Joined Oct 2006
25K Posts | 4K+
Your Mom's House
To get back to the point: Could someone else fulfil the role that Puig plays in MotoGP? Yes they could. However, the problem is that nobody has stepped forward to do so. Puig was not asked to run the Red Bull Rookies Cup, he schemed, pressured and manipulated behind the scenes to make it happen. In fact, he pushed for the RB Rookies to happen because the Grand Prix Academy was producing so many Spaniards, and he understood (along with Ezpeleta) that the series needs more nationalities.
So why are there so many Spaniards in the series? Is this down to Puig? To my mind, the dominance of the Spaniards is caused by the growing importance of the Spanish 125cc championship. ...
The CEV has become the de facto talent pool for 125cc (and now Moto2) talent, because it's well organized, well funded, has a full and active schedule and a highly competitive field. The fact that Dorna runs it suggests that they understand how to run a racing series, and make money out of it. ...
You say that there are many others who would like to get involved and could do Puig's job. True, but why isn't Kenny Sr running a similar program? Kevin Schwantz - to his credit - got involved in the RBR in the US, and is now fully involved in the international RBR. But why isn't Giacomo Agostini or Marco Lucchinelli running an Italian talent-scouting program? Why isn't Niall Mackenzie, Carl Fogarty or Neil Hodgson running a British program? Where's Jean-Philippe Ruggia or Jean-Michel Bayle?
Apparently they cannot muster either the enthusiasm, motivation, funding or organizational skills to put such a program together. Puig can, and has. Talk is cheap among old motorcycle racers, around the paddock and across the internet, but actually getting off your arse and organizing .... is much much tougher. Puig did so, others haven't.
Yes, Puig is an arsehole, and a manipulative, lying, scheming troll. But he gets .... done. Now, Hitler built one of the most remarkable networks of roads the world has ever seen, and made the trains run on time. The question you have to ask is, do you want the trains to run on time or not? If you don't want Puig to be running things, that's fine, but they won't get done if he doesn't do them, because nobody is stepping up to take his place. And those that could step up to take his place are just as evil, scheming and manipulative. The paddock isn't full of great, honest, hard-working people all ready to pull together and make the world a better place for motorcycle racing. It's full of lying, conniving, thieving, scheming, incompetent, back-stabbing scum out to make a quick buck. It also contains a surprisingly large number of competent and likable people, though as I have an extraordinarily low opinion of human beings, any number greater than zero qualifies as "surprisingly large." The reason for my low opinion of the human race, I might add, is basing my opinion on myself. If I'm the last, best hope of mankind, we're .......
Thanks for the great reply Kropo. We have learned much through your insider perspective. I think we agree for the most part on the Puig question in regards to his qualities of moral character, its just sitting from my vantage point (admittedly a very distant one), I’m not so willing to give the dude a pass in any form (not that you are, but I think we both have an understanding). Regarding the Stalin etal analogy, it served its purpose in our exchange, and really the analogy only serves as a very broad comparison of which I see you could appreciate. Most often people fall into the trap of saying how outrageous it is to compare these infamous historical figures to anything, especially the ones we were comparing them to, eh.
Regarding the lack of others stepping up, I’m not so sure it’s just a matter of willingness & tenacity as you say, though I'm sure you are right that this is a big part; but rather I contend another major obstacle is access & suitability, I have a theory. I think Carmelo etal are not gonna loosen their strangle hold & control on the series to include some former racer they cannot fully control. KRSR had many aspirations for the series; but he was not given much attention, and…the man has very little tolerance for games & ........ (suitability conflict). Schwantz ran a good deal for the Americas RC, but unfortunately it was eliminated, the ........ reason, Red Bull’s lack of funding. Red Bull, who sponsors both American GPs, a valuable market, decided on their own it was untenable to continue their support of the cup here? I think the Euro cup simply wanted to maintain all the prestige and control (my speculation). But that’s neither here nor there, as I think these guys know that trying to garner any support from Dorna will be next to impossible for these former racers, especially the ones who are unwilling to play by Dorna’s corrupt conventions.
It seems, as you correctly describe, the business of this particular business is pretty dubious; a foul laissez-fair corporate culture not suited for gentlemen of a strong moral character, an environment best suited to spawn the Puigs and Suppos of the world (that is not to say there are no good guys, that would be equally naive, as I'm sure you would agree). BTW, I think your view of corporate business is right on point! Some people are too naïve to realize that an overwhelming majority of these entities strive to accumulate wealth & power by any means possible. Interestingly, as sport mimics life (or is it the other way around) the machine of big business is so savvy & powerful to have even convinced many of these naive types to cast their support and vote against their own self interest. Yes, we are ......!