MotoGP: TT Assen; Predictions, build up, practice and qualifying but not the race.

MotoGP Forum

Help Support MotoGP Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
bluegreen
3549521372455691

I agree. When JLo went down it was his own fault, nobody around and he was trailing Pedro in the points after all these Yamaha tracks when he hit the dirt.


But significantly Cal downplayed his first pole acknowledging the absence of Jorge. If Lorenzo doesn't race and carries the ill effects of the injury through Sachsenring and possibly Laguna then if the title goes to Pedrosa right or wrong, part of me will consider it a pyrrhic victory.


 


The history of Moto GP and WSB is replete with such examples. I always considered Hodgson's 2003 title hollow given the departure of so many factory teams and riders. 


 


Ultimately though, if a rider is eliminated from contention it is still down to the remaining title protagonists to win races, podium or remain consistent. Pedrosa is riding better than he ever has since his 250 days.
 
Arrabbiata1
3549541372457027

But significantly Cal downplayed his first pole acknowledging the absence of Jorge. If Lorenzo doesn't race and carries the ill effects of the injury through Sachsenring and possibly Laguna then if the title goes to Pedrosa right or wrong, part of me will consider it a pyrrhic victory.


 


The history of Moto GP and WSB is replete with such examples. I always considered Hodgson's 2003 title hollow given the departure of so many factory teams and riders. 


 


Ultimately though, if a rider is eliminated from contention it is still down to the remaining title protagonists to win races, podium or remain consistent. Pedrosa is riding better than he ever has since his 250 days.


 


Cal is showing what a class act he is, that made me like him even more.


 


I see your point. The problem as I see it is there are different degrees of this. If Jlo is gone for 5 races and MM takes himself out of 3 or 4 then yeah, kind of an empty WC, through no fault of Pedrosa, but if George starts from 12th one race injured from his own mistake and Dani continues to ride the way he has been on his way to a WC. Full points in my book. It's on Lorenzo not Dani for Lorenzo to show up, quali and race healthy.
 
lil red rocket pilot
3549531372456024

I agree with the first sentence.


 


But the second!


Man this ain't preschool!


That sorta .... should not happen!


 


Red, what second sentence?  :)
 
Pedrosa is riding better than he ever has since his 250 days.

This sentiment has been repeated lately. I humbly submit this inquiry to u my respected friend: What has changed to make him ride so great? He never had it better AND thats saying something! Not that he hasnt been on the most powerful and consistently competitive seat in the paddock; but this situation has been even more leeched out. Best bike hands down against an anemic field of win worthy bikes so depleted that one injured among them puts him in title management mode, as indicated by his lack of haste to get back out in Q. For comparison sake what did the 3 other challengers (that is--riders on competitive bikes) do recently after a fall in Q? All 3 got back out there straight away (Cal, Lorenzo, and Marc). Pedro is in management mode already and he was thinking this as he 'took the gloves off ', ironically not in the 'fighting' sense.

I ask again, what has changed that he is riding so impressive now? Because to my armchair biased ass, it seems that he started to "ride better" exactly when his then teammate was injured coinciding with HRC putting together such a superior bike that afforded him a clear advantage at Brno last year...and hes been riding "better" since. Competing against a snot nosed rookie, albeit talented yet still a rookie serves to also mask this notion that Pedro is riding "better". I fully suspect he'd still be second fiddle to last year's teamnate. Im not convinced anything other than the circumstances of the competitive environment surrounding him has changed . But...it doesn't much matter. Hes got the edge on the title now, and the debate is of no consequence.

As u said buddy, history is repleat with the names of riders with the tenacity to ride injured. Great memories of the 02 Wsbk season today. Bayliss riding with a broken collarbone keeping his championship alive (after colliding with hiz teammate no less, haha). And memories of Edwards winning race 2 at Laguna, the beginning of the final push to win back the title (and other unmentionable memories. Btw, oddly enuf, Nitro is wildcarding at Imola this weekend). Speaking of Imola, I encourage any of u reading this post, do urself a favor and watch the Thrilla of Imola 2002 Wsbk finale.

Im not so sure Pedro is as "fragile" as we've been led to believe, I just dont think hes made of the same superior mettle as his colleagues, who display superhuman determination. He was content to watch his colleagues put their ass on the line as they all dropped him from pole. One of those riding with broken bits and surely in much pain. I hope playing it conservative this early bites him in the ass.

Flubber Pedro and the pony he rode in.
 
Not fragile?

Have you seen his list of injuries? Makes Schwantz' look wussy.
 
Pedro has taken his fair share of injuries, and I'd be surprised if he could actually finish a season without breaking something, and you've got to have big brass ones or a short memory to get back on a bike that can have an electrical glitch at any moment and try to kill. Speaking of memory mine's a little shot at the moment but, isn't it around race 10-12 that Pedro's title hopes are normally gone every season due to injury.
 
bluegreen
3549581372458672

Red, what second sentence?  :)


 


I have no fcuking idea!


I must stop posting drunk.


At least i don't have to appologise  to anyone this time ;)


 


My rant was referring to the pic I think.
 
Lorenzo declared FIT for warm up,


Re-assessment to be performed prior to race.


 


That guy is a robot, Pretty sure he has some Energizer batteries up his ass, keeps on going and going and going
 
shovelhead
3549751372488823

Lorenzo declared FIT for warm up,

Re-assessment to be performed prior to race.

 

That guy is a robot, Pretty sure he has some Energizer batteries up his ass, keeps on going and going and going


Impressive seems too weak a word...
 
in case u didnt know motogp LIVE BBC Red button only 11am-3pm freeview ch301 and sky / freesat Red button & ONLINE
 
Jorge cleared to race. My thoughts - not great to want to stay in it and not lose points but will this make full recovery longer? Will it cost him points in the end? Is he just doing it to introduce a new engine then retire? Hmmmm...
 
Jumkie
3549621372465326

This sentiment has been repeated lately. I humbly submit this inquiry to u my respected friend: What has changed to make him ride so great? He never had it better AND thats saying something! Not that he hasnt been on the most powerful and consistently competitive seat in the paddock; but this situation has been even more leeched out. Best bike hands down against an anemic field of win worthy bikes so depleted that one injured among them puts him in title management mode, as indicated by his lack of haste to get back out in Q. For comparison sake what did the 3 other challengers (that is--riders on competitive bikes) do recently after a fall in Q? All 3 got back out there straight away (Cal, Lorenzo, and Marc). Pedro is in management mode already and he was thinking this as he 'took the gloves off ', ironically not in the 'fighting' sense. I ask again, what has changed that he is riding so impressive now? Because to my armchair biased ass, it seems that he started to "ride better" exactly when his then teammate was injured coinciding with HRC putting together such a superior bike that afforded him a clear advantage at Brno last year...and hes been riding "better" since. Competing against a snot nosed rookie, albeit talented yet still a rookie serves to also mask this notion that Pedro is riding "better". I fully suspect he'd still be second fiddle to last year's teamnate. Im not convinced anything other than the circumstances of the competitive environment surrounding him has changed . But...it doesn't much matter. Hes got the edge on the title now, and the debate is of no consequence. As u said buddy, history is repleat with the names of riders with the tenacity to ride injured. Great memories of the 02 Wsbk season today. Bayliss riding with a broken collarbone keeping his championship alive (after colliding with hiz teammate no less, haha). And memories of Edwards winning race 2 at Laguna, the beginning of the final push to win back the title (and other unmentionable memories. Btw, oddly enuf, Nitro is wildcarding at Imola this weekend). Speaking of Imola, I encourage any of u reading this post, do urself a favor and watch the Thrilla of Imola 2002 Wsbk finale. Im not so sure Pedro is as "fragile" as we've been led to believe, I just dont think hes made of the same superior mettle as his colleagues, who display superhuman determination. He was content to watch his colleagues put their ass on the line as they all dropped him from pole. One of those riding with broken bits and surely in much pain. I hope playing it conservative this early bites him in the ass. Flubber Pedro and the pony he rode in.


As with Valentino I've never been Dani's greatest apologist based on the way he has acquitted himself in the top class and admittedly clouded by my limited perceptions of him as a person. Ultimately though, none of us know the real Dani Pedrosa. Indeed most paddock insiders know nothing of the real Dani Pedrosa who like Stoner is somewhat of an estranged enigma and man that prefers to keep his private life entirely separate to the racetrack. Inevitably though we try to surmise what is unfolding behind the black visor and the steely gaze.


 


From memory, Dani was leading the race at Indy, not sure what year, probably 2009, and he crashed out and remounted. Someone posted that for that reason it was an incredible gutsy ride and I responded in a way that practically mirrors you sentiments here adding that this was nothing remarkable or atypical - negligible damage to bike and no injury, that's what these guys do.


 


An eighth year on a full factory Honda without delivering the title however is remarkable. It's not simply attributed to his relationship with Repsol; fate has unquestionably played into Dani's hands -  the retirement of Casey, the tragic passing of Marco and I would also venture the untimely death of Daijiro have all contrived to forge that indelible signature and an infinitely renewable self perpetuating HRC contract...but then, of the other riders available - who else would you have placed on that machine?


 


He has also been the ill fated victim of a series of bizarre accidents and injuries which have without doubt cruelly scuppered his championship preparation or campaign. No point in mulling over the minutiae of these circumstances, most that have followed the sport closely will be amply aware of the events surrounding them.


 


There is no question that the MSMA, driven by HRC ushered in the 800cc debacle and that the loathsome RC212v was designed around Dani and a myopic 'vision' / future strategy which at the time anticipated similarly diminutive drones to pilot a smaller, stabler, more agile and nimbler Honda. In effect they tried to 'out yam' Yamaha and not for the first time in their history - got it hopelessly wrong. there would be my first contention with your argument. No, Dani has not 'consistently been on "the most powerful and consistently competitive seat" in the series, that is simply fallacious and inaccurate. Based upon his career also spanning the 125 and 250 classes I may well be inclined to agree with you.


 


You say that Dani's run of wins in the second half of the season was very much attributed to the superiority of the machinery...it also worked the other way. This time last year Honda were fighting back. Watch footage of Dani wrestling the RCV out of Geert Timmer - a bike still completely in disharmony with the new softer carcass tyre. HRC eventually found the solution as they tend to do via a gazillion chassis revisions and a minor change to the cush drive which cost pennies. Not before Laguna though. The Sachsenring race which preceded it was one of Pedrosa's most commanding rides to date. 


 


People talk of Jorge's 'metronomic precision' actually overlooking the fact that in style Dani is very similar. The Honda demands an adaptation almost a compromising of that style. I have always maintained that and I seriously believe although there are huge variables involved, notionally if you placed Dani on the M1 and Jorge on the RCV - Pedro would immediately and initially fare better that Jorge on the Honda despite the fact that I percieve the latter to be stronger mentally and physically.


 


Dani is renowned as a confidence rider, we know that, but the Pedrosa that I contend has come of age (admittedly after eight seasons on a factory honda), is a Pedrosa that is more inclined to ride strategically around problems and contrary to what you say, stronger mentally and physically. To say that Dani is riding better than he has since his 250 days is moot because performances in different classes are simply not comparable. What I should have said is that Dani reminds now more of that commanding and self assured figure that made the class his own in 2004 and 2005. 


 


During the wonderful battle with Lorenzo at Brno last year, in spite of his advantage up horsepower hill, Dani was losing time in the first sector and noticeably down on the Yamaha overall. Watch the race again if you can. Mid way through he reduced the TC which was sapping to much power and rode the rest of the race sideways like Stoner. I have always resolutely insisted that the Honda, punch and grunt out of corners and seamless shift aside, is a more challenging motorcycle to ride and find and exploit the limit than the M1. Dani adapts very well and like Stoner, has been able to modify his riding around the bike...something we have not necessarily seen Lorenzo do since his move to the Premier Class.


 


Pedrosa also seems less freaked by fairing bashing these days. In 125 the psychotic Stefano Perugini was a continual thorn in his side while the 250 class in 2005 resembled the carnage of WSS. Forget Bautista, need I remind you that the Jorge of old was a deranged cross between Marquez, Simoncelli and at worse, Kenan ......' <span style="font-size:14px;<span style="font-family:arial, sans-serif;Sofuoğlu. Pedrosa was completely unfazed by the competition..in 125 much to the irritation of Puig he was renowned for cooly toying with the pack before eventually pulling the pin.


 


<span style="font-size:14px;<span style="font-family:arial, sans-serif;Don't agree with this ........ that Marquez (snotty nosed rookie?????) has been given stern instructions to give Pedrosa room, ride shotgun or even accede to team orders. Dani couldn't catch Jorge at Catalunya but he could hold off Marc..which he did brilliantly. Again, what was once his achilles heel is an aspect of his riding which has 'changed to make him great'. Like I said in the Catalunya race thread...


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


Arrabbiata1
3540221371479675

As I say, Catalunya is a tough circuit to make a pass but I also think we need to give Dani some kudos here. Jorge was able to control the race very well and when Dani closed him down, he responded. Towards the end it was less about catching Lorenzo..(far less passing him) and more about taking defensive lines which Dani does brilliantly. It is no coincidence that the rider in the current field regarded as the most difficult to pass aside from Vale is Dani. In fact ask the Doctor himself and that's the response you'll get in spite of the fact that two years ago Rossi only had to show him a wheel and he'd crumble like a polverone.



 


<span style="font-size:14px;<span style="font-family:arial, sans-serif;Also don't agree with your view that Pedrosa pulled the gloves off yesterday in qualifying. He knows he's got the speed. Dani likes to build progressively over the weekend besides, I don't believe he had time for a second run at him. He knew his time was good enough to allow the hole-shot today. 


 


The Honda isn't as balanced a motorcycle as the M1, but it has greater strengths if you can find them. I do believe however alongside Jorge, that Dani is the most balanced rider in the field in all aspects of his riding, race craft and strategic management of his season. In addition to that, with the added shift to Honda circuits as the season progresses the scales are tipping in his favour irrespective of the disproportionate relative weighting that you subjectively and selectively assign to those factors perceived to influence this advantage. 
 
Mick D
3549891372498383

Jorge cleared to race. My thoughts - not great to want to stay in it and not lose points but will this make full recovery longer? Will it cost him points in the end? Is he just doing it to introduce a new engine then retire? Hmmmm...


Thats what im thinking. Use there last couple of engines, then start from pit road on the new one, do one ;lap  then retire. If he starts from pit road, we will know.
 
He may as well take the new engine in any event.  If he needs to start from the pit lane to get one, do it.


 


Assuming he can ride at all, he'll no doubt work his way past most of the pack.  Given how strung out the field is, a pit-lane start shouldn't cost more than a handful of points.
 
AnnoyingTwit
3549231372444991

I'm not convinced. Which rookies on Japanese factory or satellite bikes have done worse than Smith in the last few years?


 


He's doing better than Spies and Barbera were at the same time last year. And they weren't rookies.


 


He has more points than Simoncelli or Crutchlow in 2011, at the same point in the championship.


 


He has more points than Espargaro in 2010, at the same point in the championships.


 


He has more points than Toseland, Hayden, Gibernau, Kallio in 2009, at the same point in the championships.


 


He has more points than Hopkins, Melandri, De Puniet in 2009, at the same point in the championships.
 
 
So, to answer your question: "Which rookies on Japanese factory or satellite bikes have done worse than Smith in the last few years?" - Simoncelli, Crutchlow, Kallio, Toseland, Espargaro 
 
To answer the other question: Which World Champions on Japanese factory or satellite bikes have done worse than Smith in the last few years? - Hayden, Spies, Gibernau, Simoncelli, Crutchlow,  
 
Not doing too bad, is he? Not bad at all.
 
Espargaro only did 4 races in 2009
 
Pigeon
3549321372448618

found a firefox chrome add on "mediahint"


a browser add on that lets you watch tv content from other countrys


BBC (Cough) i just watched some hulu content ok which i shouldnt be able too as a rule


if it works for anyone you should get glastonbury all weekend


http://www.bbc.co.uk/events/ej58q9#p01b85kl


 


I tried to add it to Chrome - it just doesn't show up... I followed their instructions, but no dice.
 
Lorenzo to start, Dovizioso and Barberian to get a point each. The world continues, however, to turn.
 
mtorn
3550111372512505



 

He's doing better than Spies and Barbera were at the same time last year. And they weren't rookies.

 

He has more points than Simoncelli or Crutchlow in 2011, at the same point in the championship.

 

He has more points than Espargaro in 2010, at the same point in the championships.

 

He has more points than Toseland, Hayden, Gibernau, Kallio in 2009, at the same point in the championships.

 

He has more points than Hopkins, Melandri, De Puniet in 2009, at the same point in the championships.

 

 

So, to answer your question: "Which rookies on Japanese factory or satellite bikes have done worse than Smith in the last few years?" - Simoncelli, Crutchlow, Kallio, Toseland, Espargaro 

 

To answer the other question: Which World Champions on Japanese factory or satellite bikes have done worse than Smith in the last few years? - Hayden, Spies, Gibernau, Simoncelli, Crutchlow,  

 

Not doing too bad, is he? Not bad at all.

 

Espargaro only did 4 races in 2009


We seem to have a new Wiki king....
 

Recent Discussions

Recent Discussions

Back
Top