Herve took a business decision to sign with KTM. That’s his prerogative. However, it was clear that he did so without telling Yamaha anything first. That is also his prerogative, but with a 20 year relationship between them, he could have easily used the KTM Deal as a carrot and forced Yamaha’s hand. And I honestly think he would have won that negotiation because KTM needs Tech 3 more than Tech 3 needs KTM.
True but there is also the elephant in the room of Team VR in years ahead as Yamaha have stated that team VR will get Yamaha bikes if they choose so whilst Herve's bargaining position was strong today it would be weaker in a few years when he had to go looking for another brand.
He has likely taken the hit today for what he hopes is a longer term gain but my fears are whether he and KTM will attract the riders to raise the brands results and profile over the next few years or, will Herve be in another of the lull periods he had a few years back.
It is becoming increasingly clear that Zarco has bigger ambitions than developing the KTM into a race winner over 2-3 years. And while it is only the first race weekend, it does look like KTM is not starting off 2018 where they finished off 2017. Now Yamha goes ahead and says that one factory bike for whoever that takes over Tech 3’s contract is possible. Reading between the lines, that sounds like Yamaha’s Hail Mary pass to retain Zarco (with no guarantee that it will work though) .
My opinion only, but Zarco is the hottest property in that paddock short of Marquez himself so he would be a fool to take a risk on the unknown and should head to a known quantity and team.
Stories are of course that it is HRC but with Yamaha now offering the factory bike as you suggest, could it be a factory Yamaha?
Could we see VR go to his own full factory liveried team for 2019/2020 with a full factory spannered bike leaving the official team as Vinales/Zarco?
All guesswork but he has had his team in the past in just such a setting as this then leaves one spot available as well without opening any new spots/grid positions.
Can you imagine Marc VDS- Yamaha with a factory bike and Zarco on board, winning races while Herve has the unglamorous task of helping KTM develop the RC16 into a top 5 machine?
If you think that these things aren’t bothering Herve, you are far too naive.
I personally have no doubt that Herve will be questioning himself but also suspect it will be very briefly as he needed to look at the longer term given the dollar investment and Yamaha could not give a long term future, thus he chose the KTM path with is somewhat laden with dollars.
Personally I suspect he has chosen well but it is a 5 year path before he will see reward as whilst his team is a good team, riders went there for the Yamaha so KTM need to step up to maintain the attractiveness of a Tech 3 ride.
Fair play to Herve though, Yamaha was arrogant as ...., took him for granted and he showed them the error of their ways. I am just not sure if the baby has been thrown out with the bath water.
For 2019 I suspect he has cut-off his nose to spite his face, but I suspect that bu 2022 or so he will be feeling better.
All this of course is dependent on him not selling his licence to a prospective buyer as he does possess the grid spots which may be valuable to a team wanting to join.
All hypothetical and pure guesswork mind but I do hope he gets results this year and next, as if there is a team that deserves a win for perseverence it is Tech3