And like so many have told you over and over again, certain sports require certain physiques. The world of sports is full of " tweeners" who were to big and slow to play one position, yet to small to play another. Guess what, they didnt make it, even though they were exceptional talents. Thats life, the sport didnt change for them. You adapt, or you go home. Besides, i cant think of one circumstance where a crash diet by a GP rider turned his fortunes around. Its all in their head. They see smaller riders dominating the scene and automatically assume its their size, when in fact, its more to do with talent. Lets face it, Nicky and other riders can lose down to 100 lbs and they are not going to be as fast as Stoner, Pedrosa, or Lorenzo. Like Krop said, bigger guys { Rossi, Sic, can/ could, ride GP bikes with the hobbits, they have/ had the talent.
Of what benefit are any of the things you type?
You argue that the talent pool should be arbitrarily smaller than it could be if practical rules were used. The result is less competition amongst the riders which means they are possibly less deserving than if the rules were altered--the exact opposite of what you claim.
You argue that the manufacturers should be allowed to write whatever rules they please, though they didn't write the rules until 2002. Their underlying objective is to artificially alter the distance between the competitors at the finish line. They also undermine the 80/20 formula which is probably the most important part of GP's tradition, and one of the most important elements of separating 'the men from the boys'. You don't seem to care.
Now that you can no longer avoid the consequences of blanket endorsements for the manufacturers, your response is that you only wish you could have more. I read what you type, it is mind boggling--a Christmas list with no particular relation to reality. What have I been talking about for the last several years? Rev limits, tire regulations, increasing manufacturer participation, and rider stature. All of those things are on the front burner, and I've explained why people would be obsessing about them. I recently implied that success ballasting was the work of the manufacturers. Two-days later Domenicali fessed up.
If you want the things you want, you'll quit wasting your time trying to convince me I've lost the plot, and you'll start coming up with clever ways to preserve what you want.