This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Stoner: A tough cookie

<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (chopperman @ Jul 15 2009, 09:32 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>wires crossed here Gaz
<
i was answering to this


Cool, thus why I asked but I forgot the smiley after it.

All good.






Garry
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (chopperman @ Jul 14 2009, 05:32 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>here you go mate, read at laugh with us
<

link
The screenshot didnt open when I checked the link but with all the posts, I got the gag.
reading between the lines, Im presuming that Pinky has certain unresolved issues, resulting most likely from his own inadequacies and feels the need to ridicule others (Rossi) to make himself feel less of a failure.
Or it could just mean he's a bit of a prick (who likes chinese boys).
Thanks for clearing that up for me.
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (somedamnwriter @ Jul 14 2009, 03:06 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>rog, you should do the honors and baptize this new member from the great knowledge we all share
<



Oh yes, The one post every new member should see!

<
<
<
<
<


Carry on laughing!
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (clarkjw @ Jul 15 2009, 04:21 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>The article is fake and self contradictory.Despite this, it highlights some flaws in Stoner's persona.
He think's he's a motorcycle racer and development rider. This is a false conception many athletes have. Casey must understand that he is an entertainer . GP's wouldn't exist without fans. No world class racetracks would ever get built without fans. His first obligation is to himself/family, then to the sport in general, finally his team/sponsors.

FWIW, Stoner is 'friends' with Nicky

Im not sure why you point out that Casey is an entertainer. He clearley knows that as his job is broadcast world wide for audiences to enjoy. BUt what he said in that interview (which is probably just a fabrication) is that he is not an Actor.

Casey entertains, well he entertains me at least, i enjoy watching him throw that bike around and do masisve whellies, i also think Rossi entertains. They both are diametrically different in their ways they ride and celebrate, but they are also both themselfs, meaning neither of them act. That is who they are.

And yeah you are spot on, Casey and Nicky are good mates, as is Casey with several others in the paddock, Colin Edwards and a few others. So the last 'quote' is rubbish, along with the whole interview.
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Gaz @ Jul 15 2009, 10:12 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>If the article is 'fake' as you claim then how can something that is fake highlight any flaws in Stoner's persona as you attest?

If something is fake, it is just that, fake and no credence should be applied to any component of it as being truth.





Now here I disagree for the reasons stated by some of the othere responses.

Racers are not entertainers but athletes. Athletes by their particpation in competition contribute to an entertainment package but that alone does not make them entertainers.

I would also disagree in the order in which you have placed the improtance of the efforts as I would expect that Stoner's commitment to sponsors and his team is more important than the sport in general as his team are the ones that pay his wages. Were he contracted to DORNA thence I would tend to say that his commitment to the sport come before his team.







Garry
His team would not exist without the sport??!! His team would have no money to pay him without the public buying Ducati's, alpinestars leathers, nolan helmets, Shell V-power.....do I need to go on?

You would not know who Casey Stoner is without the fans buying these products....I think though that Casey is doing a good job at pleasing his fans, people who like him are generally like him-pretty bland and serious-meat and 2 veg types (married at his age??-with all the potentials of his status??!!), people who like Rossi are the opposite. And the two shall never agree, that is what makes this sport entertaining. Like it or not the personalities do dictate where your allegiance lies.
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Talpa @ Jul 17 2009, 11:56 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>His team would not exist without the sport??!! His team would have no money to pay him without the public buying Ducati's, alpinestars leathers, nolan helmets, Shell V-power.....do I need to go on?

You would not know who Casey Stoner is without the fans buying these products....I think though that Casey is doing a good job at pleasing his fans, people who like him are generally like him

All three of them?
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Talpa @ Jul 17 2009, 09:56 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>His team would not exist without the sport??!! His team would have no money to pay him without the public buying Ducati's, alpinestars leathers, nolan helmets, Shell V-power.....do I need to go on?

You would not know who Casey Stoner is without the fans buying these products....I think though that Casey is doing a good job at pleasing his fans, people who like him are generally like him-pretty bland and serious-meat and 2 veg types (married at his age??-with all the potentials of his status??!!), people who like Rossi are the opposite. And the two shall never agree, that is what makes this sport entertaining. Like it or not the personalities do dictate where your allegiance lies.



Well, yes you do need to go on and I will argue (debate) why.

People were buying all of these products well before Casey Stoner rode for Ducati, or used Aloinestar leathers, Nolan Helmets etc. So each of these companies is not dependent on Casey Stoner for the marketing of their products as they have numerous marketing forces behind them to make the consumer buy the product just as these same companies will not be dependent on CS when he leaves. This alos means that these numerous marketing forces are able to ensure sufficient funds for these companies to pay Stoner today.

Whilst riders will say that they are there for the fans in truth, the fans are not the primary reason for the rider being in this game. The fans are an integral part however and as such they can determine certain aspects of popularity which some riders covet, whilst others have no such illusions.

But to say that we would not lnow of CS without the products and fans purchasing of these products is a different argument altogether and one that I believe is flawed. Many people who follow sprt will recognise talent and follow it without buying the products that the rider may endorse or those products of their sponsors. This does not show a lack of support but many people already have products with which they are happy so will not change, certainly however some may change brands but personally I do not.

CS is there first and foremost to ride bikes extremely fast, which is something he can do well and as such that draws attention onto him and his tealent. Fans swanning around in Ducati jackets, Nolan helmets etc do not bring the attention to Stoner, but his riding does. I would even go so far as to say that most people could not tell you the sponsors of CS not Ducati. Yes they may get some but they will not get all and that is because most people simply do not really care.

As a slight aside, the only two helmet designs that I recognise when I see a replica on teh street are Rossi and Doohan, I simply could not tell you the designs of other helmets because I focus on the racing and riding, not merchandising.

As for personalities, absolutely as people will be drawn to support a rider because of the riders personality and achievements. But to generalise Stoner's fans in terms of 'pretty bland and serious-meat and 2 veg types' could be risky as to generalise Rossi fans as all being good humoured, fun loving always smiling characters would be wrong.







Garry
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Gaz @ Jul 18 2009, 09:43 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>generalise Rossi fans as all being good humoured, fun loving always smiling characters would be wrong.
Garry
u mean gay?
<
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Pinky @ Jul 18 2009, 03:32 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>u mean gay?
<



My wife ain't gat Pinky, trust me there, she sure aint gay.
<


Mind you, just once in a while ...................................... nah, better not.






Gaz
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Gaz @ Jul 18 2009, 09:43 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>As a slight aside, the only two helmet designs that I recognise when I see a replica on teh street are Rossi and Doohan, I simply could not tell you the designs of other helmets because I focus on the racing and riding, not merchandising.


Garry

Well I think judging by this you are in the minority mate. I'm not that die-hard but I certainly recognize a Rossi,, Schwantz or Haga lid.

My point was that the sport wouldn't exist to the level its at, with 18 odd rounds per year around the globe, cutting edge technology and so on without the serious sponsorship it receives. And Ducati wouldn't be there nor would Casey-Simple. Of course Stoner wants the attention and the money, him and his parents wouldn't have thrown it all on the line otherwise, they would have stayed in oz and been happy with 100k a year and serveral Aussie superbike championships as Jamie Stauffer is. And this certainly would have proved him to be one of the best riders on the planet as Jamie is.

Look at ASBK- some of the best racing on earth-consistently, such a shame there are only what 8-rounds, two of which are at the same track on the same weekend. So no one turns up to watch it and its aired on 10's sub ONE HD 2 weeks after everyone has read the results in AMCN. Without big money sponsors this series will never get off the ground despite its amazing 'Racing' spectacle. No Factory Ducati here. It's pretty much propped up by Yamaha and has been for years.

The majority of fans around the world love the racing, love the personalites and love to purchase and display (or ride) their colours. This is what keeps it alive.
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Talpa @ Jul 18 2009, 10:10 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Well I think judging by this you are in the minority mate. I'm not that die-hard but I certainly recognize a Rossi,, Schwantz or Haga lid.

The majority of fans around the world love the racing, love the personalites and love to purchase and display (or ride) their colours. This is what keeps it alive.
Good point of debate... I'm curious - my personal opinion is that a poll would come out about 50/50 in terms of who cared/purchased branded products. I avoid them like the plague - I'm me, not some wannabe, nor do I feel the need to publicly pay tribute to riders (musicians or anyone else) I admire.
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Talpa @ Jul 18 2009, 03:10 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Well I think judging by this you are in the minority mate. I'm not that die-hard but I certainly recognize a Rossi,, Schwantz or Haga lid.


And it makes me no less a fan just because I do not openly purchase merchandise of my favourite rider/team/brand. To be honest I would say that SoD is correct and any poll would reveal a 50/50 split.

Of course fans of individual riders would know their respective Helmet designs etc but I will strongly argue against most fans knowing all sponsors, but that is in reality a mute point.

It is however an interesting discussion (which has been covered elsewhere - different forum maybe) and like SoD who uses what product does not make me change to that product. It does raise my awareness that the specific company makes a product within the bracket but it will not make me buy it.

Personally I also strongly suspect that people will not buy a Nolan Stoner replica helmet just because they may be a fan of Stoner as helmets are a very individual thing. If they use Nolan they may well buy a CS replica, just as they may try a Nolan because CS uses the product. But most people will buy the product that best suits their needs and with helmets (as example) being such a personal thing I doubt that people will switch to a Nolan brand or a CS replica simply because they are fans of that rider. Yes, people buy Rossi replica helmets (and Doohan in the day) but most of those people alre4ady usedt hat brand helmet or in many cases with Rossi are new to riding (as his popularioty opens up motorcycling to a new market).

As for ASBK I am yet to see it but will be at Eastern Creek. Yes it does produce some excellent racing but to call it some of the best on earth consistently may be pushing it a bit from my watching experience over the years. I find BSB to be a far superior package in terms of racing and do not see enough of AMA or other countries to judge.

But absolutely agree that sponsorship within Australia is sadly lacking for all motorcycle sport and sadly I do not see it improving to quickly due to the image of motorcyclists protrayed within our ever bias media.

As for 8 rounds, arent 4 or 5 of those scheduled for PI this year (which IMO is a joke) but it is the first year with a new promoter and I hope he improves the package from where it was left over the next few years.



EDIT:
I notice that the number of PI rounds is now 2 which is reduced (thankfully).






Gaz
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Mick D @ Jul 18 2009, 06:47 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}><div class='quotemain'>Good point of debate... I'm curious - my personal opinion is that a poll would come out about 50/50 in terms of who cared/purchased branded products. I avoid them like the plague - I'm me, not some wannabe, nor do I feel the need to publicly pay tribute to riders (musicians or anyone else) I admire.


I am with you SoD.

I don't buy a product just because a particular person may advertise or claim that they use the product. I research for myself and purchase the product that best suits my requirements, whether that be a helmet, bike, gear or consumables.

I will admit that if I hear an advertisement for a product and it is a brand with whom I was unfamiliar then I may research that brand but just because CS, Rossie or whomever may use it does not mean that I will buy it. Nor will I buy a brand shirt or jacket because I may like that teams rider, I just don't operate that way.

I may well support a rider but that does not mean that I want to dressed like that rider, or behave like that rider, no I am myself and I make my own decisions. Being totally honest I do not know many people who support motorcycling who do go to the lengths of many team based supporters in football etc.

An interesting test woudl actually be to go to a favoutite bike haunt (in NSW, that could be the Halfway house, Mt White, Robertson etc) and count the team specific gear and I suspect that it would be 50/50 at the worst. The more I rack my fading mind in all my years riding I can only recall two guyst hat I have ridden with who have purchased gear of their favourite rider (1 x Doohan Replica Helmet, 1 Nolan CS replica) and in both cases the riders where already using those brands). Interesting discussion but I suspect wrong thread.





Garry
 
Re: the replica helmets; pick up a copy of Roadracing World and when you look through the photos from AMA races and club races there is always someone wearing a Nakano replica. Has to be Arai's biggest seller.

When I was club racing in the '70s and '80s virtually every rider who had an extra few bucks was wearing Spencer, Lawson, Mamola, Wes Cooley, Schwantz or Roberts replicas. The Roberts lids were the most popular then - because AGV helmets were so much cheaper than any other company.
 

Recent Discussions