I'd agree with this if he weren't on the Ducati all this time. Talent can get you just so far on a .... machine.
Over the same period:
Stoner - 23 wins, 42 podiums, 21 poles, 20 fastest laps.
Yeah, talent that seems to be lacking in Hayden.
Even if I extend it to the more years he spent at Honda than just the last 3 with Ducati, his results are worse than a single Stoner, Pedrosa or Lorenzo season, apart from podiums - he has averaged 2.5 a season...
Sorry, I just don't see how criticism of him is any different to that of any other rider. It seems that Bradley Smith is the subject of some negativity regarding his form on the Tech 3, Hayden has six years of bad form... but criticism is unfounded?
IMO he's past it. Even given a factory Yamaha or Honda he would be struggling to hang with the top 4. Even at the top of his game he wasn't that good, and now age is catching up with him as well.
In his entire GP career he has amassed 3 wins. That's in 11 years in the paddock (come the end of the season - unless I am being previous and he is going to magic a win out of his arse before the end of the year?). Approbation is heaped on other riders with similar figures but for some reason Hayden is off limits?
Nah - his criticism is deserved. While he has had team-mates tearing up the track on the same equipment he has bumbled about in mid-field. 8, 6, 13, 7, 8 his his last five championship placings... nothing there that demands I cut him any more slack than the rest of the riders not doing their pedigree any justice. After all, as we are so often reminded, he is a world champion. He barely scraped ahead of Edwards last year... not the form we expect from world champions on factory bikes.