I guess we can agree to disagree. If a person's pension is bad - it's because A. He didn't earn enough or B - someone in the organization he worked for stole from the pension fund. I'm well familiar with this stuff. I was in unions (including the Teamsters) from the time I was 19 till when I started my own business at 42.
Re: taxes - generally speaking the tax rate is commensurate with degree of public services offered by local government. NY State offers social services, programs for seniors, for children, after-school programs, business training programs, arts programs etc etc etc that are not parallelled in places like Florida or Arkansas.
If a person is 85 years old, living on a tiny pension and SS and doesn't much go out of the house, they don't care about the quality of schools or arts programs and so on. I get that.
I've got lots of friends who've moved down to Mexico because they just didn't earn enough to retire in NY. I moved up to Rockland County a few years ago because I'd been in NYC for more than 50 years and it's lost it's appeal, and I'm happy up where I am which is very rural with lots of farmland - but I still end up driving into NYC to hear bands, and world music, go to the theater and get authentic food from Thailand, Vietnam, Malaysia, China, Venezuela, Paris, Germany, Poland etc that you will never find in Florida or much of anywhere outside a cosmopolitan city - and cities cost more money to run than suburbs.
There's folks around here who in all there life have never been more than 75 miles away from home. And they're happy. That's all good. They mostly never read a book and couldn't find China on a map. They don't know what they've missed out on by their lack of curiosity, but they're happy enough all the same, and I get along with my neighbors just great. But when I tell them I've just come back from 6 weeks of touring Vietnam and Cambodia on a motorcycle they just kind of give me a blank look like I must be some kind of eccentric. I reckon that sort of dull lack of interest in the wider world is a direct result of a lesser education system and local government that doesn't support arts and cultural exchange. And when provincial types are on occasion exposed to people with a wider range of cultural engagement they sometimes think of those people as "elitist". But being elite in itself is not a negative thing. MotoGp racers are an elite and so are top people in any sport or field of education.