Sure, he ...... up by going there, not by what he has done there, I have said all along including before they went there that if he and jb can't sort the bike then it isn't sortable, and the bike including the engine characteristics are more or less the opposite of what he has preferred and developed elsewhere, which was hard for anyone to see prospectively. The current regulations particularly the tyre regulations don't fit a maverick bike, and everyone is saying audi and all their resources won't offer a short term fix whoever is there, and cal partisans are hoping cal doesn't go there.
I also think he would still be very competitive on a honda or yamaha.
I still wonder if he more or less decided to retire then changed his mind. By the time he decided yamaha was untenable for him he had no choice other than ducati, and while I can see why he thought yamaha were disloyal to him I guess it would also have been hard for yamaha not to give the younger defending world champion who they saw as their future equal status, Valentino's first significant injuries having occurred at the most inopportune time. I actually don't think his main motive was to prove yamaha wrong or to prove anything to or about jorge, he wanted an effort fully focused on him for the time he had left; the nastro azzurro honda set-up from early in his premier class career seems to be the one he most liked anyway. Mick doohan had a similar attitude to him except more so, he resented other honda riders reaping the benefit of his development and set-up work. We all also know that there are hardly ever two absolutely equal riders or drivers in any team in motorsports, with the rare exceptions such as 2009 at yamaha occurring when there is no real external threat.
I won't pretend I would ever want to see him beat stoner, but I would actually support him should he ride for kevin schwantz suzuki in the future
.