Crutchlow to Motogp.....?

MotoGP Forum

Help Support MotoGP Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Jul 13, 2009
Messages
2,428
Location
Alaska
Sundays announcement of Cal Crutchlow's incredible promotion to the Tech 3 Motogp team for the next 2 season's is intriguing. I'm trying to remember the last time a relatively unsuccessful Superbike rider was promoted to the big time so quickly, CV had a better resume so I'm thinking it was Andrew Pitt on the Kwaka, though I'm not too sure of Guintoli's origins, prior to that it may have been Haslam, back in those days though the seats were not so much a premium as today.



In the modern era the promotion of Riders like Toseland, Bayliss, Edwards and Spies was more easily accepted as they were Superbike champions-most even multiple champs. But Cal hasn't really set the world alight in WSBK besides a string a poles IMO. To his credit Cal's outperformed his ex-motogp teammate this year but other than a couple of wins at home, they have struggled with crashes and setting the bike up to not chew the rear tyre all season. And as we know, the ability to precisely diagnose and cure set-up issues is ever-more crucial in the top-class.



The push to acquire at least a single British rider in Motogp may have blurred the lines a little- I'm not sure, or is it just that there is a lack of other viable options. Moto2 seems to have a gaggle of great talent, some of the front-runners however have already outstayed their welcome in the top class, as have some of the current Motogp crop. With a serious hole to fill Yamaha has seemingly taken a rather large gamble-and with contracts in the way, maybe Cal's just the best option of 'available' 'untried' talent......and in looking to 2012.....?
 
My guess he is going to have a Brit back on the grid.....I don't think he will set the world on fire in MotoGP. I think he will do as good as Toseland did at best.
 
My guess he is going to have a Brit back on the grid.....I don't think he will set the world on fire in MotoGP. I think he will do as good as Toseland did at best.



Nobody will unless they are given factory equipment.
dry.gif
I agree, Crutchlow is being promoted prematurely. He has yet to prove himself. Although he has shown incredible talent and speed. I think that he is going to outshine JT, just depends on how long they give him to come to terms with the bikel.
 
Didn't Spies get the early MotoGP nod only if he won the WSBK title for Yamaha in 2009...and if not then he would have the chance to move up for the 2011 season???



If so....the Crutchlow bump up to the big league kinda sucks with a lackluster WSBK season compared to Spies.
 
Personally I think he would have fared better in Moto2, I would have given the ride to either Haslam or Rea, regardless good to have a Brit back on the grid and I wish him luck.
 
Personally I think he would have fared better in Moto2, I would have given the ride to either Haslam or Rea, regardless good to have a Brit back on the grid and I wish him luck.

Agree about Rea,the lad can ride anything.
<
 
I think Cal has been gifted accelerated access to motogp for being British, and due to the un-settled nature of the moto2 field currently. Besides Elias no rider in the field has established themself enough to be considered worthy of riding at a higher level, and Dorna are quite public in their want and willingness to pay for Brits. Cal will know this and starts his career having to prove himself, and following Ben Spies. It will be tough
 
pointless..everyone knows the Britts cant ride
<



<
Its a shame. I'm hoping in a few years when moto2 and moto3 filter down to national level we might be able to start breeding decent GP riders without sending them to Spain. At the moment all we can do at home is make good superbike lads and hope one of them can make the switch. You guys are in a similar position, except you have Ben Spies.
 
I'm trying to remember the last time a relatively unsuccessful Superbike rider was promoted to the big time so quickly, CV had a better resume so I'm thinking it was Andrew Pitt on the Kwaka, though I'm not too sure of Guintoli's origins, prior to that it may have been Haslam, back in those days though the seats were not so much a premium as today.

I'm thinking (actually I know) you are wrong about Andrew Pitt ... he went straight from supersport to that piece of .... Kawasaki. Bit hard to be an unsuccesful Superbike rider when he hadn't even been on one on the world stage.
 
100% passport.. If they had to have a Brit, Rea should have taken Melandri's Honda seat, he is more deserving a shot at GP than Crutchlow at this time.
 
100% passport.. If they had to have a Brit, Rea should have taken Melandri's Honda seat, he is more deserving a shot at GP than Crutchlow at this time.



Honda haven't taken a superbike rider in since Hayden. I wouldn't count on them doing it anytime soon either
 
I've said it before, and I'll say it again: Charlie Boorman is the best current Brit rider out there!!!



Hell Crutchlow hasn't even done half the Dakar!!



<
<
<










Actually who knows Crutchlow may blow us all away, he's got his ticket now, lets just see how he goes.
 
pointless..everyone knows the Britts cant ride
<

Maybe they don't want to ride you mean.
<




Crutchlow turned down another opportunity to race as a wild card in MotoGP at season finally Valencia.



Cal Crutchlow will not compete in the season ending race at Valencia. ...



"The reasoning is the same as that which led me to turn down the M1 when Valentino got hurt - he explained - that I didn't want to race on a bike that I don't know, with carbon brakes and Bridgestone tires. The best thing for me is to test calmly and without the pressure of a race."



Crutchlow, in any case, will still be on track at Valencia for the traditional post season test. gpone.com
 
the good thing about the move is cal is used to a bike where there is so much room for set up..A WSB bike has soooooo many postions to set everything up as witch will help him in motogp( i Hope) tech 3 seem to have got it sorted but it will defo be interesing.,his lap times at the last sliverstone would put him 5Th on a motoGP bike on the same track,, id love to see a brit do well in motogp!
 
the good thing about the move is cal is used to a bike where there is so much room for set up..A WSB bike has soooooo many postions to set everything up as witch will help him in motogp



Relative to what? Everyone else in motogp will either have motogp or 250 experience or both. They are bikes with far more setup parameters than WSBK so in this respect Cal is at disadvantage
 
[quote name='Tom' date='27 September 2010 - 03:05 PM' timestamp='1285599922' post='252816']

Relative to what? Everyone else in motogp will either have motogp or 250 experience or both. They are bikes with far more setup parameters than WSBK so in this respect Cal is at disadvantage

[/quo



, i reckon he will do well,what i was trying to say was,it maybe early to pick him formWSB but he has had experience on a quick big bike and loads of set up, and tech 3 have pushed ben to a good level,
 
Relative to what? Everyone else in motogp will either have motogp or 250 experience or both. They are bikes with far more setup parameters than WSBK so in this respect Cal is at disadvantage

well i hope he does better than toseland or he'll be gone after his 2 seasons are up...
<
 
well i hope he does better than toseland or he'll be gone after his 2 seasons are up...
<



Yes i agree, and i hope he does better. I think the fact that he'll be racing his 4th class in 4 years will work in his favour because he already has an open minded learning mindset built in. It worked for Ben Spies
 
Yes i agree, and i hope he does better. I think the fact that he'll be racing his 4th class in 4 years will work in his favour because he already has an open minded learning mindset built in. It worked for Ben Spies

yeap..and i think he's goin in with the right attitude to succeed as well. just go in & learn the 1st season building toward the 2nd. good luck to him!
 

Recent Discussions

Recent Discussions

Back
Top