This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

2017 Gran Premio Red Bull de España

You'd never admit to yourself or others that you went to an event such as the TT to see riders killed. That's the spectacle... men risking death for TT glory and you wanted to see it firsthand.
Sorry mate, I have to call you out on that.
The TT isn't the spectacle of death, it's the spectacle of speed.
Speed in an environment that we can relate to, i.e. the road.
The movement of the bikes on a less than perfect surface adds to the spectacle of speed.

I'm surprised to see a stand point on the TT such as yours on a bike racing forum. I thought all race fans got it.
Still we all have the right to free speech, but just so that you know, it's not cool to accuse someone of watching the tt just for the deaths
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
What a load of bollox, people know it happens, but we don't go to see them die.

I find it hard to approve of the TT now in late middle age, but if you stay home in bed all day you quite possibly will die of a DVT and subsequent pulmonary emboli.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
I find it hard to approve of the TT now in late middle age, but if you stay home in bed all day you quite possibly will die of a DVT and subsequent pulmonary emboli.

The riders know the stakes involved for better or worse. As long as they are aware of it, frankly I don't see why you would not approve of the TT. No one is holding a gun to their head and telling them to go race there.
 
The debate comes around every year, how about getting rid of horse racing and bullfighting first or banning people from climbing mountains? Everest alone has claimed 300 lives, that's more than the TT and the Manx combined.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 people
What a ....... .... you are,i went every year because i lived in England and i love motorcycle racing,i went because its the most awesome event you will ever see,the spectacle is seeing insane speeds between lamposts and brick walls and getting up at 4 am and riding the course yourself and being overtaken by real racers out for an early practice, not seeing people die,you are a complete .... and a disgrace to this forum and this is the last time i will reply to the utter .... you speak

I was going to reply to this, clicked like by mistake, clicked unlike, typed a response, deleted it. I despair at fuckwits like you, I really do. What a ....... low, inflammatory thing to say.

I thought it was great that the others that just want to piss other people off and have childish arguments had gone off elsewhere to do it.

Sorry mate, I have to call you out on that.
The TT isn't the spectacle of death, it's the spectacle of speed.
Speed in an environment that we can relate to, i.e. the road.
The movement of the bikes on a less than perfect surface adds to the spectacle of speed.

I'm surprised to see a stand point on the TT such as yours on a bike racing forum. I thought all race fans got it.
Still we all have the right to free speech, but just so that you know, it's not cool to accuse someone of watching the tt just for the deaths

Just because the truth is hard for you to accept doesn't make it less true. The TT isn't just a spectacle of speed, WSBK and BSB bikes are just as fast (if not faster) but compete in a safer environment. GP bikes are FASTER, but compete in a safer environment. The appeal of the TT is men risking their life on one of if not the most dangerous circuit in the world. There are deaths every year and people from all over the world purchase tickets to go see it. It's not much different then Romans going to the Colosseum to see gladiators die.

Do racers really have to accept such a high level of risks to be considered "real" racers? I have respect for TT racers and I like watching Michael Dunlop race, but I don't consider him more of a real racer than GP, WSBK, or BSB racers.
 
You'd never admit to yourself or others that you went to an event such as the TT to see riders killed. That's the spectacle... men risking death for TT glory and you wanted to see it firsthand.

Actually it's more that we like to see real racers who live in the real world racing for the love of a pure sport rather than watching a bunch of spoilt rich Spanish and Italian kids riding million pound motorbikes around glorified go-kart tracks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
Pyeman can't sit here and post that he wants Rossi to "crash lightly", but then admit he enjoys watching the TT where racers lose their life annually. He has the same thirst for blood when watching Moto GP or WSBK, they're just not as likely to satisfy him. Doesn't stop him from watching and wishing the racers go down in similar to fashion to what he enjoys about the TT.
 
Actually it's more that we like to see real racers who live in the real world racing for the love of a pure sport rather than watching a bunch of spoilt rich Spanish and Italian kids riding million pound motorbikes around glorified go-kart tracks.

Is that really what you think? The TT racers are the real deal, but the GP guys are just pretenders? They ..... and complain too much even with their big salaries?! If given the same equipment the real TT racers would show Marquez his ... around Jerez right?
 
Last edited:
Is that really what you think? The TT racers are the real deal, but the GP guys are just pretenders? They ..... and complain too much even with their big salaries?! If given the same equipment the real TT racers would show Marquez the his ... around Jerez right?

Modern grand prix riders ride like idiots, old school riders like Barry Sheene, Kenny Roberts, Freddie Spencer, Eddie Lawson etc. raced each other hard but there was always respect and an etiquette on track. These youngsters act like they're in a pinball game, using other riders as a berm and exceeding the track limits, the crash statistics are horrendous, the world champion for 2017 lost his bike nearly 30 times last year. 2017 was a record breaking year for accidents the number of crashes in MotoGP exceeded 300 compared to less than 100 in 2006.
 
Just because the truth is hard for you to accept doesn't make it less true. The TT isn't just a spectacle of speed, WSBK and BSB bikes are just as fast (if not faster) but compete in a safer environment. GP bikes are FASTER, but compete in a safer environment. The appeal of the TT is men risking their life on one of if not the most dangerous circuit in the world. There are deaths every year and people from all over the world purchase tickets to go see it. It's not much different then Romans going to the Colosseum to see gladiators die.

Do racers really have to accept such a high level of risks to be considered "real" racers? I have respect for TT racers and I like watching Michael Dunlop race, but I don't consider him more of a real racer than GP, WSBK, or BSB racers.

Pyeman can't sit here and post that he wants Rossi to "crash lightly", but then admit he enjoys watching the TT where racers lose their life annually. He has the same thirst for blood when watching Moto GP or WSBK, they're just not as likely to satisfy him. Doesn't stop him from watching and wishing the racers go down in similar to fashion to what he enjoys about the TT.

Is that really what you think? The TT racers are the real deal, but the GP guys are just pretenders? They ..... and complain too much even with their big salaries?! If given the same equipment the real TT racers would show Marquez the his ... around Jerez right?

Another mind reader. :rolleyes:

The rest are ludicrous straw man ........ from someone who has twisted ideas about why people like the TT.

Personally knowing the level of risk involved, I think it's nuts. But it's an old tradition, road racing and old traditions like this are culturally ingrained, like bull riding at rodeos, or Buzkashi, bull fighting or American football and they're so much apart of their cultures that they're very slow to go away.

A couple people a year die at the TT, but it's a tiny number compared to the number of football players who get brain injuries that lead to suicide. Your odds of dying on a street bike at the hands of a soccer mom in a 20 year old Celica are a thousand time higher. Your odds of dying at the TT are small compared to dying of heart failure from eating too much red meat.

Nobody ....... goes to the TT to gawk at death. People go because it's more egalitarian, more raw; an old school/roots-of-the-tradition form of racing.

Same reason why people love to go to watch vintage racing. Not because it's "better" but because it's different.

Hamburger anyone?
 
Last edited:
Actually it's more that we like to see real racers who live in the real world racing for the love of a pure sport rather than watching a bunch of spoilt rich Spanish and Italian kids riding million pound motorbikes around glorified go-kart tracks.


Spoilt rich kids don't end up in GPs. They aren't tough enough. I know a couple of kids who made it to moto3, won't name names, but I can assure you...their parents were broke after sacrifying all their resources to give their kids a chance. The environment of the Grand Prix Racing world himself might have a lot people looking spoilt, but very rarely those people HAIL from a spoilt environment.

Rossi himself, despite having a father who was a former GP rider, grew up in a family that was anything but wealthy in his pre-turning-pro years.

In some areas of Italy, such as Romagna, riding a motorcycle is like running, playing football, or having a bicycle for kids. Meaning EVERYONE does it. And it's the same in Spain: it's not really a sport for those who have enough money to try it out, is just something that people have in their culture and therefore in their blood. The "it's expensive" always comes afterwards.

Having a huge amount of people who try out the sport is why Spain and Italy produce more riders than any other country.

If you think TT is tougher because people die, here's a list of all the riders who have died in the history of Grand Prix Racing:

https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incidenti_mortali_del_Motomondiale
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
Just because the truth is hard for you to accept doesn't make it less true. The TT isn't just a spectacle of speed, WSBK and BSB bikes are just as fast (if not faster) but compete in a safer environment. GP bikes are FASTER, but compete in a safer environment. The appeal of the TT is men risking their life on one of if not the most dangerous circuit in the world. There are deaths every year and people from all over the world purchase tickets to go see it. It's not much different then Romans going to the Colosseum to see gladiators die.

Do racers really have to accept such a high level of risks to be considered "real" racers? I have respect for TT racers and I like watching Michael Dunlop race, but I don't consider him more of a real racer than GP, WSBK, or BSB racers.
I agree with you about the speed aspect, in sheer numerical terms when comparing closed circuit racing to the roads, what I am talking about is the sense of speed that comes from the bikes going through the towns and villages at full lick.
I also don't think less of any GP, or SBK racers, not at all.
All I am saying is that most people watch the TT for the speed, just because there are fatalities there does not mean that that is the motivation for the spectators- although I concede that it may be for some.
The thing to bare in mind is that the racers choose to do this, so the analogy of the gladiators is off the mark a bit. I have never seen a fatality at the TT and I never want to. The GP fatalities I have only ever seen live and will never watch any footage of them again and, being candid, I had my fair share of unpleasantness in the army, so I can assure you that, for me at least, it is just for the speed.
There is slow mo footage of the bikes going through 'Conker Trees' (I'm not making it up), you should watch that. It's incredible to see the compression of the suspension and goes some way to showing as to why the TT is so popular.
By the way, before anyone asks, yes I do have kids and no I don't know how I would feel if they wanted to become road racers.
 
Spoilt rich kids don't end up in GPs. They aren't tough enough. I know a couple of kids who made it to moto3, won't name names, but I can assure you...their parents were broke after sacrifying all their resources to give their kids a chance. The environment of the Grand Prix Racing world himself might have a lot people looking spoilt, but very rarely those people HAIL from a spoilt environment.

Rossi himself, despite having a father who was a former GP rider, grew up in a family that was anything but wealthy in his pre-turning-pro years.

In some areas of Italy, such as Romagna, riding a motorcycle is like running, playing football, or having a bicycle for kids. Meaning EVERYONE does it. And it's the same in Spain: it's not really a sport for those who have enough money to try it out, is just something that people have in their culture and therefore in their blood. The "it's expensive" always comes afterwards.

Having a huge amount of people who try out the sport is why Spain and Italy produce more riders than any other country.

If you think TT is tougher because people die, here's a list of all the riders who have died in the history of Grand Prix Racing:

https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incidenti_mortali_del_Motomondiale

I don't think it's tougher because people die, I find it more refreshing because the riders are more down to Earth and proper salt of the Earth types.
 
I don't think it's tougher because people die, I find it more refreshing because the riders are more down to Earth and proper salt of the Earth types.



Mate there are a lot of kids racing moto2 and moto3 that couldn't be more down to earth. And even MotoGP. I was lucky enough to chat with Dovizioso and Pol Espargaro for example, and they were both more down to earth than some of my friends who ride amateur dirt track with me :D

All I'm saying is that the way the two things (TT and Grand Prix racing) are marketed and presented makes one look more genuine and one look more spoiled. IMHO, that ain't true.

Peace
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
I don't think these documentaries in recent years have helped the cause for road racing, Road in particular was extremely morbid and pretty much just portrayed death right from the start. I'd like to know how that project ended up like that to be honest because originally it was meant to be a documentary following Michael and William through the Irish road racing season rather than an actual documentary about the family, apparently a lot of footage filmed during the year 2012 never made it into the final film, some of which is available on the DVD as an extra.

Closer to the Edge was more upbeat and had funny moments while still briefly dealing with the tragic side of the sport and showing how normal these fellas really are, Road I felt just portrayed them as maniacs and showing Roberts crash was just wrong in my opinion, according to Michaels book they never even told the family they were going to show that when they viewed it at a private screening.
 
Do racers really have to accept such a high level of risks to be considered "real" racers? I have respect for TT racers and I like watching Michael Dunlop race, but I don't consider him more of a real racer than GP, WSBK, or BSB racers.

They couldn't care less if you, I, or others consider them real racers. Do you know why? Because they are racers. All that matters is speed. Times. Beating that upstart .... who rocked up with his $$$$$ trailer and stickered bike. That's what they do. Go hard, analyse everything. Go harder, faster.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 people
I agree with you about the speed aspect, in sheer numerical terms when comparing closed circuit racing to the roads, what I am talking about is the sense of speed that comes from the bikes going through the towns and villages at full lick.
I also don't think less of any GP, or SBK racers, not at all.
All I am saying is that most people watch the TT for the speed, just because there are fatalities there does not mean that that is the motivation for the spectators- although I concede that it may be for some.
The thing to bare in mind is that the racers choose to do this, so the analogy of the gladiators is off the mark a bit. I have never seen a fatality at the TT and I never want to. The GP fatalities I have only ever seen live and will never watch any footage of them again and, being candid, I had my fair share of unpleasantness in the army, so I can assure you that, for me at least, it is just for the speed.
There is slow mo footage of the bikes going through 'Conker Trees' (I'm not making it up), you should watch that. It's incredible to see the compression of the suspension and goes some way to showing as to why the TT is so popular.
By the way, before anyone asks, yes I do have kids and no I don't know how I would feel if they wanted to become road racers.

I have attended live motor racing since my early teens, and always abhorred the spectators who attended to see the crashes. I actually don't follow the TT because I do find it just too dangerous, and I wouldn't watch people climbing Everest if that was a spectator sport either.

I go both ways on this though, no one forces people to compete in TT racing or climb Everest as has been said, life is a risk in general from which all danger can't be removed, and staying home in bed has its own risks. I personally agree that a significant percentage of competitors ending up with traumatic encephalopathy is probably worse than the fatality rate in TT racing, or ending up quadriplegic from a rugby scrum.

People have also perhaps somewhat forgotten just how dangerous the more mainstream sport of FI car racing once was.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
In the press conference when asked if there is anything he is scared of Iannone grinned and answer 'Marc' while laughing and then high fives Marquez.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
..... sake guys. It's tiresome...

Enjoy your sniping and bringing everything down to the same old ..... Have fun pissing each other off. I'm going to just watch the racing, the warm ups, the practices, every snippet I can find. I'm going to read stuff, no doubt on the internet, but I won't be reading pages and pages of bickering.

Great, thanks, I’m sure there won’t be any more bickering or inflammatory things said…

I was going to reply to this, clicked like by mistake, clicked unlike, typed a response, deleted it. I despair at fuckwits like you, I really do. What a ....... low, inflammatory thing to say. ,

I thought it was great that the others that just want to piss other people off and have childish arguments had gone off elsewhere to do it.

The forum is truly a fascinating human social experiment. Furiosa, here me out, I’m responding to you because if this part you said: “What a ....... low, inflammatory thing to say.” and “I thought it was great that…’childish arguments’ had gone off elsewhere…” I assume you are talking about the flame war Kesh has been conducting against me lately, ironically over me telling Kesh to stop flame warring with Synn and Albert Tetlock (who left over ‘bickering’ as you lament above). You have described the bickering as “childish” as if there isn’t a right and wrong side, just two people “feuding”, right? Except…what is this here? Oh, I’m sure we can all rationalize why this is “different” and why its ok in this instance to use inflammatory language, the logic seems to boil down to: if ‘I’ say it, its not inflammatory, if I bicker, its not bickering, its okay, etc. and so forth. There is actually a name for this ‘double standard’ but I won’t use the H word because its just too inflammatory, but I bet you’re now thinking of it and its raised your blood pressure. But here me out if you may.

Here is another thing I find fascinating, you skipped/ignored completely one inflammatory post to target another one. Sorry Pyeman, but I have to point out your post here (I’m not attacking either Furiosa or you, but I am making a point about the interesting dynamic of this forum).

Furiosa, you stepped over this post here, after you clicked the “like” button no less:

As i've said here before i don't want to see any rider get injured, but a nice little low speed front tuck on the grass again would be good...

Furiosa, You don’t think this might be “inflammatory” to a Rossi fan? I don’t like Rossi much myself, but you don’t think expressing a desire for a crash might be fodder Vudu, Danski, Synn, or other Rossi fans? But you “liked’ this post, then as you stepped over it you went right after Vudu’s predictable reaction and added something rather inflammatory to him ”I despair at fuckwits like you[Vudu]”, I really do. What a ....... low, inflammatory thing to say.

Fascinating, especially when you add in Theo’s indignation

What a load of bollox, people know it happens, but we don't go to see them die.

Keep in mind, Theo expressed a desire that Rossi had died instead of Simonchelli. (A post that wasn’t chastised with the same harsh language that Furiosa, Pyeman, or any other people chiming in over the this bickering here). But let me point out something else that is fascinating, this kind of dynamic then gives license for others to chime in with “inflammatory” language…


Another mind reader. :rolleyes:

The rest are ludicrous straw man ........ from someone who has twisted...

Hamburger anyone?


Furiosa, keep in mind, Kesh actually mocked me when I pointed out Theo wishing death on Rossi. Interestingly, the level of hostile reaction to Vudu’s protest over anyone wishing ‘his’ favorite rider crash out hasn’t reached the level of hostile reaction against what Kesh has been doing, or what Theo said. Why? (It’s a rhetorical question).

Furiosa , do you feel I’m attacking you or Pyeman? I’ll know soon enough from your reaction to my post. Here is why I’m taking the time to detail my response to you (and Pyeman below). You reacted hostilely to Vudu over his theory that people watch the TT as a blood sport, that is, your reaction expressed anger at him making a theory about something you hold dear. Vudu is a “.......” according to you. Not much different than what Kesh has been doing with me, is it. Albeit, relentlessly and disconnected from any logic or self-control. But you haven’t taken the time to see there is an identifiable ‘right and wrong’ to our conflict, but rather its just “childish bickering” to you, both sides equally. You have done the forum a disservice by characterizing it this way, as it gives license to the perpetrator for the bickering to go on. It seemed great when Kesh was chasing Synn around, after all he is about as popular as Vudu. When I called out Kesh for klogging the threads, there wasn’t a senior member to call him to stop “bickering” and klogging up threads despite him being the senior member. Now this thread has been derailed, and I’d like to point out, before my post here, so you can’t actually blame me. ‘We get the forum we deserve.’


What a ....... .... you are,i went every year because … not seeing people die,you are a complete .... and a disgrace to this forum and this is the last time i will reply to the utter .... you speak

Pyeman, I don’t think it was unpredictable that a Rossi fan would react to you in this way, given that you wished VR ‘harmlessly crash’ (harmless or not, its inflammatory and you should have expected a reaction. There is you and I are sitting as friends talking .... at the bar saying .... Rossi, but when you post it here, well its fair game.) Its not really a debate about the TT, rather it’s a reaction by a Rossi fan who adversely reacted to you expressing his guy crash out. I shouldn’t have to feel sorry to point this out actually, but I’ll say sorry Pyeman to point this out, I’m not attacking you, but rather the predictable reaction was, well predictable, as it should be; imagine say Vudu posting he hopes ‘Marc crashes out’. I could see it now, the entire forum might ‘crash’ from the hostile replies to Vudu (sorry about the pun, I’ll get my coat).

We get the forum we deserve. We may likely be pointing out the boos on this very thread if Marc is on the podium (or cheers if he crashes out at Jerez, or anywhere else for that matter). Its not enough to say “stop the bickering”, equating it to a “feud” with no right or wrong, take the time to see if there really is a right and wrong. Much like Oxley trying to distance himself from the adverse reactions to Marc on the podium, as he if wasn’t partly responsible for creating this dynamic. Spade a spade. Kesh has relentlessly been klogging up the thread, even trolling his own non-trolling thread. The only guy to call him out up until that moment (before I did in the Qatar thread) was Albert Tatlock. He is now gone, perhaps realizing this forum is burned, or as Furiosa says “sucked all the fun out”. Kesh of course was encouraged by a few members, particularly Barry Machine. Then three more members chimed in asking Kesh to stop klogging threads, Danski, Barbwireriderr, and me, immediately Kesh reacted negatively. Granted, Kesh then conducted two flame wars simultaneously. I don’t see a reason to stop point this out, as when I read a reference to Kesh attacking others being characterized in ‘general’ terms as “bickering” and “feud” I feel compelled to point out the disservice this has on the forum at best, the double standard at worst.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person

Recent Discussions