<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Sarita @ Mar 6 2010, 10:19 AM)
<{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>.. well, no one denies Stoner is massively talented. People say "he this, you that" about the riders, belittle one to praise another, to make some point as in the article.
When I watched the races live (the 1000's at Sepang and the 800's at Donnington park), it was indeed the Ducati riders/bikes that outshone the rest in speed and I ended up paying heaps of compliments to Casey's ride. However Rossi's riding just happens to give that kick to most people because there is some magic about the mind at play as well.. something which an artist would do, not necessarily seen in sportsmen - that sets him apart.
I don't know, I think Rossi is more.........adaptable and professional.
Rossi always appears to be outdoing himself and he has the uncanny ability to interact with the competition. Catalunya was probably the greatest performance (from the fans standpoint) of his career, and it happened after his thirtieth birthday. It was like Jerez 2005, but in 2009 version, he doesn't ram his competitor in the final bend. He gets better and better.
Stoner is a little bit more like the mad artist. Everything has to be just so or he can't reproduce his best work. He's doesn't play off of the competition, but when he's on song, he treats us to performances that are technically superior to anything Rossi or anyone else has ever delivered. Stoner can modulate every control simultaneously while sliding both ends, and he does it on the bike no one else can ride.
Rossi is too smart to ride that far over the line for 30 laps 18 times a season. He crosses the line very sparingly and sometimes it's beautiful (Catalunya 2009, Mugello 2006) sometimes its quite awful (Jerez 2005, Laguna 2008).
Rossi is the GOAT b/c he's smart and he knows his limits. Imo, those limits are not quite as far "out there" as Stoner's.