Good read. He uses Stoner as the standard, and he is right, as they are all "far from the best". But given that Nicky is on Rossi's ... week in week out on what is suppose to be less equipment, I'd say Hayden is "close to the 2nd best". Rainey did say Nicky give his maximum. So given Nicky's eternal 2nd fiddle status when it comes to equipment and clout, I'd say he's shown to be pretty good.
He was much more harsh on Edwards and Spies though. Saying Edwards had outlasted his welcome and Spies not being aggressive enough has got to hurt. As Pov said above, I'd rather a legend say the talent is the issue, as he suggests with Nicky. But not having the "guts", well, if that doesn't but foot to ... for Spies, then nothing will.
Rainey's chastise on race direction for Sic's penalty should make those who called for Butler's resignation happy, and I agree. It should also be a slap to Pedro and Lorenzo who wanted Sic to be burned at the stake.
Rainey had some great takes, though I see it a bit different. Regarding Stoner, he's right on the money. I think Stoner, as a rider, is the only alien, or as Rainey described it "a rider from another time". He also touches on Stoner's social skills in saying that nothing else much matters to Casey. I wouldn't expect Mr. Rainey to call Stoner a whiner, but I think Schwantz did ro came close to it. Regarding Spies, I personally think Spies has the guts. What I think may be seen by Mr. Rainey a lack of aggressiveness is perhaps more a willingness for Spies to make clean passing or resort to dangerous tactics. Spies almost never concedes a pass once he attempts it, and I have seen this repeated several times. There is a sequence that I think typifies Spies style of racing, if you care to look up a sequence in Race 1 WSBK 2009 Assen; you will see Spies and Haslam go through a series of turns neither willing to concede but neither willing to resort to dirty racing. Regarding his take on Nicky, I think a follow up question should have been the parity, or lack there of regarding darling rider influence. The lesson of 2011 highlights the ramifications of talent and equipment combination. As far as Edwards, sure he may have stayed too long, but who was beating him? Edwards was never going to have the clout of a Spanish or Italian rider. Edwards being Rossi's teammate was a role rather than an attempt to win a title. I'd say once Edwards was relegated to the Tech3, then he stayed too long.
I've met Wayne Rainey, and I can honestly say, he left a life long impression on me. I've also watched others meet him, and I see that they have had a similar experience when they walk away. Its almost like if there is an energy that beams from his eyes and pieces your soul. I'm not embellishing either, as I know others here have felt the same way when they have met the man.