?
 
I think Rossi, Stoner, Marco Simoncelli, Ben Spies, and Collin Edwards should all be penalized for handing that sucky rider "The Kentucky Squid" a podium. That really pisses me off, now he even looks better then he really is.





lol thats a bit harsh!



But then again....he's jumkies guy so .... him!
<
 
If the powers that be would really be dumb enough to fine Stoner, I think we should collect money to reimburse every last penny. Not because he needs the cash, but to demonstrate that a lot of racing fans are fed up with this .....



And yes, I am willing to contribute some myself.



LMFAO



this thread is really getting good.



It would prove the number of nuthuggers in the house.....thats true boner behavior if there ever was any!



Seriously though he wont get fined, all will be forgotten everywhere else but this little bubble of a forum.
 
Look at the harmony in this picture. Stoner and the crowd clapping while Rossi is waiving at them, and some angree Yamaha guy (looks like Lorenzo's brother) destroy the peace by throwing someting (?) at the passing Rossi?
 

Attachments

  • ideal pass.jpg
    ideal pass.jpg
    125.9 KB

Recent Discussions

Recent Discussions

Back
Top