<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (J4rn0 @ Apr 12 2009, 12:27 AM)
<{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>The 'personnel' could never do anything like that against the will of the management (if they are just incompetent, they would be sacked).
So you are actually saying that Ducati's management intentionally provide anybody but Stoner (Capirossi, Melandri, now Hayden) with incompetent technical teams so that they can only manage a poor show? Interesting theory. I am not saying that's impossible. But we have to understand,
why would they do that?
No I'm not saying that either.
I'm simply saying based upon my own understanding, that Casey's crew are very tight, and bond well with the rider just as the Aussies Burgess, Briggs and Stephens et al. comprise the enduring nucleus of Rossi's crew which he brought over from Repsol Honda to Yamaha.
I don't think that the other side of the Ducati garage is as cohesive, and functions as smoothly with quite the level of reciprocity between rider an crew as Casey's team where there's almost a 'symbiosis' between machine, rider and engineer, just as there is at Fiat Yamaha with Vale. This is one of the main reasons why both are the chief protagonists in the Championship.
This situation at Ducati is not by design, and owes more on Casey's side perhaps to happenstance or serendipity. Who know's? I'm not claiming I do, it's just speculation. I probably deserve to be flamed for my viewpoint, but I think that Nicky's side of the garage certainly lacks this balance, and the situation could be redressed/addressed somewhat by Domenicalli or Suppo.
I did not attribute Melandri's woes last season purely to his attitude or his apparent inability to ride the bike to a lack of ability. We all know how hugely talented he is. I think Ducati can suffer from the inflexible HRC syndrome where too much emphasis is placed upon the machine/brand. at the expense of faith in, and support for the rider.
Anyway, this season, watch Christian Pupilin during Hayden's debrief, I've noticed over the years he very seldom speaks. I'm honestly not sure he has the right personality/affinity for the job. Again, I may be well off the mark here, it's just a theory.