Tamada: He is talented, last year he got a win (or 2?), but in the bumpy Brazilian tarmac the Bridgestones were an advantage, so it was difficult to judge his performance.
This year he is on Michelins like the rest of Honda riders, and he is usually the worst of them along with Bayliss which is not very good, although he has been injured twice this season and that affects the rider's confidence. The jury is still out on Tamada's case, so far I would rate him as good but not brilliant.
Hopkins: We can't really judge Hopkins because he is riding a piece of junk, although if we compare him with his teammate Roberts, he is usually faster than Roberts (who has been a World Champ) so obviously he's got the pace. I think he needs to improve mentally, he rides like if there was no tomorrow, and therefore crashes often, that's why Kenny has got more points.
Currently I rate him as good with the potential to be a winner in a near future if he gets the right bike and calms down a little bit.
Pedrosa: I think Pedrosa in terms of talent is right up there with Rossi, the only problem I see is if he will be able to handle a big fat bike like the RCV, because Dani only weights 50 Kg and is very little. Pedrosa, like Rossi, was very weak in wet conditions in the 125cc, now he is getting better and I expect him to be completely adapted to wet surface in a couple of years..