That sums it up pretty well. I just finished it and often found myself wondering how the film had come to certain parts. They arrive at Sachsenring but them there's a break to discuss how everyone got started in racing. Great footage, great interviews, but it seemed to lack direction. As Sun pointed out, perhaps this was the best Neale could do considering Rossi went missing for six weeks.
Hahaha, perhaps buddy. But Neale should have then realized his mistake and started making a movie about the sport rather than one man...perhaps a lesson Dorna failed to learn too.
Imagine i made a movie about soccer, i mean, football, and proceeded to make a movie who's storyline revolved entirely around Cristiano Ronald. Showed his best performances, interviewed his teammates, interviewed his parents, his doctor, his rivals about him, hell, even shopkeepers in Cristiano's hometown. Would u feel satisfied that the movie coverred and showcased the sport properly?
(Btw, i would have said Leonel Messi, but i understand he's still the 'current' best player? And even if u replaced his name above, it still might have left u equally satisfied.)
Austin, the best example i can give u is this, imagine i made a movie about the AMA and spent the entire story about Matt Mladin. 95% of footage from his best performances, the 5% of footage not of Mladin presented in a context about Mladin. Knowing what u know about the AMA, Mladin having won a string of titles on undoutedly the best package, the most succesful rider in the series, who basically had to beat his teammate, which Spies did. Now two years removed, and ur boy Josh Hayes winning the last two titles, a modern movie take about the AMA surrounding Mladin might leave an equal feeling of ........ as i felt.
Tom said, well, the movie isnt that bad and it shouldnt bother u it had Rossi on the screen and story all the time, etc. Yeah, no ...., but as a film proported about 'the sport', this movie failed miserably as it was ONLY about one man's experience about the sport. It would be like making a movie about NBA, and it be all about Jordan, or golf and all about Tiger, or boxing and all about Tyson. Austin, how much would u enjoy a movie about American baseball, then watched a movie where 99% of it was about the Yankies?
I find it sad that we are so desperate for movies about our sport that we are willing to stomach anything we are fed. What choice do we have, right? Again, im glad i didnt pay a dime for this movie (had i purchased it, i would have been pissed, i hate being lied to). Lifted from torrents, and have already erased from my hard drive to make space. If dude would have titled it 'a fairwell homage to Rossi', i might have purchased it and kept in my library to show again, however, as it stands, i doubt i'll ever watch it again.
The movie also revists many topics we have argued about to the Nth degree here, yet in the movie makes all the wrong conclusions. In the movie, it frames every single one of these with the conclusion that Rossi is the blameless hero, a result of a trait of his will to win a trait we should all admire without question. From the vilification of Biaggi & Sete, to his dastard torpedo of Sete at Jerez, to his vilification of Honda, even revisiting his big '.... you' production celebration of him shackled like some prisoner doing hard labor as a Honda rider. Then like a Messiah, single handedly saves Yamaha. Which completely smacks hallow today since we know he couldnt develop Ducati despite every possible advantage given to a rider to do so.
This storyline continues with the framing of 'his bad luck loss' of the 06 title, and BLAMES HIS TIRES for the Valencia crash. Yes, read that again! That us a chickenshit statement. Takes no respinsibility fir his own epic fail. This, a man that had the exclusive benefit of special tires in most all of his premeir titles, making them all in my eyes skewed & questionable. Then the movie frames the significant difference in the title that year squarely on the central figure of Elias, who beat Rossi at Estoril making the 5 points difference, but glossing over Pedros torpedo effect on those same points. The point is sealed by selectively injecting Hayden's sound bite calling 'Elias his boy' and there u have it folks, the 06 season in a nut shell.
Then they go on to Laguna 08, where the soft vilification of Stoner begins. The now infamous Corkscrew "MISTAKE"; yeah, thats right, Rossi admits its a mistak finally on camera, one that he recalled he had made in practice, but now framed as a racing move for which Casey had no right to protest, because in Rossi's words, "did not touch Casey". But just incase the viewer didnt get the message, they go on to include a sound bite that 'Casey is mentally weak' when covering Stoner's illness. Casey can on ocasion (seems to be increasing with frequency) says some stupid .... when given the opportunity, yet to have some jouno's sound bite questioning the mans mental strength when before & after his illness Casey ran the field in the races, is not only inaccurate but vindictive. Moaning, whining, and saying stupid .... does not a weak mind make.
But the vilification of Rossi's rivals doesnt end there. Lorenzo benefiting from "Rossi's development" is a prominent theme as they frame the 2009 rise and 2010 championship as Rossi "sharpening the tool for his rival." Enter shopkeepers on the street interviews, who tell us Lorenzo is just leeching off Rossi and is copycating him to boot. Again, given Rossi's downplaying of his development role at Ducati 2011 makes his heroic development of Yamaha completely inaccurate. If this wasnt enuf, the leg injury is framed again as heroics, for his triumphant return at Sepang. Lets forget for a moment that Lorenzo won the title there, the movie concentrates on interviewing Dr Claudio Costa at every opportunity, who tells the viewer how amazing it was for Rossi to return and win so fast. Which is true, yes, absolutely, but when u make a 2 hour movie and spend 99% of the footage about Rossi, it begins to paint a picture that this is only a homage, and nothing more.
The part that actually had me laffing, and i mean, i burst out laffing, was when they started showing these cardboard cut-outs on the sides of houses and shops in Italy. I was like, dude, i get it already, yes, its all about Rossi, do i need to continue to see images of cult worship and interviews from the angry little old lady calling Lorenzo a copycat? Hahaha. ....... overkill.