Joined Sep 2007
2K Posts | 60+
here
No one ever said Lorenzo and Stoner were Gods, that was reserved for a certain cult. Yes he won races, and a couple of championships, but the walk on water miracles of riding from the back of the pack to win races were long gone once Stoner and Lorenzo arrived. He could not toy with them and had to race balls out. Its not a coincedence that his winning percentage was slashed by 50 %. If Rossi is a God, i guess that makes Stoner a Super Maximus Prime God, you know, since he has dominated the regular God.
As Spooky has already pointed out, Assen 07 and to a lesser extent Sepang 10 give the lie to the "he can't ride from the back of the pack to win races". As for the fact that his winning percentage has been slashed since Stoner and Lorenzo turned up - you have to remember that he is older than either. He also was able to "race balls out" and beat them in 2008 & 2009.
I don't maintain that Rossi is a god, and think that Stoner is a more naturally skilled and versatile rider. Stoner has demonstrably beaten Rossi during the time that they have both been on factory machines, and Stoner at Ducati was probably a real god, although he hasn't utterly dominated the field on the more friendly Honda, even last year when the chatter was less evident.
Lorenzo on the other hand, whilst hugely talented, is a rider whose style is very similar to Rossi's and I think that the case is less clear cut as to which is better. During the time they have been racing together Lorenzo has been on what is arguably the best bike. He has 40 podiums to Rossi's 42 & 21 wins to Rossi's 16 wins. 7 of those wins were after Rossi left Yamaha and so stopped challenging him for wins & podiums, but on the flip side in Lorenzo's first year when highsiding to the moon, he "only" managed 1 win & 6 podiums.