Joan is mentally stronger and more consistent, but relatively speaking, Mav has the numbers. He has twice as many career wins, and, [cherrypick] Vinales has 10 times as many wins in the premier class.[/cherrypick].I'd say Mir is the best rider without a 2025 contract. Mav is on his last leg. If he goes to Honda thats game over for him.
Mir is a world-champ, and he's probably a better fit for Honda, but on equal, functional equipment (not HRC), I think Mav would prevail.