<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Squarewheel @ Sep 29 2009, 12:33 AM)
<{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>There's nothing fair going on when an Italian wins or has a good day on the bike, am I right Jumkie?
Take it easy Square, my "....... Italian" comment was a play on Colin Edwards funny but candid assessment of DeAngelis move at Misano. Don't take it too heart man. BTW, don't mistake my arm-chair spectator critic of Simonchelli (or for that matter J.Rae) as me disliking them. No, I like them both and have enjoyed their suburb racing talent. Simoncelli has brought great racing to 250s & J.Rae to WSBK. So don't confuse my take on their questionable moves as personal dislike, particularly your countrymen. (If that's the way I come off, then I apologize to you and the J.Rae fans).
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE <div class='quotemain'>Simoncelli made a though pass on Biaggi but I'd definitely say that was a fair pass, Biaggi just didn't think Simoncelli could have the intention to pass him there (his own words). Then, if you always look form the perspective of your personal superheroes, is it Stoner, is it Spies... your fault here. I'm Italian so I obviously tend to cheer for Italian riders, but Simoncelli is one of my least favourite Italian riders. But this time I think he did a really good race, I don't know how you can say the opposite.
Yes, I am bias, but I think we all have it, right. Btw, yes, I'm rooting for Spies, but i've said it before, I'm not a fan in the classic sense (or at least I wasn't). But the man has been winning me over, not just with his professional perfomances, but with his take on human relationships with his rival. I was very impressed with Spies' last interview where he basically says he learned from Mladin how NOT to be, adding, he learned he does not need to "hate" his rivals to want to beat them. And the man is walking the talk, as you remember, he mention having a BBQ with Haga, his main rival. That's class. And I admire that.
Ok, regarding Simoncelli's pass, we both agree with was a hard pass, but what does that mean? When you execute a hard pass and upset the other rider by taking his line, is that still a "hard" pass or a "bonsai pass"? Here is what I think, he tied to make a personal statement on Biaggi, a fellow Italia, on the same machine, in Italy. That makes for a pretty good headline. Now you have people saying "he embarrassed Biaggi". WTF, he screws up the pass ad now its Biaggi who was shown up? That's .........
I'm sure you saw Simoncelli's pass on Spies, that was a "hard" pass, that is to say, a close pass that was "fair" and resulted in not crossing of line or upsetting the rider. Yet the pass was close and made a statement clear enough. That kind of pass is respectable. Contrast that pass with the bonsai mistake that he executed on Biaggi. In my limited assessment as in 'monday morning quarterback' (not sure if you are familiar with that saying) I think Simoncelli was trying to make a personal statement, but he made a mistake and broke a hair too deep resulting in upsetting and crossing Biaggi's line. That is a mistake. The consequences of which resulted in two rider having to quickly evade a sure collision sending Spies into the gravel. So no, I'm not impressed with Simoncelli. I think he screwed up by trying to say "look at me", I'm the story.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE <div class='quotemain'>Talking about Fabrizio, so... to you if a rider is potentially inferior to the others, does this make him loose the right to try as hard as he can to win? Did you think the same back in '94 with wild card Nori Abe or did you just enjoy that great race? I think no rider should help the others if you want a real and clear championship. Did you want Fabrizio to stop just before the finish line and make Haga arrive first? Sometimes your immense sense of logic is faded, and that's because you as everyone here have got your own favourite riders and tend to view all things to their point of view, be serious and admit it!
Woe, woe, I basically said it was nice of him not to back down regardless of his torpedo prone style. Yeah, its a dig at his race craft but not in the least saying he should let Haga win. Hell, after taking out Spies he should at least race Haga hard to save his integrity. Which he did. Do I think Fabrizio races above his head, yes. Does this mean I want him to stand down, no. His pass on Haga for the lead was clean, and that's what I've been calling for. Fabrizio is out of the championship (for all intents and purposes) so if he's gonna pass or beat the leader, I want him to be mindful about the overtaking move, and it looks like he was. That goes a long way to restoring respect for his racecraft.