- Joined
- Aug 30, 2009
- Messages
- 958
A few big assumptions in this thread which I don't think are right.
"Stoner can't develop a bike everyone can ride". I don't believe that we have enough evidence to show this. Stoner rode around the issues to get the results he did, unfortunately this doesn't tell us anything about his feedback given to Ducati or whether or not the feedback was good enough so that Ducati could make the right decisions, or whether or not Ducati just did it on their own.
Rossi and team have not yet fixed the Ducati so until they do, no credit can be taken for that regardless of his history in that respect. If they do fix it firstly for Rossi and then for the other Ducati riders, then credit will absolutely be due. Development of a bike is a huge part of Motogp, and this can be more important than being the quickest rider for the reason that a quick rider on a bucket of poo will struggle to consistently win.
Rossi wasn't given the order to go out and break his neck trying to get the thing round the track as quick as the Hondas, he was given the mandate to change the bike, develop it and make it into a consistent competitor for more than one rider. This will take time and, given his injury recovery, one would expect it to take more time.
Barry - Stoner is not the first rider to swap manufacturers and then win so I'm not sure why this is so conclusive for you, especially given the Honda is arguably in far better shape than the bike he left so you would expect an improvement in his performance.
"Stoner can't develop a bike everyone can ride". I don't believe that we have enough evidence to show this. Stoner rode around the issues to get the results he did, unfortunately this doesn't tell us anything about his feedback given to Ducati or whether or not the feedback was good enough so that Ducati could make the right decisions, or whether or not Ducati just did it on their own.
Rossi and team have not yet fixed the Ducati so until they do, no credit can be taken for that regardless of his history in that respect. If they do fix it firstly for Rossi and then for the other Ducati riders, then credit will absolutely be due. Development of a bike is a huge part of Motogp, and this can be more important than being the quickest rider for the reason that a quick rider on a bucket of poo will struggle to consistently win.
Rossi wasn't given the order to go out and break his neck trying to get the thing round the track as quick as the Hondas, he was given the mandate to change the bike, develop it and make it into a consistent competitor for more than one rider. This will take time and, given his injury recovery, one would expect it to take more time.
Barry - Stoner is not the first rider to swap manufacturers and then win so I'm not sure why this is so conclusive for you, especially given the Honda is arguably in far better shape than the bike he left so you would expect an improvement in his performance.