Well no he wouldn't be fourth if they did it tomorrow. It would be a bike he is not used to...
Who knows what would happen if he were acclimated to the bike. I still think he beats all but three guys on equal bikes. The bike alone doesn't run up front and win or contend for wins consistently, especially against the current top guys. See riders like Nicky, Dovi, and Colin. Had factory bikes, not a whole lot done with them.
Ok my friend, then give him the whole off season and the whole season (don't know why you're trying to nit pick saying he'd need some time) it's rather obvious what I'm getting at. I'm trying to get you to consider the artificial condition that we often fall for, which i think has convinced you and many Rossi is the fourth fastest, but I figure it's because he is on 1 of the 4 fastest bikes. Yet for 2 years he was no where near the front. Was he not the 4ths fastest then?
I've asked you to consider him running a Ducati or Suzuki, but you keep trying to shift back the parameter (obvious to advance your posotion, which I've seen before by others when I've posed this question) setting this condition so as to free us from the this ideation that has been set artificially. So again, if Rossi would have ran a Suzuki or Ducati ( giving him time to acclimate for say 6 months, would that satisfy you) then according to you, Rossi comes in 4th this year in any given race? Maybe even challenges for the title, as we saw this year? Im talking consistently, because Rossi is so good, he would have taken a non-RCV or non-M1 factory bike to 4th? Thats what you believe?
No, the question is NOT if all bikes are equa, that's not what I'm asking, I've specifically framed the question this way. Because I think it's ridiculous to condition ourselves to think Rossi is the 4th fastest while at the same time recognizing, as I am assuming you do, that there were 4 bikes head and shoulders above the rest--as we all should have starkly understood from the Valencia display. In fact if each of the factory M1s/RCVs bikes could all start from the back and they would all end up 1 2 3 4. No doubt!
Had Rossi stayed at Ducati for 5 years do you think the 5th year when undoubtedly he would be finishing outside the top 10 or outside the top 8 you would have declared that he was fourth fastest? I seriously doubt it. And that's what happens to many of us who are conditioned to believe the finishing order has less to do with the parity.
And let's not pretend Nicky, Dovi, and Edwards had carte blanche to challenge as the number one rider. Even the year Nicky won he was on an Evo. Edwards was happy being Rossis ...... No, not while their teammates were Rossi/Pedrosa, who had all the political clout during their stint. If anything should have been apparent to you these last two weeks, politics makes a big difference, if not all the difference!
So again, if Rossi were on a Ducati or Suzuki, everything else the same, (given enough time to get used to it, etc.) where does Rossi finish in your estimation?
Edit: by far one of the best lines I've ever read on this forum, was from JKD, in response to a member starting a thread, 'the next step for Ducati is an alien, to which JKD retorted: "the next step for an alien is a factory Honda or Yamaha.