Thanx for the info Hawk, hadnt seen that. Btw, i said it when Dovi moved on (and u can check me on it), that i wish Nicky would do same ballsy move. I wasnt or havent been too much of a Dovi fan, but that FU to Honda for Sat Yamaha was ballsy and respectable. Much props to him.
Talps, ur making the same mistake Kropo made in his last article, that is to not understand the difference between the league doing ur bidding as oppose to a vested player within the series. Again, a point u ( and Kropo, see his lazy and flawed comments on Spies & Edwards tweets) have failed to comprehend. I say Kropo, because like u, its one thing for a rider to get hired by the manufacture that wants u, as opposed to the infinitely different case in the league changing, bending rule, bidding backroom deals, horse trading FOR THE RIDER.
Talps my man, i've read u bring up Nicky's accession to GP as favoritism or for marketing purposes. But u are wrong! This is one debate u wont win. Honda wanted the next young supertalent, as they always do, talent wise that kid in 03 was Hayden. Having the credentials lacking one dirtrack mile win to put the man into the Grand Slam of record books is fantastic on a resume in terms of American prospects. U also underestimate an AMA title, especially during a time Wsbk was nothing more than a Ducati cup (where Honda were forced to build a Ducati of their own). Btw, John Hopkins was promoted on less, never having won a AmaSbk title. Why? Because at the time an AMA title mean some .... (and still does as Spies proved in Wsbk). Honda initially wanted to groom NH under Rossi. That is until Rossi left then all direction changed with Pedrosa being over hyped as the future for Repsol and the Spanish resurgence/ paradigm shift "final solution": Spaniard domination in GP. This happened when the sky fell and Rossi left. (Much like Stoner leaving now, everything has now changed, all bets off, a new direction is born). Nicky wasnt going to win .... under Rossi, or need i remind u why the man left Yamaha? 06 was NH only chance, 07+ at HRC he was doomed under the thump of the Puig who's hand is always up Carmelos ... (or is it the other way round, matters not). all u need to know about race wins is to count how many Rossi has at the end of his 2 years for "factory" Ducati. I dont believe for one second Rossi would have any had he ridden for the brand from 07 to present. The only year NH was almost #1 at HRC was the year he lifted the title, thats the magnitude of being #2, especially under Rossi, then way worse under Pedrosa.
I don't have a great problem with them scrapping the rookie rule, particularly in advance of honda actually drafting marquez straight into the factory team next year. If they do, it will be stupid imo, Valentino is a much better bet to win the championship next year for them, as cal probably would be imo, particularly given marquez is not even winning moto 2 currently. If they were to park him on a full factory bike in a satellite team and he was to have promising results compared to the factory team riders (I really can't see him out performing pedrosa in his rookie year on the factory team or off) they could devote resources to him anyway.
The satellite rule was hastily devised (they didn't appear to have thought how it might apply to suzuki) under a previous paradigm to help satellite teams, quite likely with good intentions. This was at a time when there were 4 or 5 satellite ducatis and hondas. The most recent paradigm as I understand it (dorna may have changed it last week or this morning as is their wont) was for there to be only 2 satellite bikes for each marque next year and for up and coming riders to be developed/prove themselves on the crt bikes. Given that each of yamaha and honda have in recent years had 1 factory signed rider on a more or less factory bike on a satellite team, this means by my arithmetic1 available satellite seat on either a honda or yamaha, for which there are hardly likely to be a shortage of talented aspirants (those rides will be more appealing than ducati factory rides, imo). As others have argued and with which I agree if repsol/dorna/honda have such big plans for marquez he is unlikely to be very beneficial to a satellite team anyway, particularly if they temporarily have to take repsol with him.