Next time you get sick as a dog and can't get out of bed, send me the x-ray that proves you are sick.
Come on compa, are broken bones and MRI's of soft tissue damage the only health problems you can believe because? We were comparing the difference in people believing Stoner's illness with Rossi's shoulder, remember. You 'chose' to believe one but not the other, yet the evidence that you have for both is remarkably the same. Infact, I haven't heard that much technical specifics of Rossi's shoulder except him telling us he injured it. It wasn't until GP was originally to go to Motegi did we hear much about it. We then started to hear about it periodically, and now, its quiet constant. Again, the similarity of Stoner's and Rossi's potential season ending sabbatical is remarkably similar. But according to you Stoner's is shrouded in mystery and suspect because you don't have proof positive?
Bottom line, answer this, do you believe Stoner was lying about his illness and its severity, yes or no? If the answer is no, the argument ends. If you say yes, then you need to produce the MRI scan of Rossi's shoulder.