I’m not so sure about that Mike. IIRC most of the riders called Rossi’s favoured tyre unridable and Michelin let slip that they went back and worked on Rossi’s favoured tyre despite the riders almost unanimously favouring the other tyre. Clearly there was still issues with the tyre that was voted in originally by the riders but it does make somewhat of a smoking gun that instead of fixing the issues with the chosen tyre Michelin seemed to have gone back and revised/reworked the tyre that Rossi chose.
Didn’t they have a vote which went the way of the Rossi tire?. As I recall only Vinales, Lorenzo and one other voted to retain the tire which had been the overwhelming choice in a pre-season vote. Vinales of course was Rossi’s team-mate who had done much better than him on the initial tire and faded away subsequently, and I as a Lorenzo fan was annoyed with Lorenzo being disadvantaged. As I said, I wouldn’t have had much problem if the Vinales/Lorenzo tire had continued along with the ‘new’ tire.