Stoner critical of Hayden

MotoGP Forum

Help Support MotoGP Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Oh I made a point Reg. Just because you don want to accept it doesn't mean its not there
<
 
The Randy incident I accept as dangerous. The Nicky one was not in my opinion.

Yeah he may have messed up his hot lap a little, but for goodness sake it was only FP3.

He made a mountain out of a molehill & again made himself look like a .........

Absolutely love the way he rides, but getting tired of his hissy fits.

Spot on.
 



Just wondering Krop, do you think the media actually feels sorry for Stoner, or has it gone well beyond this?



Generally when an athlete carry's on like this as regularly as Stoner has for years, a general dislike develops across the board, his high and mighty attitude whilst winning seems to be setting up and major downfall when he is eventually beaten?
 
Just wondering Krop, do you think the media actually feels sorry for Stoner, or has it gone well beyond this?



Generally when an athlete carry's on like this as regularly as Stoner has for years, a general dislike develops across the board, his high and mighty attitude whilst winning seems to be setting up and major downfall when he is eventually beaten?



Most of the media don't care, they just want stories to sell newspapers, and will sacrifice anyone and anything to do so. There is one highly-respected journalist I know who seizes any opportunity he can to slip subtle insults into his questions to one rider. Another journalist picked selectively from quotes from a rider and turned them into a sensationalist story that has meant that rider will never get a ride again with a particular factory. The Italian media is currently riding Lorenzo for they are worth because they're afraid to go to Motegi, but don't have the guts to tell their editors to .... off, and so are hoping Lorenzo can get the race canceled.



There's a warning here too. Marco Simoncelli's star is waxing as Rossi's wanes. If Simoncelli starts to sell as many newspapers as Rossi does, then the press will drop Rossi like a hot potato, and a raft of ugly stories will appear about him. There's a lot of resentment stored up for having to spend so much of their time writing about Rossi over the years (for an example, go look at the Sportmediaset RSS feed, about 80% of the non-race stories are about Rossi).



As a rule, journalists are scum (and I haven't even got onto their precious egos yet), and I hope I don't turn out like them. I remind myself every day that I am stupid, ignorant and lazy, and that keeps me slightly more honest than I would be otherwise. So all personal abuse is welcome, to keep me in line.
 
Most of the media don't care, they just want stories to sell newspapers, and will sacrifice anyone and anything to do so. There is one highly-respected journalist I know who seizes any opportunity he can to slip subtle insults into his questions to one rider. Another journalist picked selectively from quotes from a rider and turned them into a sensationalist story that has meant that rider will never get a ride again with a particular factory. The Italian media is currently riding Lorenzo for they are worth because they're afraid to go to Motegi, but don't have the guts to tell their editors to .... off, and so are hoping Lorenzo can get the race canceled.



There's a warning here too. Marco Simoncelli's star is waxing as Rossi's wanes. If Simoncelli starts to sell as many newspapers as Rossi does, then the press will drop Rossi like a hot potato, and a raft of ugly stories will appear about him. There's a lot of resentment stored up for having to spend so much of their time writing about Rossi over the years (for an example, go look at the Sportmediaset RSS feed, about 80% of the non-race stories are about Rossi).



As a rule, journalists are scum (and I haven't even got onto their precious egos yet), and I hope I don't turn out like them. I remind myself every day that I am stupid, ignorant and lazy, and that keeps me slightly more honest than I would be otherwise. So all personal abuse is welcome, to keep me in line.

Stoner spin doctor ...... !!





There dont say i dont give you anything .
<
<
 
I am fairly sure that was not stoner's point though. His consistent argument is that this is a safety issue, and I believe it is about this for him and not about people screwing up his laps; I also believe he is correct in this view, if exaggerated with some of the specific incidents (I wouldn't necessarily baulk if someone said many of the incidents). Imo he is not saying that nicky is morally reprehensible and deliberately screwed up his lap, but rather that it wasn't accidental that nicky was going slowly on the racing line and hence in stoner's view constituting a safety risk.



This doesn't imply that I think nicky is morally reprehensible btw, just that he does not consider it to be as big a safety issue as stoner. The whole thing does not seem as big for the riders as it is for rossi fans currently bereft of other avenues to criticise stoner; my surmise as I have said previously is that they think stoner has a bee in his bonnet about all of this and don't take it very personally, perhaps also recognising that there is some basis in fact even if he exaggerates the matter.
'





I don't know what to think about Stoner and safety issues anymore. I understand that he doesn't like people to be in his way or tail him at all but one thing I noticed with the Nicky incident was that Stoner passed Nicky, then slowed down to let Nicky pass again and then proceeded to block him. He's done that before, Yea maybe they deserve it, i don't know, but thats not safe either is it? Anyways Nicky said his tires were cold and he was on an out lap, so Stoner's comments about Nicky trying to hold him up for a tow deff sound like something made up by him?
 
Maybe he didn't completely block him but from what i can remember he was trying to mess up Haydens out lap..lol
 
Maybe he didn't completely block him but from what i can remember he was trying to mess up Haydens out lap..lol

Yep he deliberately slowed and blocked nicky for two or three corners and was looking over/gesturing like the complete .... that he is, about as safe as punching someone in the back at 100kmph.......
 
So is riding a bike at 200mph. Maybe we should limit the bikes speed and send them out 1 at a time. How does stoner feel about block passing and break checking? You have to work around other riders during a race so why can he get it into his head you have to do the same at other times on track. Casey just wants clear track in quali and the race. Yes he is fast, probably the fastest bloke in motogp but he has to accept he is not the only person out there and deal with it. Sometimes your on pole and get away and end up with clear track to the finish. Sometimes you don't and have to work harder for it. That boy needed more smacks as a kid imo.

Stoner's attitude to this is entirely consistent, if overblown as david is saying. Whilst I am sure having nice laps ruined annoys him and is part of what underlies his attitude, and that his attitude was also partly formed because he got fined for accidentally blocking dani pedrosa's line when he (stoner ) was a nobody in 2006 when no other rider has to my knowledge been fined since, I am sure he genuinely thinks he is on a safety crusade. This is after all what he says when asked as david reports, and he is famous for saying what he thinks.



He also seems to have a scale for such things, with deliberately rather than accidentally being on the race line a worse offence, and riders seldom deliberately dawdle on the racing line in races, perhaps something to do with the rules
<
. In a race if there is something wrong with your bike you immediately have to get off the racing line, and if you continue particularly if dropping oil or debris are blackflagged. I unfortunately (or fortunately depending on pov) don't remember back to when there were enough bikes and/or a sufficient performance differential for bikes to be lapped in this class, but in most forms of motorsport in this circumstance when riders/bikes are merely slow rather than disabled blue flags are waved to require them to get out of the way. I am not aware that practice kilometres per hour are in any way slower or less dangerous than race kmh either.



Not necessarily in your case, but from my biased stoner fan perspective this is mostly about there being few remaining avenues of attack on stoner, as illustrated by hawkdriver construing me pointing out that rossi had said something about being impeded by a slower rider in the warm-up at silverstone as an attack on valentino rather than an example that stoner's concern about the issue is not solitary. I didn't watch the warm-up but I think the incident may have resulted in valentino putting the bike down, which I would have thought rather makes stoner's point.



As far as the clear track thing, it seems pretty obvious now that the ducati needs clear track to be gotten through corners in any way fast, with valentino testifying that the thing just won't turn, so getting to the lead quickly and attempting to skeedaddle was stoner's only winning tactic on that bike, and winning seems to me to be what he is not unreasonably about. Now that he is on a bike that allows for mutiple tactical approaches he is relaxed about not being in the lead early, and sometimes bides his time for at least few laps before making clean, precise and decisive passes, often on corners and against identically equipped riders (seeing these are mainly the ones up with him
<
) rather disproving previous contentions about his ability to pass as he is disproving so many other things.
 
Generally when an athlete carry's on like this as regularly as Stoner has for years, a general dislike develops across the board, his high and mighty attitude whilst winning seems to be setting up and major downfall when he is eventually beaten?

You don't get irony, do you?
 
What is truly amazing is the fact that no one has managed to advise or persuade him to cease this disturbing, and dangerous

behaviour. As I said after the de puniet king hit, a $5000 fine

obviously did .... all, a 2 round ban would sort this out real

quick......personally I hope he continues with his spats, as

eventually he'll pick the wrong guy to .... with and get what he deserves.

Yes, a two race ban might give valentino rossi and others a chance to get somewhere near him.



Stoner may be making mountains out of molehills, but you are continuing your usual practice of ignoring mountains in favour of molehills. What stoner has been doing may be arrogant or impolite, but nobody except you and a very few other rabidly anti- stoner posters on fan forums think it involves danger particularly in comparison to the behaviour which has provoked it on some occasions, notably the rossi torpedo and the de puniet incident.
 
You don't get irony, do you?



nor do you, obviously......soon it will be the third time for your boy, slow learner that he is.



Sorry, but you can't really apply this one either way as history will always show Stoner as well being the top '....' by a margain, of the era.....
 
Yes, a two race ban might give valentino rossi and others a chance to get somewhere near him.



Stoner may be making mountains out of molehills, but you are

continuing your usual practice of ignoring mountains in favour of

molehills. What stoner has been doing may be arrogant or

impolite, but nobody except you and a very few other rabidly

anti- stoner posters on fan forums think it involves danger

particularly in comparison to the behaviour which has provoked

it on some occasions, notably the rossi torpedo and the de

puniet incident.



right so, the only rider to have been fined for dangerous behaviour recently is..........you guessed it!



Get a grip mate.....you would be genuinly mortified to hear most racing professionals comments on your hero. Even some of his greatest supporters here are changing their tune on his ....... behaviour, seems it will take older dogs longer to learn new tricks whilst continuing to look rather stoopid.
 

Recent Discussions

Recent Discussions

Back
Top