Totally agree. Jack was a questionable signing to the factory duc. Imo he is the worst of the 4 Ducati riders. Bagnaia seems solid but I think Martin could be very special. He has been healthy for 3 races and shown amazing form. The way he is able to manage tires while being chased is better than most veteran riders. Also manages to put down scorching laps for quali on a regular basis. I think he has the most potential of any rider on the grid right now. I like Remy. He seems like a good kid with some serious speed on the track. Can't wait to see what he is capable of. We also have a couple Americans in the pipeline, but I can't help but feel that Roberts really blew his chance by not signing with Aprilia this year. Who new aprila was going to be decent this year though.
Here goes.
I actually don't see Jack as a questionable signing as for me he was the best available and had out-performed other options that would likely have fit within the dollar range that Ducati wanted plus he has potential and it was said he only wanted 1 year (and was on the Duke at the time)
I also see no real issues with a re-signing as has been done as at that point his results had been quite good with the failures being fixable - the old saying, 'you can teach a fast rider not to crash but you cannot teach a slow rider to be fast'.
Now that said, he needs to stop crashing.
I can cope with the fact that the tyres are an issue as all riders are having problems, but he needs to learn to ride within that component and stop throwing good results away
I have never felt that Jack is a title winner and I say that with openly bias eyes. Nope, to me he will win races, get some bloody good results but not win a title purely because I do not feel he is mature enough yet in race terms, and with his experience he has had chances to mature.
Next year is the make or break year as from all reports again it is a single year deal and without a close fought title battle it will be his last on a factory Ducati.
Said before in another post and meant it but Jack should have taken the Honda ride when it was said to be offered as I genuinely feel that there would be less pressure and expectations purely as the Aussie on the Ducati, there is pressure.
Sad to say from my side but I just do not see Jack as a champion but that said, he still has more race wins than many with longer careers
Edit to add:
I genuinely like Jack - I like that he is not robotic and scripted, he wears the heart on his sleeve, he gets emotional and seems genuinely about fun and having it.
But, this could also be the achilles heel to the whole package