This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Soup Interview Casey Stoner

<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Jumkie @ Jan 22 2010, 09:37 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Is anybody here (preferably a Rossi bopper ie. Inam, Talpa, Fish, etc.; willing to admit going off track at the Corkscrew is a mistake?

me... on page 5... see my post
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (jazkat @ Jan 23 2010, 02:03 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>ummm didnt we come to some sort of agreement over this?

there really is no need for these kind of arguments....

here is my take:

Yes rossi made a "mistake" by going in to hot....he seen an opening and miscalculated the breaking sequence ended up running into the gravel...was it on purpose?....NO...
Did stoner nudge rossi... YES...was it on purpose... NO...he was trying to overtake while holding the line to take the corner going around the outside.

i will be honest as i can and say stoner running into the gravel was his own fault...he also went in to hot but i think that was because rossi made him furious because of the corkscrew inccident, stoner was prob thinking rossi done it on purpose, but i believe rossi didnt as no one will play games at that speed.

i believe if rossi had not of made that "mistake" stoner wouldnt have not run into the gravel and then it would have been a 50/50 chance of either winning... like rossi and lorenzo @ catalunya.

everyone makes errors i have done it on motox bikes many times....when you see a chance you have to take it when adrenaline is running high but it always doesnt work out.... so on the day both riders made mistakes as they are human after all and errors can be made.

so there you have it, settled.....rossi made the first "mistake" and stoner made mistakes of his own.

i have been as unbiased as possible...so if you cant see it how i explained it you need help!!
<
<
<

This is pretty much my take. My main reason for participating in this and previous threads is to point out to those calling stoner a "....." is that stoner has some grounds for complaint whether or not he was wise to do so, particularly since the rossi "mistake" seems to me to be the one where there was the most risk of a dangerous collision and the one requiring evasive action by the other rider. If rossi had actually said something conciliatory about the corkscrew incident initially maybe stoner would not have been so steamed.
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (michaelm @ Jan 23 2010, 10:45 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Even if this is due to stoner moving in on rossi rather than rossi moving out on stoner as jumkie (who has the advantage of actually being at the race and knowing the track intimately) says, it hardly compares with the corkscrew where rossi forced stoner from one side of the track to the other, oddly without stoner putting an elbow into him despite his dastardly behaviour immediately before
<
. The way stoner's bike is leaned over suggests he is thinking about getting around the corner rather than moving in on rossi, so if the contact was caused by him it seems likely it was a mistake, albeit a smaller one than rossi's at the corkscrew.

This is a bit absurd, at the Corkscrew VR was already passed (as he had done on at least 1 other occasion in this race) and missed the apex by 1/2 a meter, now seeing as the corkscrew is probably the most famous corner in motorcycle racing at present because of the fact that you can't see the apex as it follows a 3-4 meter sheer drop, then all things considered at race pace in Motogp in a battle for the lead, this is a mistake-sure, but not as big as you all make out-depending on your POV.

CS's 'Round the Outside' move up the hill was completely different but very dangerous, of course CS was thinking about getting around the corner......its pretty hard to blame the guy in front for this one, though some here are trying. CS touched VR on the way through and knew where he was before doing it. Ala Max.

I do note we haven't got to the other 'Round the Outside' move by CS at the end of the Start/finish straight where he nearly cannonballed VR before missing the braking marker completely and running at least 3-4 meters wide of the apex.......big mistake here......don't see any CS boppers admitting it. All depends on your POV

Of course the biggest mistake in the race at least was the one that ended it, made by CS running in too hot on brakes again. The corkscrew move was simply a flash and one of many passes, CS was just too impatient and wanted to try to gap VR too early, not wanting to be involved in last laps dicing no doubt.

So carry on with your bopper and religious ........ all you want, the facts remain, CS had the pace that weekend to win by 10 seconds or more, yet he was out raced and out-psyched

The fact of the matter here is, that all of the moves by both of these riders were awesome to watch and created one of the best spectacles in Motogp since Malaysia 06 IMO. The reason we are arguing is because of CS's reaction, showing some of the worst sportsmanship I've ever seen and he still seems to be holding a great deal of resentment over it.......if a cooler head prevailed post race then he no doubt would have been in a much better position mentally for the rest of 08 and indeed, even more so, today.

So maybe in hindsight, CS's biggest mistake of all in 08 wasn't on the racetrack at all......
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Talpa @ Jan 23 2010, 06:19 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>This is a bit absurd, at the Corkscrew VR was already passed (as he had done on at least 1 other occasion in this race) and missed the apex by 1/2 a meter, now seeing as the corkscrew is probably the most famous corner in motorcycle racing at present because of the fact that you can't see the apex as it follows a 3-4 meter sheer drop, then all things considered at race pace in Motogp in a battle for the lead, this is a mistake-sure, but not as big as you all make out-depending on your POV.

CS's 'Round the Outside' move up the hill was completely different but very dangerous, of course CS was thinking about getting around the corner......its pretty hard to blame the guy in front for this one, though some here are trying. CS touched VR on the way through and knew where he was before doing it. Ala Max.

I do note we haven't got to the other 'Round the Outside' move by CS at the end of the Start/finish straight where he nearly cannonballed VR before missing the braking marker completely and running at least 3-4 meters wide of the apex.......big mistake here......don't see any CS boppers admitting it. All depends on your POV

Of course the biggest mistake in the race at least was the one that ended it, made by CS running in too hot on brakes again. The corkscrew move was simply a flash and one of many passes, CS was just too impatient and wanted to try to gap VR too early, not wanting to be involved in last laps dicing no doubt.

So carry on with your bopper and religious ........ all you want, the facts remain, CS had the pace that weekend to win by 10 seconds or more, yet he was out raced and out-psyched

The fact of the matter here is, that all of the moves by both of these riders were awesome to watch and created one of the best spectacles in Motogp since Malaysia 06 IMO. The reason we are arguing is because of CS's reaction, showing some of the worst sportsmanship I've ever seen and he still seems to be holding a great deal of resentment over it.......if a cooler head prevailed post race then he no doubt would have been in a much better position mentally for the rest of 08 and indeed, even more so, today.

So maybe in hindsight, CS's biggest mistake of all in 08 wasn't on the racetrack at all......
I would agree tactically, strategically etc that stoner would have been better off not complaining, which is a different question than whether he had cause for complaint, and have said many times that the corkscrew was a racing incident and one where the only alternative may well have been putting the bike down and taking stoner out anyway.

However, did any of stoner's "mistakes" actually require evasive action from rossi to avoid a certain collision? The point stoner perhaps unwisely made after the race was that with his crucial mistake, one which he freely admitted was his from the get-go, he chose to go into the dirt rather than collide with rossi; as far as I am aware he himself never accused rossi of brake-checking in that incident either.

I see again that even when in a position of great strength, such as when arguing that rossi out-raced stoner on the day at laguna seca 2008 (not something I have argued against btw), you still feel the need for epiphets.
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (TP70 @ Jan 22 2010, 03:59 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>He parted the gravel and lead his disciples through. It was a devine moment that is now part of the biblical book of Rossi.

And if this ‘gravel parting’ set them free from being slaves, they followed… Or should I say The Prophesy Materialized with another Championship to add 9 by now!

By the way, if you can show me an overtake as Rossi’s at the Corkscrew from any rider, in any bike class competition, at any time… I would admit Rossi’s was NOT biblical, other than that… It is written in Stone! Not as in Stoner!
<


<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Jumkie @ Jan 19 2010, 02:36 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Cutting the chicane (which is what the corkscrew is with an elevation change) is as legal as passing on a yellow flag...oh wait, who has done that before???

Not only once, but at least twice as I recall (Phillip Island and Donington same year)… And the ‘biblical’ part is that in both sanctions Rossi got punished and almost wan them ‘Both’. In one he had 15+ seconds minus 10 penalty still wan, in the other only after the 10 second penalty he was Second… Has any other Rider in history achieved this? Biblical isn’t it?
<


<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Jumkie @ Jan 22 2010, 03:32 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Please tell me you are not making a case to compare this to Rossi's OFF TRACK sequence.

No Compa… Not comparing it… My point is that this lead to the Corkscrew!

Yes, they were battling it out, pushing each other to their 110% limits, in one case and first Stoner elbowed Rossi, and the second Rossi risked it all and got away with it surfing the dirt. So Rossi risked it but got it!

Point being: ‘Fair’ or ‘Just Racing’ in both?
<


<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Jumkie @ Jan 22 2010, 03:32 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Eres tan romantico.

I am a Latin bro, it is in my blood!
<
 
<


Great stuff VH, very, very good.

And Mick, I'm just trying to bring the debate back to its origins, which is Stoner's off track behavior. Which is why, as I've stated many times before why I dislike the guy.....if he had a nice wry grin after Laguna 08, and acknowledged the brilliance of the race at some stage (as MickD or Troy Bayliss would have IMO, as VR did at PI and Catalunya this year), then he would have many more fans (including me) and no doubt many more good results.

I'm certainly not dismissing or ridiculing CS's talent on a motorcycle, and I for one am seriously hoping for more Laguna 08'a and Catalunya 09's in 2010 with all three or even four of the aliens and maybe even the younger (or older!) Americans involved.
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Talpa @ Jan 23 2010, 10:08 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>And Mick, I'm just trying to bring the debate back to its origins, which is Stoner's off track behavior. Which is why, as I've stated many times before why I dislike the guy.....if he had a nice wry grin after Laguna 08, and acknowledged the brilliance of the race at some stage (as MickD or Troy Bayliss would have IMO, as VR did at PI and Catalunya this year), then he would have many more fans (including me) and no doubt many more good results.
I would like to see video evidence of mick doohan doing this after he lost a close race; I don't recall him doing it overly under any circumstances for that matter (cf the classic post-race video someone posted last year of him explaining things to alex criville after they had a coming together)
<
. Racing incident though it may have been, I don't think anyone including valentino would have tried the corkscrew move on mick.

Different strokes for different strokes; I get that you don't like stoner, and I have never said you have to like him. Your dislike does seem to rather colour many of your posts though.
 
I suddenly hate Stoner and will not be rooting for him even once in 2010. its rossi or spies. even lorenzo is a fuckee
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Jumkie @ Jan 22 2010, 10:37 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Is anybody here (preferably a Rossi bopper ie. Inam, Talpa, Fish, etc.; willing to admit going off track at the Corkscrew is a mistake?

It's a sad thing to watch a grown man loosing his ability to reason, read and in general communicate in any meaningfull way. That holds true regardless of diagnose.

The move were not perfect and the gravel crossing is the main symptom, to high entry speed were the rason. So, yes the off track can be called a mistake.
Btw this was pointed out by me two days ago and numerous times after the race.
That said, Rossi has called it one of his best moves ever, and he got out of the corkscrew as the leader of the race. I think that put the mistake in a good perspective. It's about as major as my spelling mistakes right her.
<
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Jumkie @ Jan 23 2010, 09:50 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Rossi boppers: "Hey look the moon is made of cheese."
Yeah Casey's CHEESE from the Female infection..?
im out pi$$ed film time ttyl.ppl
<
gooned
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Jumkie @ Jan 23 2010, 10:50 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Rossi boppers: "Hey look the moon is made of cheese."
Well, at least we acknowledge there is a moon
No, Jumkie the moon is not a marketing trick from Rossi
<
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Jumkie @ Jan 24 2010, 07:50 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Rossi boppers: "Hey look the moon is made of cheese."

wow....is it Feta, Brie or Blue vein? We don't actually know what its made of cause we didn't really go there hey Jum, it was all done in a studio in Hollywood right?

<
<
<
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (michaelm @ Jan 23 2010, 09:52 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>I would like to see video evidence of mick doohan doing this after he lost a close race; I don't recall him doing it overly under any circumstances for that matter (cf the classic post-race video someone posted last year of him explaining things to alex criville after they had a coming together)
<
. Racing incident though it may have been, I don't think anyone including valentino would have tried the corkscrew move on mick.

Different strokes for different strokes; I get that you don't like stoner, and I have never said you have to like him. Your dislike does seem to rather colour many of your posts though.

The flip side is that you are certainly a Stoner Fan and this colors pretty much all of your post.

Though at least you use reason and intellect, shame only you and two or three other CS fans here upload informed, debatable posts, but hey we need entertainment too....!
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Talpa @ Jan 24 2010, 01:12 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>The flip side is that you are certainly a Stoner Fan and this colors pretty much all of your post.
Of course, and I freely admit my bias. My point which is perhaps hair-splitting is that from my perspective anyway I mainly defend stoner rather than attack rossi. I have never said you should stop posting though, as you say it is all part of the fun. I suspect jumkie would be devastated if you withdrew from the forum
<
.
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (jazkat @ Jan 23 2010, 01:38 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>me... on page 5... see my post

Doesn't matter how many Boppers accept it, Rossi himself has since called it a big mistake.

The stupidity is that the Boppers think he was kissingthe track there cos they thought it was an overtaking manuever, whereas in fact he was kissing the track there cos it was so good to get back onto it alive
<
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (BarryMachine @ Jan 24 2010, 11:26 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Doesn't matter how many Boppers accept it, Rossi himself has since called it a big mistake.

The stupidity is that the Boppers think he was kissingthe track there cos they thought it was an overtaking manuever, whereas in fact he was kissing the track there cos it was so good to get back onto it alive
<


I'm sure you can show us a link where he admit to his big mistake?
Maybe he is falling apart from old age as he first said it was a fantastic move?
Or maybe you heard all this (and much more) from the voices in your head?