Jorge could and should still win the title

MotoGP Forum

Help Support MotoGP Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I have to disagree.

Diego Costa is the sort of guy who brings an entire sport down because of his behavior. This goes beyond simply being annoying, he's a thug on the field and makes games unfun to watch as a result. I don't mind villains as it makes for more interesting games. But he takes .... to a level that is simply unacceptable at any level of sport.

I'm not condoning him or his behaviour, he's simply a personification of the modern game which is legitimised by his manager and tragically emulated by a generation of kids across parks and playing fields nationwide. The failure of the F.A. to eradicate this from the game is positive reinforcement just as players hurling themselves to the ground and writhing around in mock agony is similarly vindicated.

Stick Costa on a rugby field for five minutes, that'll sort it.
 
I think we have interacted more on whatsapp regarding soccer than we ever did about MotoGP. (Well, except when your phone experiences that intermittent gremlins of the type that surely sabotaged Valentino's fateful Valencia race in 06, caused in part or not by a soccer t-shirt, who knew?)

Notwithstanding, I must register my disagreement with you regarding the ref’s plight, even specifically in this match. As you know I have expressed my disdain for refers often, especially during the FIFA World Farce (Mexico’s exit to the ........ tournament aside), but…I have had a change of heart. The game in question did end up being a farce, but as much as you wouldn’t blame the physician for your health negligence, I see a parallel here as well. Blame the doctor? No, the ref is a single man running around trying to make split decisions in a game where one single call can decide to erase 90 mins of action. First of all, the rules are ........ and need to be “modernized” (I’ll get to your point about the “modern game” below). Only in soccer can one bad decision be so monumental that it makes the entire contest meaningless. Its like the players are playing this game while there is this hair-trigger bomb poised to explode at any second or not, in any given game, regardless of its importance or lack their of. Its called the penalty rule, and I have yet to hear a consensus whenever it has been applied properly, ever. Imagine that, a rule that nobody agrees on but yet decides a contest, regularly.

Second, the ref is trying to manage a game where 22 players on the field are trying to deceive him first and contest the contest second…this my friend is what I perceive as the “modern game”! Diego Costa’s job is certainly NOT to “exploit the vulnerabilities” of players personalities, that is utterly a rubbishing of the game, a perversion of the contest and its rules at best! In fact, its why I never liked this sport, because its constant manipulation, contrivance, deception, and a circumventing of the spirit of this game. How many times have we heard the following to accept this hogwash (sorry Cameron): “Soccer is like life.” This ........ rationalization doesn’t even hold up for its intended ostrich like rationale. It is NOT like life, but it certainly is a rationalization and cliché that has tricked the masses into living an dying by an arbitrary contest that has often been decided by little to nothing regarding the skill of the player’s performance on the pitch.

What needs to happen to legitimize the arbitration of this “modern sport”? I don’t think the Penis rule will ever be modified, and in theory it makes good sense, but in practice, it is impossible to apply. Therefore, the recourse for this and all the other shortcomings of the game could be mitigated by the introduction of referee aids, in the form of more referees, technology to assess calls to make more accurate calls, and heavy handed sanctions for attempts at manipulating the rules. How many dudes would do what chickenshit Diego Costa and Pepe do on a regular basis, if they knew when getting caught it would result in a 3 month ban? It’s the same with MotoGP, the Fenatis and Marquez’s of the sport, and ......... in life, exist because the policing of them is so weak. And before anybody says, this would disrupt the “flow” of the game if say we were to introduce instant replay, for .... sake, tell the guys running around (even when they are losing) who just scored a goal like they just cured cancer to put their shirt back on and ....... get back on the pitch. Not to mention those feigning injury masterminds, it is still called “injury time” right? You know, those few minutes they add to every single half ever. Haha.

Regardless, I still have hope for soccer. I am a fan.

Go Shrewmberry Town
Go Leisure City
Go Southcrapton

For the large part I absolutely agree, bar the aspersions that you cast on the reliability of my phone - you are welcome to furnish me with a new one. Thinking about it...you actually did sort me with one for the duration of my last stay, and that door stop was infinitely more reliable than the supposedly 'smart' one that you always exhorted me to purchase.

The debate over video policing has raged for years in football and aside from the fears you mentioned that it would disrupt the game, it would be difficult to effect at grass roots level. Goal line technology has been a revelation but you are right, until we revert to a fully integrated system of video monitoring through a rugby union style TMO this flagrant cheating will continue to be a blight upon the game.

"Its called the penalty rule, and I have yet to hear a consensus whenever it has been applied properly, ever. Imagine that, a rule that nobody agrees on but yet decides a contest, regularly."

Not sure what you mean here. The ruling is clear, the problem, which you of all people should appreciate, lies in interpretation, emotional investment and subjective judgement.

Incidentally, your mail has evidently still not arrived? Conspiracy theories and cheating footballers aside, perhaps if I send the next one now it'll be there in time for Christmas compa...

22f68c6d-96e9-418b-91c5-d6c61ffb4be1.jpg
 
Your thoughts on the Ashes, and Clarkies captaincy?

Clarke has been a good captain and an outstanding batsman. But, he should of retired last year. This was particularly evident when he said at the beginning of the Tour " I can't imagine what it would be like, to win the Ashes. I knew then, they would lose.
If a Captain can't imagine winning, then how does he inspire his team.
 
.... cricket - its rugby's time to shine at the moment!!!
2-3 years ago I would've never dreamed of watching and enjoying soccer (intermittently while not screaming at it) but at the behest of the same three blokes who got me into soccer, I have been watching the rugby world cup. I still have absolutely no clue what the .... is going on, and I mean that wholeheartedly, regardless it gives me a sense the players are good honest sportsman. Certainly nocrybaby fragile ego divas on the field, and that is a pleasure to watch. Not to mention the scary intimidation thing they do at the beginning.


 
Last edited:
I'm not condoning him or his behaviour, he's simply a personification of the modern game which is legitimised by his manager and tragically emulated by a generation of kids across parks and playing fields nationwide. The failure of the F.A. to eradicate this from the game is positive reinforcement just as players hurling themselves to the ground and writhing around in mock agony is similarly vindicated.

Stick Costa on a rugby field for five minutes, that'll sort it.

Yes there other issues involved, diving in particular, but Diego Costa isn't simply an extension of diving. What he is doing is actively undermining the entire sport. He's physically assaulting players on the pitch as opposed to diving. That is even worse than a dive in my book if you had to rank the two things. Diving needs to be cracked down on, but the absence of enforcement of one thing shouldn't mean a lack of enforcement on another issue. Look at the bans Suarez got hit with, and Diego Costa has skated by with nothing?

He got a 3 game match ban for it, It should have been longer (I'd say 6 to 9 games as a repeat offender) but at least he finally got hit with something.

I second sticking him on a rugby field. Though I'm pretty sure if someone just punched Diego Costa in the face repeatedly, that might solve the issue too.
 
I second sticking him on a rugby field. Though I'm pretty sure if someone just punched Diego Costa in the face repeatedly, that might solve the issue too.

It may well be a cosmetic improvement to boot.

Clarke has been a good captain and an outstanding batsman. But, he should of retired last year. This was particularly evident when he said at the beginning of the Tour " I can't imagine what it would be like, to win the Ashes. I knew then, they would lose.
If a Captain can't imagine winning, then how does he inspire his team.

I suspect that this is the only Captain that inspired your answer...

Captain_Google.gif
[/URL][/IMG]
 
So, who's people's money on now?

Jorge is always strong at Motegi and Valencia. Malaysia is 50/50, both have had a win there but have been pretty even as Yamaha teammates as they have been at PI.

One things for sure, it's gonna be close!
 
So, who's people's money on now?

Jorge is always strong at Motegi and Valencia. Malaysia is 50/50, both have had a win there but have been pretty even as Yamaha teammates as they have been at PI.

One things for sure, it's gonna be close!

Silverstone, Misano, Aragon were 70/30 favorable to Lorenzo but Rossi has managed (with a little help from the gods and also from Jorge himself) to turn the balance of these three in his favor. Now you can be sure he'll attack and try to close the battle in the next three races in Asia, where the chances are 50/50.
He'll try to avoid arriving at Valencia without a safe margin, if he can.
 

Recent Discussions

Recent Discussions

Back
Top