2024 silly season!
- Thread starter #22
- Start date
Help Support MotoGP Forum:
- Joined
- May 13, 2009
- Messages
- 6,313
- Location
- Shovel's Club
This is ....... absurd, LOL.
No way Ducati would accept this. Yes Gresini has the final say but they would certainly hurt their relationship with Ducati forever.
- Joined
- Oct 17, 2008
- Messages
- 5,926
- Location
- In Cider
Interesting point.
- Joined
- Mar 27, 2023
- Messages
- 1,107
- Location
- Australia
I know everybody here seems to be obsessed with MM to Ducati. Of course it would be interesting to see the results of such a move. Not sure it would be that great for MM, but it will keep the interest up.
Bastiannini and Morbidelli do not seem to have bounced back from the big injuries. In Franky’s case it’s already been a couple of years. I can’t see why anybody would want him on their bike. Rare are the athletes who can come back from major issues. A Doohan they don’t seem to be. No matter which bike.
Bastiannini and Morbidelli do not seem to have bounced back from the big injuries. In Franky’s case it’s already been a couple of years. I can’t see why anybody would want him on their bike. Rare are the athletes who can come back from major issues. A Doohan they don’t seem to be. No matter which bike.
- Joined
- Sep 14, 2015
- Messages
- 734
- Location
- Office cubicle
I'm worried about Rins as well, he's has got plenty of injuries and bounced back well but the latest one is no joke. And his Yamaha contract only runs for one year, it's a risky move.
Yeah but unless Gresini want to ride Honda bikes in 2025, they won’t upset the factory.
I’m hearing that the contract may be tough to break but can’t imagine someone like MM not having some kind of performance clause, which by know I would think are standard in motorsport, especially for these big stars. So, from his language, I think he’s either staying at Honda or truly wants to help them and leave the relationship as healthy as possible…
- Joined
- May 13, 2009
- Messages
- 6,313
- Location
- Shovel's Club
With Marc on board they could probably get factory support from any of the other manufactures.
The only thing would be if Dorna is involved, as they were with Valentino going to Yamaha the first time, probably with him going to Ducati, and reputedly with Stoner going to LCR at the start of his premier class career when they wanted an Australian rider in the field.
That is the only explanation that could make sense to me for the otherwise preposterous proposition of a one year rental of MM, it would save face for Honda to some degree I guess, and if he returned and won further titles with Honda I guess he would still be predominantly a Honda icon in retirement.
Certainly if Ducati aren’t grateful to Dorna they should be, pretty much everything has favoured them in motogp for years now, particularly the concessions allowing them to develop their bike after which there was substantial freezing of development, and the control ECU iirc being from the manufacturer they were already employing . Nakamoto pretty much foresaw the problems removing the bespoke software would cause HRC and threatened to withdraw which I do recall correctly. Regulations haven’t exactly worked against Ducati in WSBK either. I am not sure MM taking secrets back to Honda would be a particular concern, riders swap between the marques all the time, and he, great as he is at actually riding, if anything has been shown to be not all that great at development and feedback to engineers etc. if he gets a 1 year old satellite bike purely to ride then he wouldn’t get recent factory secrets anyway.
I don’t know whether Dorna care, they might be happy with only European bikes on the grid for all I know, but Suzuki have left and there doesn’t look to me to be much in it for Honda and Yamaha in the premier class currently apart from humiliation. I imagine they wouldn’t want to leave on a lower note than Suzuki managed, and won’t leave in the short term for reasons of face, but that is about it. I guess they will likely hang around for a new start with the new formula, although they are returning to F1. The current focus on ride height devices and aero etc which is irrelevant to their road bikes as Lex and others have said must be hard to sell to the corporate guys. I am sure they are not going to spend a fortune on building a new engine for the dying days of this formula which is probably what they need for the current formula sans their bespoke software, another aspect which might fit with an MM rental.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Mar 27, 2023
- Messages
- 1,107
- Location
- Australia
It can be difficult for the teams to know what will happen with riders who come back from injury, will they perform as per prior injury or loose their edge?
Most riders want to be world champion, in Rin's case if he stays with LCR he has zero chance of becoming world champion
Rin's needs to take risks if he wants to be world champion
Off topic - Ducati built a road bike with WSBK regulations in mind. I don't think the way rev limits in WSBK is defined is fair between manufacturers...
Wouldn't like to see that. I recall a time when it was all Japanese bikes and Cagiva came in, the Japanese helped Cagiva (in particular Yamaha) as they didn't want a championship that was just Japanese bikes. Hopefully they will find a way to keep Honda and Yamaha in MotoGP
I changed my mind. Looking at today's result, the bike is a complete disaster, lol, you are right.
- Joined
- May 13, 2009
- Messages
- 6,313
- Location
- Shovel's Club
I knew you would come around.
Sure, Honda did it for a couple of years once, but mainly because they considered the regulations to favor Ducati's engine configuration.
Having watched WSBK for several decades if not so much now (although I did like watching Razgatlioglu in his pomp) the regulations haven't exactly generally worked against Ducati over that time, so much so that it has often been dubbed the Ducati Cup, not that I minded when Troy Bayliss was the one riding the Ducati.
- Joined
- Sep 14, 2015
- Messages
- 734
- Location
- Office cubicle
Rumors coming from Ricard Jové (who gets some things right and others wrong) is that in the wake of a possible Márquez departure, there have been contacts from Honda inquiring about the contract situation of... Maverick Viñales and Aprilia's team manager Massimo Rivola. I think the claim is a wild one to be true and also I don't know why either of them would leave for Honda, other than the economical package.
Either way, the domino pieces are falling already: Key Honda technical director exits as major reshuffle begins
If I were Honda I would offer the HRC seat to Oliveira, he's more talented and "instinctive" than Mav IMO, who needs to have everything right to go fast and takes his time to adapt, plus he has proven himself on troublesome machinery already.
Either way, the domino pieces are falling already: Key Honda technical director exits as major reshuffle begins
If I were Honda I would offer the HRC seat to Oliveira, he's more talented and "instinctive" than Mav IMO, who needs to have everything right to go fast and takes his time to adapt, plus he has proven himself on troublesome machinery already.
Max Biaggi is desperately hoping Marc leaves Honda to jump on a competitive bike. Seems like he's badly wishing Marc to slash all of Rossi's records, lol. The guy never overcame the rivalry.
MotoGP, Biaggi: "La storia tra Marquez e la Honda è arrivata al capolinea"
MotoGP, Biaggi: "La storia tra Marquez e la Honda è arrivata al capolinea"
Says the guy who has been contending the current Honda bike isn't that bad.
You mean me or Max? LoL
Each to their own was my point. It seems fairly likely you don’t want MM to surpass Valentino’s records. It is pretty much a done deal that he won’t match or surpass Rossi for premier class winsin any case btw, he needs 30 odd more wins and I really can’t see him racing for several more years to do so after all his injuries. Credit to Valentino for avoiding injury for all those years in his pomp.
Why shouldn’t Max be a fan of MM’s , who is quite definitely in the very top echelon of GP riders ever and a thrilling rider to watch. I personally found Casey Stoner, of whom Alex Criville for one seemed to be a fan perhaps partly related to being a Honda guy, even better to watch. Most of us have our favourites.and are biased one way or another..
Last edited:
Similar threads
