Motogp 2013 Round 3: Jerez

MotoGP Forum

Help Support MotoGP Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
woody996
3511561368131779

By your reasoning, every rider that overtakes and makes another rider alter their line in a corner has therefore completed an illegal move. I don't understand why Lorenzo turned into MM. He must have seen him as he was looking the right way. Sure MM's line wasn't perfect and he probably went in a little too hot but he still would have made it through the corner.


I think Lorenzo went too wide on his entry to the corner. Notwithstanding this, anyone can be passed in any corner if the choices for the competitor in prospect of being passed are to be punted or give way. This admittedly did work for Ayrton Senna over quite a lengthy career.


 


I make no claim to being a Rossi fan, but his passes are/were usually things of elegance and beauty.


 


As I have said, I don't have much problem with MM in actual races, he is obviously extremely rapid, and commendably game. The Willairot practice incident remains concerning though.
 
stiefel
3512011368199698

He does that a lot.


 


Well no .... buddy, hes a champ, and he is sought for his opinion.  We, on the other hand give our opinions just as much, with little to no expertise.  As many as there are riders and champs, there are varying opinions.  Are Stoner fans still upset with him, haha.
 
michaelm
3511941368192747

I think Lorenzo went too wide


 


This seems to be the number one justification for Marquez to barge through the corner.  It appears it was Lorenzo's fault that Marquez didn't apply the brakes properly.  
 
RaceJumkie is Scwantz, he just hires some dude to show up and drink and have a good time!
 
Kropotkin
3511641368132904

Noyes spoke to Mike Webb. Webb said if it had happened during FP3, or even QP2, Marquez would have got a punishment. This was the last corner of the last lap of the race. A little latitude is allowed, people are allowed to take risks, to try to beat the other guy. Marquez would have made the corner on his own, though he would have run wide and been slow. It was a legitimate last-lap attack, one which Lorenzo asked for by leaving the door open.


 


Thanks for clearing this up my fine friend.  So the rider would have been admonished for dangerous tactics (?) on the same track, but not during a race situation because...during a race, similar risk is allowed?  That’s a fantastic message. (sarcasm)  Okay…I must conclude they are not thinking about "safety" in their decision-making (not that they ever did).  Mat Oxley shared your cavalier sentiment by opening his contribution on your site ‘thanking race direction’ for not admonishing Marquez.  Let me say, I don’t think Marc should be “penalize” but certainly “warned”.  I suppose physics and unusual circumstances don’t collude during races…right?  Remind me when Sic’s fatal accident occurred, was that during a practice?


 
Kropotkin
3511641368132904



And there's the difference with Harada. Harada had the door shut. Capirossi did not brake. Note, not 'made a mistake in braking', but 'did not brake'. He t-boned Harada.


 


Incorrect!  There was a "gap", as you have recently describe this "space", or better yet, Harada, "left the door open" (which seems to be your recent justification).  Perhaps you need to look at the Harada-Capirossi incident again, Loris did not t-bone Harada, as his bike was "ahead" when contact occurred.  Maybe it was Harada's fault for not 'braking more' or 'standing his bike up to avoid contact' as you have accused Lorenzo of failing to do, because of course so much can be done on loaded up forks in a nano second of time...How you can describe this incident in such negative terms (which I agree with) while described Marc/Jlo incident in such lofty terms (you're crazy) is rather fascinating.  


 


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X47sTzsInOg


 


 


 


(Edit to add:  God has a sense of humor!  http://www.motocuatro.com/index.php/motogp/5923-jorge-lorenzo-y-marc-marquez-se-dan-la-mano-a-10000-metros-de-altura )  Lorenzo and Marquez happen to have the same flight, and as God would ordain it, they sat in the same row.  Hahaha.  Looks like they kissed and made up.
 
IMO (and I ready myself for Jums rebuttal) but Lorenzo went way wider than necessary and basically opened the door to wave an invite in the face of Marquez (ok, so Lorenzo has said he did not realise that Marquez was that close).


 


Well, last corner last lap and Marquez went for the gap somewhat, yes he does look to be in hot but to me the aerial shot shows that he was going to use a shallow line in, long past apex turn and power out (much like last corner Saschenring can be done). If Lorenzo turned there was going to be an inevitable collision and so it happened but in saying that I also say that if (a big IF) Lorenzo had known where Marquez was then he could have avoided the collision but that would likely have also cost him the drive he would have needed to stay in front of Marquez.


 


IMO, a racing incident with no harm, no foul so to speak.


 


To me, for a few years now people have been saying that the triumvirate of Lorenzo, Pedrosa and Stoner have been to polite and yet now, when the politeness is gone we ask for polite (not necessarily you Jums).


 


 


Of more interest to me has been the lack of discussion regarding post race behaviours ....


 


 


 


 


Edited typos
 
Gaz
3512361368227204

IMO (ans I ready myself for Jums rebuttal) but Lorenzo went way wider than necessary and basically opened the door to wave an invite in the face of Marquez (ok, so Lorenzo has said he did not realise that Marquez was that close).
 
Well, last corner last lap and Marquez went for the gap somewhat, yes he does look to be in hot but to me the aerial shot shows that he was going to use a shallow line in, long past apex turn and power out (much like last corner Saschenring can be done). If Lorenzo turned there was going to be an inevitable collision and so it happened but in saying that I also say that if (a big IF) Lorenzo had known where Marquez was then he could have avoided the collision but that would likely have also cost him the drive he would have needed to stay in front of Marquez.
 
IMO, a racing incident with no harm, no foul so to speak.
 
To me, for a few years now people have been saying that the triumvirate of Lorenzo, Pedrosa and Stoner have been to polite and yet now, when the politeness is good we ask for polite (not necessarily you Jums).
 
 
Of more interest to me has been the lack of discussion regarding post race behaviours ....
Nonononono. You don't understand. Marc Marquez went in with murder in his heart and attempted to kill Jorge Lorenzo. Lorenzo was lucky the limpet mines strapped to the outside of Marquez' fairing didn't go off, and they all crossed the line safely.
 
Nonononono. You don't understand. Marc Marquez went in with murder in his heart and attempted to kill Jorge Lorenzo. Lorenzo was lucky the limpet mines strapped to the outside of Marquez' fairing didn't go off, and they all crossed the line safely.

Thinking about it, it's the sort of reasoning from a personality engaged in by the boppers and boners, but on steroids . X did Y, I love X, therefore Y was bad, X is God.

A new form of crazy emerges!
 
Gaz
3512361368227204

IMO (ans I ready myself for Jums rebuttal) but Lorenzo went way wider than necessary and basically opened the door to wave an invite in the face of Marquez (ok, so Lorenzo has said he did not realise that Marquez was that close).

 

Well, last corner last lap and Marquez went for the gap somewhat, yes he does look to be in hot but to me the aerial shot shows that he was going to use a shallow line in, long past apex turn and power out (much like last corner Saschenring can be done). If Lorenzo turned there was going to be an inevitable collision and so it happened but in saying that I also say that if (a big IF) Lorenzo had known where Marquez was then he could have avoided the collision but that would likely have also cost him the drive he would have needed to stay in front of Marquez.

 

IMO, a racing incident with no harm, no foul so to speak.

 

To me, for a few years now people have been saying that the triumvirate of Lorenzo, Pedrosa and Stoner have been to polite and yet now, when the politeness is good we ask for polite (not necessarily you Jums).

 

 

Of more interest to me has been the lack of discussion regarding post race behaviours ....


Yes indeed mate, if I was Marc I would have told Jorge to shove that oscillating finger up his ....
 
BJ.C
3511901368188800

 

Is he still in Tassie, or has the lure of Melbourne been too strong?


I think he splits his time. Don't see him for ages, then he and his family are sitting next to you at the bar. He's not looking too flash these days. Skin's hanging off him a bit.
 
Talpa
3512591368247531

Yes indeed mate, if I was Marc I would have told Jorge to shove that oscillating finger up his ....


 


 


Talps, you're a bloody Queenslander mate, you would have put the finger right where it needed to be placed, no being nice about it.   :yeah:
 

Recent Discussions

Back
Top