Help needed for info about SNS and Bridgestone switch.

MotoGP Forum

Help Support MotoGP Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Valentino Rossi’s Fiat Yamaha boss Davide Brivio has told MCN that the Italian is likely to remain on Michelin tyres for the 2008 MotoGP world championship.

Davide Brivio says he has told the 28-year-old Yamaha wants to continue with Michelin next season and not make a much rumoured switch to rivals Bridgestone.

Yamaha have been discussing with Bridgestone about a possible tyre deal for 2008, but with the Japanese manufacturer stating its intention to retain its current team’s for next season, such a move seems difficult at present.

Bridgestone boss Hiroshi Yamada has said extending its supply beyond 10 riders would be hard, and even Valentino Rossi admitted last week in Misano that a switch seemed ‘difficult.’

Michelin last week confirmed no deals were in place with Honda and Yamaha beyond the end of the current campaign, which has been a tough one for the French manufacturer.

Michelin has faced stinging criticism in some quarters having only won four of the opening 13 races in 2007.

But it seems they will be given one more year to pose a threat to Bridgestone with Brivio telling MCN he has had assurances of a renewed effort from Michelin.

“Now we think that Michelin can get back at the top level so we have said to Valentino that we want to continue with Michelin because we are confident that they can get back,” said Brivio, who confirmed thoughts of as Bridgestone switch.

“If we say that we never think to go Bridgestone for next year then me personally I wouldn’t be doing a good job in my position.

“We have to evaluate but you talk to the riders it doesn’t matter if its Bridgestone or Michelin, they just want the best and want what can allow them to win,” said Brivio, who denied some complaints from Valentino Rossi and Repsol Honda rider Dani Pedrosa in 2007 were just sour grapes as Ducati's Casey Stoner and Bridgestone’s success.

Davide Brivio said it was just crucial MotoGP got back some of the spectacular racing fans worldwide have become accustomed to after recent races in Brno, Laguna Seca and Sachsenring that even Dorna chief Carmelo Ezpeleta labelled ‘boring.’

“I can understand the viewpoint but Pedrosa and Valentino don’t care about politics.

“They know they can fight for the victory but they are not doing this, so they just want to get the package to be able to fight for the victory.

“They are trying to guess what they need and thinking what about if we do this, or what about if we change the tyre rule?” said Brivio.

Michelin, Bridgestone and Dunlop are currently negotiating modifications to the current tyre rule and further meetings will take place this weekend in Portugal for the Estoril MotoGP.

“My personal opinion is the current rule and is not so bad. But if we have the chance to adjust the rule we should,” said Brivio.

“At this moment I guess Bridgestone doesn’t want to change the rules. All we want is to bring back Michelin and Bridgestone at a competitive level.

“I like to see Stoner fighting with Pedrosa, (Nicky) Hayden, and Valentino and to have more competitive races. I believe if we think about changing the rule we should think on this target to create more balance,” said Davide Brivio.

While declaring his support for a tweak in the rules, Brivio said also that the solution also needed to come from improved development from Michelin.

He added: “It is true in order to cerate more balance that Michelin has to work more on development. If we change the tyre rule but we don’t change the development the situation could be exactly the same.

“We could have double the number of tyres, we can go testing in every circuit, but the important thing is to change something in the development.

“The important thing is how the development will be approached from now on. I don’t think it’s enough to change the rule.”

MotoGP: Valentino Rossi set to stay with Michelin for 2008 | MCN
 
Says the guy who enjoyed destroying the field so completely in 2002.

Valentino Rossi has branded the current racing in MotoGP as a ‘little boring.’

Speaking to MCN, the seven-times world champion has blamed tyres and electronics for killing MotoGP, and called on race bosses to make urgent changes to protect the premier class world championship as a spectacle.

Repsol Honda’s Dani Pedrosa and Marlboro Ducati’s Casey Stoner have won the last four races in embarrassingly one-sided fashion, and so bereft of overtaking and excitement that people are now likening MotoGP in 2007 to Formula One.

“This is the worst thing me. Before the races were more fun but now it is a little bit boring and this is the worst thing for me. The two big problems are tyres and electronics.

“We already spoke a lot to solve this problem but it is difficult. If we want a good show we have to make some changes because now there is a lot less overtaking. But for me it is more difficult to speak now I don’t win.

“I’m in a strange situation but it is the reality. Before the races were funnier. This year we see just one race with me, (Casey) Stoner and (Dani) Pedrosa fighting together. There has been no overtaking in the other races,” said Rossi, who goes into this weekend’s Estoril MotoGP in Portugal a massive 85-points adrift of Casey Stoner, with the Aussie able to wrap up the title if results go his way.

Valentino Rossi also admitted he was finding it hard to maintain his motivation. For the first time in his illustrious career Rossi is turning up for races knowing he is beaten before he’s even started.

“It is a difficult situation for me. It never happened in the past but it is even more difficult to fight when you know it is not possible to fight for the victory. But I will try,” he added.

MotoGP: Valentino Rossi admits MotoGP is a ?little boring? | MCN
 
Don't forget this...

Fiat Yamaha boss Davide Brivio has confirmed on the eve of the Estoril GP in Portugal this weekend that Valentino Rossi's factory YZR-M1 will definitely run on Michelin tyres in 2008.

With Michelin winning only four of the opening 13 races in 2007, there has been intense speculation that Rossi had been pushing Yamaha bosses to consider a switch to Bridgestone rubber next season.

But as expected Rossi and new team-mate Jorge Lorenzo will run on Michelin tyres in 2008, with Brivio confirming that Yamaha wouldn't be making a switch to Bridgestone, preferring instead to remain loyal to Michelin and try and develop a more competitive package to fight against Casey Stoner and Ducati.

Brivio also said that his personal view was to keep the current tyre allocation at 31 tyres per rider for a race weekend. An increase to 40 is currently under discussion and bosses from Michelin, Bridgestone and Dunlop met again tonight in the Estoril paddock to thrash out modifications to the rule.

Brivio said increasing the limit would not be the solution to ending the current dull racing in MotoGP, saying it was up to Michelin and Yamaha to work in tandem to develop over the winter.

"My personal opinion is that nothing should change in the tyre regulation. In this moment we have to work more, we have to test as much as we can this winter to improve our tyres and try to fight next year. There is a lot of discussion about trying to improve but we have to make sure that if we change something we are going in the right direction, otherwise its better not too change. I don't know if having a few more tyres in the allocation or having the possibility to test more will drastically change the situation. The situation might change drastically if we push much more on the development. I think we have a lot of homework to do," said Brivio, who was at pains to distance Yamaha and Rossi from rumours that both were piling pressure on Dorna to instigate a change to the current tyre rule.

"I think its better to leave everything as it and work much harder to improve our package. This is my opinion. Yamaha is not making the regulation and is not deciding anything about this. If they come up with a good solution that Michelin and Bridgestone agree then ok, but it has to be clear that its not a question that Yamaha or Valentino Rossi is asking for the rule changes, that is untrue," added Brivio.

Rossi said he agreed that the number of tyres should not increase, saying the issue at present with Michelin was 'quality and not quantity.'

MCN asked Rossi in a press debriefing this afternoon if he was happy with the decision to stick with Michelin and whether or not his preference had been to switch to Bridgestone.

He replied: "I think it will be Michelin next season." Asked by MCN if he was happy with that choice he added: "For you I am happy." Rossi confirmed that he will run the new pneumatic valve engine in Estoril, with one of his bikes running the new system when tomorrow's free practice starts. Yamaha denied to discuss specific details of the engine failure that ruled Rossi out of his home in Misano earlier this month, but confirmed it had been caused by a mechanical component failure in the bottom end. The problem has been discovered and the faulty component modified in Japan, said Brivio.

Estoril MotoGP: Valentino Rossi to stick with Michelin tyres in 2008 | MCN
 
And the river card...

Bridgestone boss Hiroshi Yamada believes Valentino Rossi has been the ringleader of a campaign to switch MotoGP to a one-make tyre rule in 2008.

Hiroshi Yamada admitted he was ‘very disappointed and shocked’ to learn that Dorna boss Carmelo Ezpeleta had proposed a one-make tyre rule, during last month’s Japanese MotoGP, with the plan greeted with fierce opposition by the three tyre manufacturers.

And he believes Valentino Rossi has used his considerable influence to get Dorna to propose such a radical rule change.

“I think the power of Rossi is very strong with Mr Ezpeleta. I believe he is the main reason for this,” said Yamada, who added it was too early to announce whether Bridgestone would bid for the exclusive contract.

What has infuriated Yamada even more is the rule would arguably penalise the Japanese factory more so than rivals Michelin and Dunlop.

Having spent millions on development, Bridgestone has emerged from high-profile disasters to become the dominant tyre brand in MotoGP.

He is upset that at the first hint of problems for their rivals, most notably Michelin duo Valentino Rossi and Dani Pedrosa, Dorna is proposing a radical rule change.

Yamada confirmed the reason Bridgestone had refused to supply tyres to Yamaha and Honda’s factory teams in 2008 was to ensure competition remained.

He was aware Michelin would quit if they lost Yamaha and Honda.

“I am very, very disappointed. Our intention was not to supply Honda and Yamaha to keep competition. This has not been decided yet but if they decide to go to one-make rule then I’m very disappointed.

“If we have no competition then I won’t have the same feeling again that I did in Motegi when we won the championship. We weren’t expecting such a situation.

“Now we have to discuss internally about what our response will be and how we will approach the situation,” Yamada told MCN.

Asked if Bridgestone could supply tyres to the entire MotoGP grid for a test session in Valencia on November 6, 2007 – when a decision would only be taken by the Grand Prix Commission in Sepang on October 20 – Yamada added: “This would be very difficult in that time frame.

“We have 10 riders this year but maybe we have to supply 19, and maybe even more for test riders. Doubling the capacity is normally impossible.”

MotoGP: Bridgestone blame Valentino Rossi for one-make tyre proposal | MCN
 
alentino Rossi seems certain to race on Bridgestone tyres next season even though a controversial one-make tyre rule won’t be implemented for 2008.

MCN understands the Italian will be the lone Yamaha rider on Bridgestone rubber next season, with new team-mate Jorge Lorenzo and Tech 3 duo Colin Edwards and James Toseland running Michelin tyres on their YZR-M1 800cc machines.

The shock revelation about Rossi and Bridgestone follows news that a one-make tyre rule seems certain to be rejected at a meeting of the Grand Prix Commission in Malaysia a week today (October 20).

That won’t stop Rossi though from getting his wish of dumping Michelin, with the 28-year-old expected to run on Bridgestone tyres in a split garage, with new team-mate Lorenzo to run on Michelin.

With Honda and Yamaha both being refused Bridgestone tyre deals in 2008 following requests made earlier this season, it looked likely that both factory teams would remain loyal to Michelin to avoid a one-make tyre rule being implemented.

But Rossi seems likely to strike a deal to exclusively run Bridgestone, while Dani Pedrosa will field Michelin tyres on his factory Honda RC212V contender.

Not even the promise of a huge increase in investment and resources has convinced Rossi to remain with Michelin, such is his desire to race on the same rubber as new world champion Casey Stoner.

In the front row press conference this afternoon in Australia, Rossi said it was still not decided what tyre brand he would be on next season. But he said that the option to run Bridgestone was still work in progress, hinting that he will be with the Japanese factory.

That’s despite Honda and Yamaha’s commitment to stay with Michelin, having initially voiced grave reservations to Dorna chief Carmelo Ezpeleta about remaining with the French brand.

“The situation is not very clear for us because we wait for Michelin to give a big effort next year to improve the situation, they understand a lot of mistakes this and especially with the new rule this year it was a bad surprise for Michelin. I think the French guys, in the head, the situation is not so bad but we had a lot of problems so we have to decide because we do not know exactly if it is possible to have Bridgestone. The situation is in progress, we have to decide, "said Rossi.

The news appeared to be a massive shock to Lorenzo, who sat alongside Rossi in the press conference.
He avoided the issue when asked, saying he was only concerned about his Dunlop tyres for tomorrow’s 250 race, where he can clinch his second successive world title.

Yamaha boss Davide Brivio told MCN no request had been submitted to Bridgestone to supply tyres exclusively to the seven-times world champion and no other Yamaha rider.

Bridgestone boss Hiroshi Yamada towed the same line, but he said increasing its current capacity by one more rider was achievable, particularly given that the rider involved is Rossi.

“I am very happy to hear Valentino wants to use Bridgestone tyres, “Yamada told MCN.

Australian MotoGP: Valentino Rossi set to race on Bridgestone in 2008 | MCN


The threat to quit...

Valentino Rossi’s Yamaha crew chief Jerry Burgess has backed the Italian over his recent scathing attack on the Japanese factory.

Rossi has threatened to quit Yamaha at the end of next season unless his demands for vast improvements in the performance of his 2008 YZR-M1 are met.

As well as being unhappy with the performance of Michelin tyres in 2007, which will see him move to Bridgestone rubber next season, the 28-year-old has now rounded on Yamaha after his comprehensive defeat to Ducati rival Casey Stoner.

Valentino Rossi’s YZR-M1 800cc machine has been left trailing behind Ducati, and last week he demanded big improvements, saying Yamaha owed him after the success he gave the Japanese factory with back-to-back world titles in 2004 and 2005.

Aussie Jerry Burgess has supported Valentino Rossi in his plea to Yamaha and he said Yamaha engineers were acutely aware that they are under severe pressure to bridge the performance gap to Ducati’s impressive GP7.

Jerry Burgess told MCN: “Valentino is within his rights to say that. We’ve said the same thing in our team meetings.

“It’s obvious when you see it on the speed charts, it would better to be in front. I think even Yamaha realise they have to do something.

“But when you physically can’t run the 100 metres in nine seconds, you can’t do it until you learn how to do it and it might not be an overnight thing.

“I don’t think there is a person at Yamaha who doesn’t think we have to build the best motorcycle. We are trying to do that.

“What we’ve needed this year is a better motorcycle in terms of top speed and we need to start focussing on some of that side of it. Every company needs to improve their horsepower.

“Every rider will be asking for more horsepower, and I bet Casey is even asking for more.”

Valentino Rossi even suggested he wanted Yamaha to dump decades of tradition by scrapping its in-line four-cylinder motor to develop and race with a V4 like rivals Ducati, Honda and Suzuki.

But Jerry Burgess added: “I don’t think he’s got enough engineering knowledge to make that sort of statement, but that doesn’t mean he’s wrong or right.

“It means having all the factors available to you and even I couldn’t say that. The race departments do not drive bike companies.

“The race departments are there to enhance the marketing department, that’s the important thing.”

Sepang MotoGP: Jerry Burgess backs Valentino Rossi over Yamaha demands | MCN
 
Yamaha is expected to officially confirm today in Valencia that Valentino Rossi will ditch Michelin tyres and race on Bridgestone rubber in the 2008 MotoGP world championship.

In a deal largely orchestrated by Dorna boss Carmelo Ezpeleta, Rossi will be confirmed as the lone Yamaha rider on Bridgestone tyres next season, with Fiat team-mate Jorge Lorenzo on Michelin rubber.

Yamaha boss Masao Furusawa strongly hinted at a special technical briefing of the 2007 YZR-M1 last night in the Valencia paddock that as expected, Rossi would be on Bridgestone’s in a move exclusively revealed by MCN last month in Phillip Island.
MCN understands the deal will be confirmed after this afternoon’s 30-lap Valencia GP.

In another twist to the long-running saga, Michelin were to block Rossi from testing Bridgestone tyres until a three-day test session in Jerez later this month.
That was to be the earliest opportunity the Fiat Yamaha rider would get to assess Bridgestone rubber, with Michelin refusing to release him from a contract to begin testing on Tuesday in Valencia.

But the situation has become largely irrelevant with Rossi’s broken right hand meaning he wouldn’t have been able to test in Valencia anyway, and most likely he wouldn’t have recovered in time to test in Sepang on November 15. He suffered three fractures in his right hand after a huge qualifying crash yesterday afternoon.
Yamaha’s contract with Michelin doesn’t expire until the end of the month, and discussions have been on going about an early release for Rossi to let him test in Valencia and then in a three-day session in Malaysia.

But furious at the scathing criticism from Rossi in 2007, Michelin was to block Rossi from making an immediate switch to rivals Bridgestone after tomorrow’s Valencia GP.
Yamaha bosses submitted a formal request to Michelin to get Rossi released. That was turned down, meaning that Rossi would not have been able to test Bridgestone tyres for the first time until 2008 in a test in Malaysia when the seven-week testing ban ends on January 20.

A compromise was to let Rossi make his Bridgestone debut in Jerez at the end of November, which is the reason why he announced on Thursday that he was unable to participate in the Rally of Great Britain. He had initially been cleared by Yamaha to drive a Subaru, but was then asked to withdraw from the rally to attend the Jerez test, which takes place at the same time.

The situation is nothing new for the 28-year-old Italian. When he agreed to join Yamaha at the end of 2003, Honda blocked him from testing the YZR-M1 until January 2004.

Valencia MotoGP: Yamaha poised to confirm Bridgestone deal for Valentino Rossi | MCN
 
The end...

As was revealed by MCN last month in Phillip Island, Valentino Rossi has today confirmed he will switch to Bridgestone tyres in 2008.

An official announcement has just been made by Yamaha in Valencia, confirming that the Italian will run as the lone YZR-M1 rider on Bridgestone rubber, with Rossi’s Fiat Yamaha team-mate using Michelin.

Rossi admitted he first pushed to dump Michelin after his poor performance in the Laguna Seca GP at the end of July.

An initial request by Yamaha in August was turned down by Bridgestone, which then prompted a huge political wrangle.

Dorna boss Carmelo Ezpeleta got involved and it was his intervention and subsequent pressure on Bridgestone to supply just for Rossi that saw an agreement reached last Wednesday.

Speaking after another disastrous day in Valencia today, where Rossi lost second in the championship after retiring with what he believes was engine problem while lying 14th, the seven-times world champion said: “In the last two years I have had a lot of problem with the tyres, and now it is difficult for me to ride and trust to the maximum the Michelins. So I am very happy about this choice. We have to see the performance next year – we try when I am fit in Jerez at the end of the month. I have to say a big thank you to Michelin because we won five championships in a row and it was a great, great story. But I am happy to change, a lot.”

Rossi will debut Bridgestone tyres in Jerez later this month, with Michelin refusing to release him from a contract to begin testing on Tuesday in Valencia.

But the situation has become largely irrelevant with Rossi’s broken right hand meaning he wouldn’t have been able to test in Valencia anyway, and most likely he wouldn’t have recovered in time to test in Sepang on November 15. Yamaha’s contract with Michelin doesn’t expire until the end of the month, and discussions have been on going about an early release for Rossi to let him test in Valencia and then in a three-day session in Malaysia.

But furious at the scathing criticism from Rossi in 2007, Michelin was to block Rossi from making an immediate switch to rivals Bridgestone after tomorrow’s Valencia GP.
Yamaha bosses submitted a formal request to Michelin to get Rossi released. That was turned down, meaning that Rossi would not have been able to test Bridgestone tyres for the first time until 2008 in a test in Malaysia when the seven-week testing ban ends on January 20.

A compromise was to let Rossi make his Bridgestone debut in Jerez at the end of November, which is the reason why he announced on Thursday that he was unable to participate in the Rally of Great Britain. He had initially been cleared by Yamaha to drive a Subaru, but was then asked to withdraw from the rally to attend the Jerez test, which takes place at the same time.

Rossi started today’s 30-lap race with three broken bones in his right hand, and he bravely rode to try and stop Dani Pedrosa from snatching second place in the championship. With Pedrosa running away at the front, Rossi only needed to finish 15th to claim second, but he retired on lap 18 after an engine problem struck at the first corner.

Rossi was livid with the failure of his YZR-M1, and he said:” “I have no words. For sure, after today, I can say that it’s not just a matter of misfortune. I did everything I could in order to be on the grid today, because I wanted to try and confirm my second place in the championship, which I think I deserved. I was riding very fast, even though my bike was not perfect. When I got into 14th place, I told myself that my task was done, but I was feeling quite good and I wanted to try to pass some more riders. Unfortunately however I felt that I had a problem with my bike and I was forced to come in. Now we are checking the data to understand what happened, because at the moment it’s not so clear. I will need 20 days to fix my hand and then I will be back in Jerez to start my winter testing programme.”

Valencia MotoGP: Valentino Rossi confirms Bridgestone tyre switch | MCN
 
Top work, JPS.
I've been trying to dig up the reports from late 2007 that showed massive drops in viewer numbers over that season....to no avail.
Care to try your hand at it?
 
Top work, JPS.
I've been trying to dig up the reports from late 2007 that showed massive drops in viewer numbers over that season....to no avail.
Care to try your hand at it?

Thanks!

I'll take a look and see what I can find.

What were you looking for, TV ratings or spectator attendance? Or both?
 
When you look at all of that, it's pretty damning evidence about Rossi's hold over MotoGP at a particularly critical juncture.

Many people laughed at the notion Rossi holds considerable sway over GP, but the Bridgestone chief knew exactly what kind of hold Rossi had over GP. That's to say nothing of the unprecedented decision to allow Rossi to run Bridgestones while his teammate had to run Michelin tires. There has never been another instance of such a thing happening in any top tier race series where one teammate was running one tire manufacturer, and the other had a different one.

But the allowance for the switch was made purely on commercial considerations, which was the belief that GP could only succeed if Rossi was competitive. Stoner from Dorna's perspective was bad for business....especially when he was beating the golden child down. Nicky Hayden winning in 2006 could have been chalked up to luck, but Stoner demolishing Rossi in a way that had never been seen was never going to sit well with Dorna. Hence the massive push to get him onto the Bridgestones for 2008. Michelin didn't much help the situation because of their woeful unpreparedness for the 2007 season. They misread the situation, and how detrimental the Saturday Night Special ban would turn out to be for them. But instead of reloading for 2008, Rossi threatened to quit till Ezpeleta stepped in at the 11th hour to broker a deal for him only.

Rossi's narrative was that Michelin started letting him down in 2006, and did even worse in 2007. His reaction seems particularly harsh when he just barely missed the 2006 title, and really was only beaten badly by one rider in 2007. He was targeting a record points score in the 2007 pre-season with 300+, only to find himself third. But the bigger story is that he was happy in 2005 and earlier when he claimed the 5 successive titles. The 2005 Michelin tires had a lot of grip, more so than what the Repsol Honda of Max Biaggi could handle, resulting in chatter that he couldn't deal with. Yet the Yamaha and Rossi by proxy had no issues with this. In fact there's a history of Rossi having the ability to ride high grip tires for all of his titles. He only started complaining about grip in 2006, and really started complaining about it in 2007....which always struck me as strange for a guy who has long been touted as a phenomenal low-grip rider...Jerez 2016 was the latest example of it.

In any event, he's a guy who has long believed it is his god-given right to have superior equipment from bike to tires, and never reacts well when those things are not delivered.
 
When you look at all of that, it's pretty damning evidence about Rossi's hold over MotoGP at a particularly critical juncture.

Many people laughed at the notion Rossi holds considerable sway over GP, but the Bridgestone chief knew exactly what kind of hold Rossi had over GP. That's to say nothing of the unprecedented decision to allow Rossi to run Bridgestones while his teammate had to run Michelin tires. There has never been another instance of such a thing happening in any top tier race series where one teammate was running one tire manufacturer, and the other had a different one.

But the allowance for the switch was made purely on commercial considerations, which was the belief that GP could only succeed if Rossi was competitive. Stoner from Dorna's perspective was bad for business....especially when he was beating the golden child down. Nicky Hayden winning in 2006 could have been chalked up to luck, but Stoner demolishing Rossi in a way that had never been seen was never going to sit well with Dorna. Hence the massive push to get him onto the Bridgestones for 2008. Michelin didn't much help the situation because of their woeful unpreparedness for the 2007 season. They misread the situation, and how detrimental the Saturday Night Special ban would turn out to be for them. But instead of reloading for 2008, Rossi threatened to quit till Ezpeleta stepped in at the 11th hour to broker a deal for him only.

Rossi's narrative was that Michelin started letting him down in 2006, and did even worse in 2007. His reaction seems particularly harsh when he just barely missed the 2006 title, and really was only beaten badly by one rider in 2007. He was targeting a record points score in the 2007 pre-season with 300+, only to find himself third. But the bigger story is that he was happy in 2005 and earlier when he claimed the 5 successive titles. The 2005 Michelin tires had a lot of grip, more so than what the Repsol Honda of Max Biaggi could handle, resulting in chatter that he couldn't deal with. Yet the Yamaha and Rossi by proxy had no issues with this. In fact there's a history of Rossi having the ability to ride high grip tires for all of his titles. He only started complaining about grip in 2006, and really started complaining about it in 2007....which always struck me as strange for a guy who has long been touted as a phenomenal low-grip rider...Jerez 2016 was the latest example of it.

In any event, he's a guy who has long believed it is his god-given right to have superior equipment from bike to tires, and never reacts well when those things are not delivered.

There will never be a smoking gun on him threatening to quit if he didn't get the Bridgestones, but that would be of a piece with the rest of this, and also with his display of entitlement at the end of the 2015 season.

What I don't think is proven is that the race day special tyres gave him a significant advantage over the other top Michelin runners, although it is pretty definite he had significant input into their formulation. I keep coming back to Max and Sete never complaining about VR having a tyre advantage, which would be rather out of character particularly for Max.

This is all the reverse of the argument in 2007, which was wall to wall complaining by Rossi fans about Stoner's massive advantages. As I have said, I have no problem recognising all of Rossi's titles, perhaps with Povol's caveat on the 2008 season if the Stoner/Ducati tyre was taken away from them (I think Rossi would have won anyway, Stoner was in dire straights mathematically post LS08), but the other title winners in his era deserve the same recognition.
 
There will never be a smoking gun on him threatening to quit if he didn't get the Bridgestones, but that would be of a piece with the rest of this, and also with his display of entitlement at the end of the 2015 season.

What I don't think is proven is that the race day special tyres gave him a significant advantage over the other top Michelin runners, although it is pretty definite he had significant input into their formulation. I keep coming back to Max and Sete never complaining about VR having a tyre advantage, which would be rather out of character particularly for Max.

This is all the reverse of the argument in 2007, which was wall to wall complaining by Rossi fans about Stoner's massive advantages. As I have said, I have no problem recognising all of Rossi's titles, perhaps with Povol's caveat on the 2008 season if the Stoner/Ducati tyre was taken away from them (I think Rossi would have won anyway, Stoner was in dire straights mathematically post LS08), but the other title winners in his era deserve the same recognition.

One of the articles I posted explicitly mentions him threatening to quit. Not sure if you missed that one.

The race day specials were giving him an advantage if you consider that Michelin only had Yamaha as their test team in 2007, while Bridgestone was pulling data from a number of teams beyond just Ducati. Povol posted an article where Burgess talked about the data from Yamaha going to Michelin for the tires before the SNS tires were banned.

BTW, Casey said after 2008, the Bridgestone tires became progressively worse, and required more effort to get heat into the carcass, something the Ducati did not do well at all compared to the Honda. He mentioned working heat into the carcass required extremely deep braking into corners. Who even to this day is considered to be the best late braker in GP? Rossi.

I linked to a Kropo article where he talks about the chatter of Biaggi's Repsol Honda due to too much grip in the tire for the bike in 2005....something the Yamaha had no issues with. You assume Biaggi would have been the first to complain, but you also are ignoring the fact that a tire being made with a certain bike/rider in mind had never been done before, so the thought would have seemed to ridiculous to Biaggi. After all, you're a good example in that you yourself have difficulty accepting this notion...so is it that much of a stretch that Biaggi wouldn't have believed something was going on? If anything, a tire having too much grip is the inverse problem of what most riders experience. For rigging purposes, going with more grip rather than less grip is a smarter move. Kind of an ingenious way to hide it...especially when you consider the 2001 Honda that Rossi won the title on was using a softer compound than any other bike could use for race distance.
 
The article I recall was TV viewing numbers dropping in 07...

I'll start looking tomorrow and see if I can nail anything down. It's been mentioned everywhere viewership was plummeting, and GP was being unfavorably compared to F1 with the lack of excitement. I'm sure the viewership drop was more of VR's fans tuning out than anything, but it'd be enough to make Dorna unhappy.
 
Well done JPS.

Isn't it amazing how all of this gets easily lost or forgotten, yet it was all out there for anyone to see! These are public reports, one can only imagine the content that has gone secret, out of the public eye. There is absolutely no doubt Rossi's career records are artificially enhanced! The tires dictated wins hence championships and the truth is Rossi had utter control of it.

They (Dorna-Rossi, let's face it this is a single entity) got caught with their pants down with Bridgestone. The system was so rigged that they engineered into it a failure by allowing Dunlop and Bridgestone to make it appear there was a tire war while Rossi was racking up ........ championships. Unbeknownst to Dorna-Rossi, the Japanese were slowing working their assess off to make a superior product that was stable everywhere months in advance. They (Dorna-Rossi) didn’t recognize it because it seemed their grasp on tires and titles was so complete, paying no mind to Bridgestone's quiet progress in 2004, 05, 06.

In 2006 it should have set off alarm bells, but the happenstance of the Catalunya GP's disastrous carnage masked the future repercussions behind Ducati-Bridgestone's hard work, which incidentally also benefited Suzuki and Kawasaki. They confidently banned SNS for 2007. Ducati were surely not going to win with their 4th choice "crashy" Stoner. Like Leicester City, absolutely nobody saw the perfect storm coming...well at least those not paying attention. (In 2006, I knew Rossi’s record was a farce and I said as much at the time. But who would believe it?) Like Leicester's run of 10 wins the previous year, everyone was distracted wilst focused on the sensational duel between Rossi and the massive underdog Hayden. Lost in the underlying accomplishments of the Valencia race, perhaps obstructed by the Yellow smoke, two BRIDGESTONE shod Ducatis stood on the podium, one a wildcard.

Surely Rossi would resume his artificial domination the next year, 2006 was written off as "The Fluke", so much was the championship universally disparaged, even by Honda themselves, prompting Nicky Hayden to display a message on his leathers "Numbers Don't Lie". The ultimate irony being, Valentino's numbers certainly do lie!

So caught out by the hard work of Bridgestone and their clients, that Rossi started to moan and whine about his tire advantage that had evaporated when the Saturday Night Special tires (which had previously provided him with such obscene supremacy) were gone. Dorna-Rossi hadn't anticipated the consequence because as is typically of such corrupt systems, often the brazen domination leads to lackadaisical mistakes reminiscent of FIFA's recent debacle. Unlike FIFA though, MotoGP being a niche sport with little to no actual global scrutiny, operates in a dictatorship on what amounts to a taxes haven island. It can impose and changed the rules at will, as long as it benefits Valentino Rossi. That is because the spectator, 99.99% of all involved go along with it. That overwhelming fanbase includes the supposed "journalists" reporting on the preceedings. Honda themselves are trumped by Dorna-Rossi as the canceled release of telemetry illustrated! At the Valencia 2015 press conference which had been convened specifically to release damageing data turned into an astonishing display of Dorna-Rossi's power! Those paying attention to the clash of power politics, watched in astonishment as Honda's Suppo apologized having to submit to the imposed gag order--when two powers collided, Rossi’s interested reined supreme!

What happened next in 2008 has effected MotoGP profoundly, it led manufacturers to exit the championship, and eventually even the retirement of one of the greatest talents of the sport can be traced to the Bridgestone Debacle of 2008. The reports are here on this thread, neatly assembled to remind us how Dorna first coerced Bridgestone to accept Rossi and only Rossi under the threat of a single tire supplier proposal, then executing the proposal a year later. The work that Ducati, Suzuki, and Kawasaki had done with their partnership with Bridgestone was summarily destroyed. And for what? Read again the reports, the clear answer is there, it was for the benefit of the viewing public that demand a restoration to Rossi's ascendance. As they say, if ever you want executives of a company to react to your demands, you hit them in the pocketbook. That is the rationale for boycotts, which the Yellow fans were executing by turning off the channel. No Rossi, no interest, no TV revenue. This is what was reported in one of the above articles, they were "leaving in droves" (Yellow droves). With the threat of Rossi quiting, the sense of urgency was clear, 2006-07 were years that could not and would not be tolerated or repeated. Rossi needed his TIRE advantage back, after all it was the theme of his whining, moaning, and threats. 2008, the Bridgestone changed so dramatically that the reining champion Casey Stoner requested to use the 2007 spec tires, a request which was denied. How embarrassing might it have been for all involved, Bridgestone's deal to provide Rossi a more suitable tire would be exposed with Stoner winning on 07 tires, and for Dorna, the risk of Rossi openly signaling to his fans that they should not be happy with Dorna was not a risk they were about to test. Afterall, when Rossi points out a villain, his fans act immediately voicing their displeasure. The lessons of Max Biaggi and Sete Gibernau becoming the object of the fanbase's hate was plenty clear to executives like Carmelo Ezpeleta who's entire mission is to maximize profit NOT (like man erroneously believe) to create an authentic competition! (Read this last sentence again until its profound truth sinks in). It bears repeating, Dorna's job is NOT to make a fair competition, but rather to increase the VALUE of the business, that has meant the utter promotion of Valentino Rossi!

Carmelo has understood and been aware, you don't want Rossi pointing his finger at you and declaring--he is to be hated. This is still true, one only need to revisit the interview he had in his office recently when he explained why Race Direction needed to be overhauled. No, no it wasn't because they were/are incompetent. 'Improvement' was not the impetus for the change; but rather their association with Dorna! Why? Because Rossi made it clear, they were the bad guys who unfair imposed an unjust penalty on him; where three-quarters of a million people sprung into action. Carmelo listened to their collective yellow voice, Race Direction had to be disassociated with Dorna, because if not then the threat of Yellow droves tuning out was a real crisis. It is no different today, except the booing of Lorenzo and Marquez is of no consequence to Carmelo Ezpeleta, his interest is TV revenue, and if Rossi fans are not happy, they turn off the TV. That is a big problem for Dorna and its financial interest. Is it any wonder Carmelo acted as Rossi's sport agent to coerce Yamaha Marketing Department to override the racing team's desire not to work with the man?

The articles JP posted are for posterity of the Bridgestone Debacle. An episode that had profound effect on the championship. However, very little was reported on the massive advantage Rossi enjoyed under the SNS era. This is true for various reasons:

1. SNS Michelin tiered tire system that was largely misunderstood and universally accepted as equitable.

2. The journalists corps has always been an extension of the fanbase, in reality it does not exist independently of the subject they are tasked to report.

3. Michelin were secretive about how the tier system was implemented. Trade secrets are guarded. There is no governing statue for transparency.

4. The SNS era proved very valuable to the promoters of the series, who used the Michelin tier system effectively to increase the value through the cult figure that began to emerge, a fanbase that gravitated to and became unique in the world of sport.

5. The sophistication of Dorna, the promoters, has increased significantly, employing modern marketing principles and the unique culture of Rossi worship as the single most important property to enhance viewership value translated into TV revenue.

6. The promoter Dorna has never had the authenticity of the contest as its primary interest, but rather increasing the value of viewership for their own pay per view platform, TV contracts, and the interests of venues to attract spectators (consider this is the only way venues recoup the absorbent sanctioning fees imposed by Dorna).

7. The property of Rossi The Brand is real and powerful, it has effectively eclipsed any remnant of fair competition. This reality is illustrated in the perversion of what is right and wrong, what is possible and impossible, what is fair and decent, including the very meaning of words. When a winner of a race is believed to have helped the runner up, that is perversion of the meaning of "helping." When riders obviously move out of the way and us called "respect" as they did in Valencia for Rossi, wilst not being able to pass is "proof" of cheating. When a man serves his penalty but is dubbed a 'lap of honor' the opposite of the meaning, the perversion has reached its zenith.

Content Warning: Look ....... (.)(.)
 
What I don't think is proven is that the race day special tyres gave him a significant advantage over the other top Michelin runners, although it is pretty definite he had significant input into their formulation.

My dear friend, I've read you repeat this point many times, I struggle to reconcile how it's possible for you not to see the obvious obscene advantage. Don't take my word for it, listen to Casey Stoner on the subject!



"They can moan and whinge about it as much as they want but it shows they have had such an advantage in the past and this season they cannot bring a tyre in just for the race." Casey Stoner

How you my dear Mike refuse to concede the fact the SNS provided an obscene advantage is quite confusing to me. Surely you don't need the same kind of "proof" that would be impossible to register for the obvious reason that it was by design not openly transparent! The evidence is abundant.
 
Last edited:
One of the articles I posted explicitly mentions him threatening to quit. Not sure if you missed that one.

The race day specials were giving him an advantage if you consider that Michelin only had Yamaha as their test team in 2007, while Bridgestone was pulling data from a number of teams beyond just Ducati. Povol posted an article where Burgess talked about the data from Yamaha going to Michelin for the tires before the SNS tires were banned.

BTW, Casey said after 2008, the Bridgestone tires became progressively worse, and required more effort to get heat into the carcass, something the Ducati did not do well at all compared to the Honda. He mentioned working heat into the carcass required extremely deep braking into corners. Who even to this day is considered to be the best late braker in GP? Rossi.

I linked to a Kropo article where he talks about the chatter of Biaggi's Repsol Honda due to too much grip in the tire for the bike in 2005....something the Yamaha had no issues with. You assume Biaggi would have been the first to complain, but you also are ignoring the fact that a tire being made with a certain bike/rider in mind had never been done before, so the thought would have seemed to ridiculous to Biaggi. After all, you're a good example in that you yourself have difficulty accepting this notion...so is it that much of a stretch that Biaggi wouldn't have believed something was going on? If anything, a tire having too much grip is the inverse problem of what most riders experience. For rigging purposes, going with more grip rather than less grip is a smarter move. Kind of an ingenious way to hide it...especially when you consider the 2001 Honda that Rossi won the title on was using a softer compound than any other bike could use for race distance.
It says he threatened to quit Yamaha at the end of the next year, which was probably the end of the contract. The "smoking gun" that I meant was VR threatening Carmelo with quitting GP bike racing, and Carmelo forcing Bridgestone to supply him, which was rumoured at the time, and which I am certainly not dismissing.

I remember all this at the time, Rossi certainly pushed for the pneumatic engine which was introduced early with a view to the 2008 season and was the engine that didn't finish the race in one of your reports, and I also recall the stuff about his engineering opinion in regard to Yamaha possibly needing to change to a V4.
 
Last edited:
My dear friend, I've read you repeat this point many times, I struggle to reconcile how it's possible for you not to see the obvious obscene advantage. Don't take my word for it, listen to Casey Stoner on the subject!



"They can moan and whinge about it as much as they want but it shows they have had such an advantage in the past and this season they cannot bring a tyre in just for the race." Casey Stoner

How you my dear Mike refuse to concede the fact the SNS provided an obscene advantage is quite confusing to me. Surely you don't need the same kind of "proof" that would be impossible to register for the obvious reason that it was by design not openly transparent! The evidence is abundant.
I have no trouble believing Dorna/Carmelo deliberately set out to hamper Casey Stoner, you actually considered me a conspiracy theorist in regard to that at one time.

The question is whether the race day special tyres exclusively catered to Rossi, or whether they were more a "control" tyre for all the top Michelin runners, as J4rn0 and before him Babelfish contend/contended. I have a somewhat open mind on that, but it seems likely that they usually suited Rossi while whether they suited others is more uncertain.
 
Where was Rossi going to go for 2008 if he quit Yamaha? He was persona non grata at Honda. Ducati wasn't about to .... anything up with Stoner winning the title. He never would have settled for Suzuki or Kawasaki. A threat to quit Yamaha was very much a threat to quit MotoGP at that time.
 

Recent Discussions

Back
Top